GWS GIANTS AFL Fantasy/Supercoach questions - 2015 edition

[Danny88]

I would think Whitfield AND smith could push their scores onward and upward this year

Both will see time through the guts and both will kick goals

 

[Quazza]

would I be right to assume you guys all have Toby Greene in your side?

 

[Bogan Juniors]

No...some will have him but more a DT player than SC. I would think Treloar & Ward are more popular. amongst GWS fans. Griffen is interesting because of his price, All 4 will be reliable I think but I would & will only have 1 of them (my heart would like more)

 

[Quazza]

No...some will have him but more a DT player than SC. I would think Treloar & Ward are more popular. amongst GWS fans. Griffen is interesting because of his price, All 4 will be reliable I think but I would & will only have 1 of them (my heart would like more)

yer I was talking DT (sorry should have stipulated that). His last 5 weeks last season were massive

 

[Determinant]

yer I was talking DT (sorry should have stipulated that). His last 5 weeks last season were massive

He is a DT player, his DE can't support SC scoring

 

[McRobie]

He is a DT player, his DE can't support SC scoring

I disagree, look at the last 6-7 games of the year last year, monster SC scores. Ive got him and Trealor both. IM keen on Devon Smith as well, do we think he will average between 100-110?
Also Jeremy Cameron fully fit could average 85 surely? thinking of some quick cash.

 

[Determinant]

I disagree, look at the last 6-7 games of the year last year, monster SC scores. Ive got him and Trealor both. IM keen on Devon Smith as well, do we think he will average between 100-110?
Also Jeremy Cameron fully fit could average 85 surely? thinking of some quick cash.

Look at our outs at the time.
I am happy for you to pick him and jc in ssupercoach one less I have to beat.

 

[McRobie]

Look at our outs at the time.
I am happy for you to pick him and jc in ssupercoach one less I have to beat.

So your saying Greene, Smith and Trealor will prob ave less than last year as more are fit?

 

[Determinant]

So your saying Greene, Smith and Trealor will prob ave less than last year as more are fit?

Specifically I am saying that at the time Greene scored well we had significant SC scorers out.
They are back for round 1, Whitfield, Coniglio, Scully, Hampton. then we add Griffen and natural progression for the whole team.
Add into context that GWS scored more SC points than their opposition whilst being beaten so there are not a lot of extra points to go around.

I love my team, but I would not pick any GWS mids in SC, they are too even.

 

[McRobie]

Specifically I am saying that at the time Greene scored well we had significant SC scorers out.
They are back for round 1, Whitfield, Coniglio, Scully, Hampton. then we add Griffen and natural progression for the whole team.
Add into context that GWS scored more SC points than their opposition whilst being beaten so there are not a lot of extra points to go around.

I love my team, but I would not pick any GWS mids in SC, they are too even.

hmm its a really good point, I thought I had some uniques going on there but now I feel to scared to pick them.

 

[eth-dog]

Will Griffen or Ward get the tag?

 

[nameless]

So having both Ward and Griffen in my SC would be a mistake?

 

[jakemelksham17]

Starting to consider shaw in DT, do you guys think that this year he can be actually be considered as a real premium that can average 90+ ? Cheers

 

[Danny88]

I've got shaw too... I think he can achieve that. He naturally gets a lot of the ball and we are increasingly chipping the ball around in the back half to set up going forward so I can see him getting some cheap points that way

 

[Yellow Feathers]

My boy Bugg has been named in centre!

What's his JS like, guys? And will he get much time in the midfield?

 

[Werewolf]

Who is second in line with rucks - is it Downie or Phillips? And will they get any games? Thanks and good luck tomorrow

 

[Scully2Folau]

Who is second in line with rucks - is it Downie or Phillips? And will they get any games? Thanks and good luck tomorrow

Probably Phillips for mine, although Downie was named as emergency for round 1.

At this stage it's not highly likely they'll get games if Mumford is fit and McCarthy is in as the 3rd tall forward with Cameron and Tomlinson. That could change but we've favoured one genuine ruck for the most part when Mumford's in (see Giles not getting a game after Mummy came back from injury last year)

 

[Double the Fist]

So, who will be sub today guys? Surely not McCarthy?

 

[Determinant]

So, who will be sub today guys? Surely not McCarthy?

I'm thinking JK, it wont be Treloar, Hampton more likely to get red and a KPF would be unusual though not unheard of

 

[Double the Fist]

I'm thinking JK, it wont be Treloar, Hampton more likely to get red and a KPF would be unusual though not unheard of

Thankyou again for being generous with your time.
I have Cam McCarthy starting in my SC squad. He showed some promise, and you have a good draw so I hope he's not sub. He could kick 4 today!!!!

 

[Danny88]

I'll be spitting chips if Kelly gets the best

Kid is a star and has earned a start imo

Hampton gets it if I'm in charge... Average preseason imo but canbe an impact player... Great vest option

 

[captainMyCaptain]

I'll be spitting chips if Kelly gets the best

Kid is a star and has earned a start imo

Hampton gets it if I'm in charge... Average preseason imo but canbe an impact player... Great vest option

Cogs has been named in the vest

 

[dyii22]

Disappointed with Griffen's output... do you guys expect him to get tagged week in week out?

 

[Determinant]

Disappointed with Griffen's output... do you guys expect him to get tagged week in week out?

From a SC/DT point of view?
They have to tag one of them, this week it was Griffen, was effective enough that it might be him again next week, but if so it frees up the others.

 

[Heater92]

Hoskin-Elliott a chance this week boys?