Hall of fame comittee is a joke!!!

[itsintheblood]

Can someone please explain to me why there are a heap of journos on this comittee??????? What a joke.

 

[Hoola Hoops]

Can someone please explain to me why there are a heap of journos on this comittee??????? What a joke.

Because they have watched more games of footy than you will ever?

 

[Ipaidmy200in89]

Because they have watched more games of footy than you will ever?

STFU

 

[itsintheblood]

Because they have watched more games of footy than you will ever?

And that makes them experts does it? They've played as many as i have. ZILCH. The comittee should be made of past champions who cannot vote for themselves obviously.

 

[Pedro]

Because they have watched more games of footy than you will ever?

Perhaps I should apply for a spot on the committee. I could put on my resume "I've seen more games than Mike Sheahan"

 

[crackers57]

And that makes them experts does it? They've played as many as i have. ZILCH. The comittee should be made of ex champions who cannot vote for themselves obviously.

Be careful, IITB you appear to be agreeing with Mick Malthouse

 

[itsintheblood]

Be careful, IITB you appear to be agreeing with Mick Malthouse

Hehehehehe. Schitt. Someone get me my medicine!!!

Yeah I do on this occasion. Most times he talks crap and is full of himself but he's right on this one.

 

[Kooley]

And that makes them experts does it? They've played as many as i have. ZILCH. .

irony.

 

[Qsaint]

So who do they bring out to defend the decision?


You










Guessed it

Panel member Caroline Wilson, chief football writer for The Age, said the panel of 12 followed the selection criteria to an "exhaustive degree''.

http://www.theage.com.au/realfooty/...ria-over-Ablett/2005/06/03/1117568348027.html

The whole article is a joke and I for once agree with Eddie

 

[Contra Mundum]

Can someone please explain to me why there are a heap of journos on this comittee??????? What a joke.

Jesus don't take Mick Malthouses Bullskit Line - it was noteworthy that Eddie said there were to many "Newspaper Journalists" on the panel

 

[m.diddy]

Caroline "I'm a man" Wilson is on the commitee. That "chick" should not be allowed anywhere near a football field let alone a commitee selecting the Hall of Fame.

 

[Hoola Hoops]

And that makes them experts does it? They've played as many as i have. ZILCH. The comittee should be made of past champions who cannot vote for themselves obviously.

Apparently they are employed by the papers and radio for there expert opinion. Also journalists are eligible for hall of fame as well so why not have the premier AFL journalists on the committee?

 

[Hotel 6]

Does anyone know if the commitee members have changed over the years? If their has been no change then I wonder how he can be admitted this year when he has been overlooked in the past.
I for one believe he should be in it and it was always just a matter of time before he entered the Hall Of Fame

 

[LongBomb]

There were several changes to the committee this year.

 

[Ipaidmy200in89]

Caroline "I'm a man" Wilson is on the commitee. That "chick" should not be allowed anywhere near a football field let alone a commitee selecting the Hall of Fame.

And rapists should go to jail.....

Dog of a man!

 

[Hotel 6]

There were several changes to the committee this year.

Thanks Long Bomb, a different commitee comes up with different interpretations of the criteria and hence he is in. Cheers

 

[Ljp86]

There should be no commentators or journalists on the panel at all.

 

[Ipaidmy200in89]

There should be no commentators or journalists on the panel at all.

Or footballers.....

Just us BF supporter..s

 

[itsintheblood]

Or footballers.....

Just us BF supporter..s

Do you really wanna give such authority to zeke and his clonies???

I can just see the hall of fame nominations for the next six years

CLOKE, CLOKE, CLOKE, SHAW, SHAW, SHAW.

 

[Qsaint]

Or footballers.....

Just us BF supporter..s

Send the Cheque Here

If Andrew D can be a CEO on 500K a year, so can anyone on BF

 

[Wojee]

Patrick Smith is on the panel. There goes any hope of credibility.

 

[Kooley]

Caroline "I'm a man" Wilson is on the commitee. That "chick" should not be allowed anywhere near a football field let alone a commitee selecting the Hall of Fame.

She is earning a very good living from talking and writing about football unfortunately yourself your hillbilly attitude would mean jack sh.it to her.

 

[m.diddy]

She is earning a very good living from talking and writing about football unfortunately yourself your hillbilly attitude would mean jack sh.it to her.

She knows ******** all about footy. And is just the token female in the sports area.

 

[m.diddy]

And rapists should go to jail.....

Dog of a man!

Rapists should go to jail. That's why milne didn't. Too fast for you?

 

[crackers57]

Do you really wanna give such authority to zeke and his clonies???

I can just see the hall of fame nominations for the next six years

CLOKE, CLOKE, CLOKE, SHAW, SHAW, SHAW.

These are just 6 more of his disciples