Sherman has played 55 games
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Hawthorn 2007 Trades/ Drafting thread
- Thread starter hawka_fan
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Sherman has played 55 games
Smiggs Pig
Senior List
I am not sure about Sherman at Hawthorn, given our current forward line if he can crumb well he may be a handy addition. I love Charman and given he is only 25 he would be fantastic to the club. Talented bang crash ruckman with Hodge, Mitchell, Lewis and Sewell is imposing.
Would be interested in looking at one of Essendon crumbing forward types. Sheedy has gone nuts on drafting these since the midfield was labelled slow three or so years ago. Dempsey was the one I would have had most interest in but apparently played too well against Richmond for Essendon to consider trading.
People suggesting Glass, Rutten and Goodes could possibly be lured to the hawks consider what you would say to us trading Franklin, Croad or Hodge.
Would be interested in looking at one of Essendon crumbing forward types. Sheedy has gone nuts on drafting these since the midfield was labelled slow three or so years ago. Dempsey was the one I would have had most interest in but apparently played too well against Richmond for Essendon to consider trading.
People suggesting Glass, Rutten and Goodes could possibly be lured to the hawks consider what you would say to us trading Franklin, Croad or Hodge.
Goodes would be a brilliant addition. We would need to trade our highest draft picks so we don't lose players like Franklin, Croad or
Imagine a centre square that had Hodge, Lewis and Charman in it. That's just about the angriest trio you could imagine.
It seems strange to me that all us hawk supporters have identifed KPB as a posi we're kinda under-manned in, yet the selection committee haven't played Jacobs or Dawson for ages. You think if they considered it an area we're deficient in we'd see a bit more of these guys.
I'd love to have an A grade crumbing forward. Yep, Buddy and Williams can crumb but it's not their number 1 strength. I want a nutcase on the forward line that can crumb anything and tackles everyone.
TheHawthornWay
Senior List
mulhollanddrive
Premiership Player
Is it just me or is thread not based in any sort of reality. Adam Goodes being traded? Glass and Rutten possibilities to be traded?
Gary Shadforth
Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Hawthorn Hawks - Muston and Savage Player Sponsor 2010
Hawthorn Hawks - Smith and Savage 2011 Player Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Beau Muston 2009 Player Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Beau Muston 2008 Player Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Beau Muston 2007 Player Sponsor
Kick it to me! My crumbers are from clangers so I need a nutcase to help me out
.
Well this is partly a 'wish list' thrad.
Adam Goodes is definitely on our wish list.
Also I've heard Josh Hunt's name thrown around for trades - what's this guy like? Worth pursuing for our KPB role?
Goodes?? might as well get Judd, Rutten and Johnno Brown while we're at it
I think we should target the small forward through the draft, perhaps maric. Im againist taking this mould of player with a first round pick - but the draft is very weak and the kid is a freak. Could slot straight into the team next year.
I hope we trade for a KP defender
Goodes?? might as well get Judd, Rutten and Johnno Brown while we're at it
I think we should target the small forward through the draft, perhaps maric. Im againist taking this mould of player with a first round pick - but the draft is very weak and the kid is a freak. Could slot straight into the team next year.
I hope we trade for a KP defender
Ppl are forgetting we don't suck anymore! And we're not near the bottom of the ladder. Maric will be gone before we have a chance of picking him up.. probably!
Josh Hunt is not really a KPB.
I reckon Geelong would happily trade though.
Word from my hardcore cat fan mate is that he has never recovered mentally from the full on criticism of pulling out of a contest (not sure whether it was last year or yr before).
Similar scenario arose for him this year where he needed to commit himself. Word was that he did it, but that it was obvious he only did it because he had to, ie wasnt natural to him like C Brown etc
Are you sure he's only played 13 games? Because if he has then that makes his 2nd in the B&F even better. I thought he played all of last season pretty much and he's played a handful of games this year not to mention 2005.
- May 13, 2007
- 2,685
- 4,011
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Seahawks, Huskies, Newcastle Utd.
No.
I wouldn't imagine WCE would trade Morton but the word is he's been shopped around. The guy has undoubted talent but is now way behind Le Cras.
Would you give up a 2nd round pick for him?
We're dripping with young talent.
If west coast have already put the kid through a year or two with some senior exposure I consider him worth a second round draft pick.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #93
Yes! with a capital Y. This kid's a gun.
After today's game and matches over the season it proves we're too soft and have a lot of players who are mentally weak.
I can't see Taylor getting a regular game next year, he can't kick and panics too much. Guerra always gets beaten, is too slow. Young needs to bulk up and work on getting the ball when its not his day.
Dixon, Vandenberg and Smith are past it. Thanks and goodbye!
Thurgood, Little, Jacobs should be delisted. Not needed now, certainly won't be needed in the future.
Trade for a decent ruckman. Keep Mark Williams at all costs. Hope Zac Dawson is the answer down back or theres trouble, Jarrad Rivers could be an option?
In all seriousness, we've gotten ahead of ourselves and there are a lot of players on the list who won't be around for much longer or take us to finals glory.
I can't see Taylor getting a regular game next year, he can't kick and panics too much. Guerra always gets beaten, is too slow. Young needs to bulk up and work on getting the ball when its not his day.
Dixon, Vandenberg and Smith are past it. Thanks and goodbye!
Thurgood, Little, Jacobs should be delisted. Not needed now, certainly won't be needed in the future.
Trade for a decent ruckman. Keep Mark Williams at all costs. Hope Zac Dawson is the answer down back or theres trouble, Jarrad Rivers could be an option?
In all seriousness, we've gotten ahead of ourselves and there are a lot of players on the list who won't be around for much longer or take us to finals glory.
- Aug 15, 2005
- 8,648
- 697
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Hawthorn
Today has proven more then ever we need a small forward who can lay a tackle in our team. The Alwyn Davey mould is ideal, its simple to beat us get numbers back and walk out of the defensive 50. Today was shocking but we definatly need some more pressure in our forward line.
Londoner86
Cancelled
- Banned
- #96
We need a Ruckman. Simple. Cambell is average and Taylor is making up numbers. We need to go after Charman/Wood whoever, soome decent. Forward line pressue/tacking can be taught in a sense. Find a good ruckman can't.
Well said mate... It is about time our supporters face reality. It annoys me when all they do is make excuses and come up with stupid comments to protect players under the microscope.
Perfect sumamry of players up there. You only left out one- VANDENBERG.
Stop sticking up for him- he is useless. Like i said earlier. Never in my life of following football, over 20 years, have i seen a player that whenever goes near the ball something bad happnes- he consistently turns it over, makes the wrong decision and is simply not good enough. All everyone keeps saying is how good his leadership skills are off the field. So what???? His performances and leadership on-field are a DISADVANTAGE
- Aug 15, 2005
- 8,648
- 697
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Hawthorn
Pace cant be taught though, Rough has ran down one person this season, Boyle hasnt, and when Franklin finally lays hands on some one he pushes them in the back.
We have Bails and Renouf coming through, Wood is a class act and you would think there is no chance Brisbane would let him go
Im not saying we might not need a crumbing forward but our Ruck is our main concern. While Charman may be available, its a great oppertunity to pick up some one decent. Also I dont feel like waiting 3-4 yrs for baily/renouf to establish themselves, thats if they do.
Similar threads
