WSYD GWS Just Has To Do Some Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Mar 20, 2002
24,571
25,490
Mosman Village
AFL Club
Carlton
Having watched the Giants closely today, there is only one conclusion that I can arrive at, they have to be very active in this year's trade period. They will be a very good football club in a few years time but they are not going to be genuinely competitive as quickly as Gold Coast has come on.

All of their players have plenty of skill but at present, are still a couple of years away physically. Time & time again the stronger bodied Swans were able to brush them aside and win possession or the contest.

With the strong speculation that Buddy Franklin will be lured across with a massive pay-packet via Free Agency and the prospect of trading #1 in exchange for a readymade senior player or two, they will be starting to address the dearth of bigger bodied players on the list. However, this will not be enough by my reckoning, they another 3 or 4 to plug the gaps.

Acknowledging that they do have 10-12 excellent top shelf players from very high up in the draft, they also have an abundance of very good players picked up in the second & third rounds as well. Only problem is, they are still a few years away from a development perspective and therefore should be attractive trade options to the other clubs. They could be exchanged for some older mature players who aren't getting the opportunities at their current club but would be in the top 22 at GWS.

It would be ideal for the Giants if they could wait that extra couple of years so the players can build themselves up physically but the AFL cannot afford to have this expansion team getting belted by 20-goals. Vlad would prefer them to be in the 8 and playing finals either next season or the one after because failure to have instant success in the rugby league heartland will not give them the media profile needed to attract members & crowd numbers. There is also the issue of how much it is costing to put this club together, an investment they definitely want to get a dividend on.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Isn't this old news already universally acknowledged?

Maybe, but being smashed by more than 20-goals in a local derby has to be ringing alarm bells a little harder than normal.

How long can they keep this sort of effort up ?? The AFL won't allow it, they want mega-success and they want it quickly, Gold Coast are miles ahead at the same point in development.
 
I thought the idea behind the over-the-top concessions was that they would probably struggle to assemble a competitive side in the short term, therefore look longer term. They will get flogged for another year, begin to break even, and then start winning all the time. Patience.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

just enjoy flogging them while it lasts because they will be handing out beltings of their own before too much longer

Yeah, that goes for every other club too. GWS is a complete shambles - they need minimum two wins by EOY and can not see it happening or next.
 
Carlton need a forward desperately so win win would be something like

Trade 1
GWS - Patton and Hoskin Elliot
Carl - Jamieson, Warnock, Yarran

Trade 2
GWS - Pick 1
Carl - Warnock Robinson and Yarran
 
Maybe, but being smashed by more than 20-goals in a local derby has to be ringing alarm bells a little harder than normal.

How long can they keep this sort of effort up ?? The AFL won't allow it, they want mega-success and they want it quickly, Gold Coast are miles ahead at the same point in development.

To be fair GC weren't that competitive in their second year ether.
 
Maybe, but being smashed by more than 20-goals in a local derby has to be ringing alarm bells a little harder than normal.

How long can they keep this sort of effort up ?? The AFL won't allow it, they want mega-success and they want it quickly, Gold Coast are miles ahead at the same point in development.
you mean the GC that at the same point last year were 1-14 (having just beaten Richmond by 2 points in Cairns) and had 15 goal losses in 3 of their previous 6?
 
The no.1 pick will get them some good players when they trade it.

I almost doubt any club would be willing to pay the price. That is the problem GWS have because they wont accept unders.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

WSYD GWS Just Has To Do Some Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top