List Mgmt. Hawthorn 2018 Trade discussion NO OPPOSITION SUPPORTERS Part 3

[hk89]

Hmmm
People also described Vickery as being like an injured Kurt Tippett, but nowhere near as good.

True, but you'd never hire Kurt Tippet so he could make another player more like Kurt Tippet, so completely different kettle of fish.

 

[HODGEYROAD]

Yes. Let’s just see what we have to play with, but there remains a potential big trade, stress potential, that could involve him. But, from what I am told GW, is very, very excited about gaining Jack.

Reckon Wingard will happen Topiary, or will Port just be too staunch and refuse to play ball ?

 

[LunchboxLegend]

The movie Gladiator is on 7mate, and I keep thinking about that ‘unleash hell’ of the ‘it’s happening’ gif...

 

[Topiary]

I reckon we should try to keep Lovell. People describe him as like Sam Mitchell but nowhere near as good. Well the best guy to make him play more like Sam Mitchell is Sam Mitchell, so might be worth keeping on our list another year.

On the way out. Will be involved in a trade one way or the other. The good news is there are apparently at least two clubs, possibly three interested in him.

 

[grumbleguts]

3 votes. J. Warbel

He's keeping a low profile.
https://www.facebook.com/james.warble

 

[Luv_our_club]

Talks cheap , plan to play final v Pies which he only just fell short on achieving ....

Yeah.. but when he was injured it was a 10-12 week prognosis, with the talk being that his year wasn't over, rather than the reverse expectation.

It is not surprising however that he didn't play again.

 

[HawkMongrel]

Never mind all of this stuff, Usain Bolt just scored his first goal and it was decent. lol

 

[Chambo78]

Yes. Let’s just see what we have to play with, but there remains a potential big trade, stress potential, that could involve him. But, from what I am told GW, is very, very excited about gaining Jack.

May?

 

[Wizzmania]

True, but you'd never hire Kurt Tippet so he could make another player more like Kurt Tippet, so completely different kettle of fish.

Irregardless of what you are saying, I agree

 

[Hodgey 15]

Excellent article.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[RIOLINWITPUNCHS]

No doubt they will be. BUT, despite what others will say because only Richmond adopts these practices in their world, Cogs has been a very solid work in progress for at least 18 months. Our constant contact with him and his management is significant.

But remember only Richmond does this sort of stuff !!!!!!!!!!!!

Sorry to be a party pooper but we were working on Shiel for 2 years minimum.

Means **** all.

 

[beta_condition]

Adelaide news pretty much reporting Burton is a done deal to Port. Christ and they talk about Victorian bias.

 

[The German Hunter]

Just watching Scully highlights. Very, very excited

 

[Topiary]

Reckon Wingard will happen Topiary, or will Port just be too staunch and refuse to play ball ?

Yep.

 

[HawkMongrel]

Adelaide news pretty much reporting Burton is a done deal to Port. Christ and they talk about Victorian bias.

You haven't seen the 9th circle of hell until you've read a piece of "news" from Michelangelo Rucci.

 

[spudmaster]

Yes. Let’s just see what we have to play with, but there remains a potential big trade, stress potential, that could involve him. But, from what I am told GW, is very, very excited about gaining Jack.

Norf are used to getting "jack" around about this time of year also

 

[spudmaster]

Adelaide news pretty much reporting Burton is a done deal to Port. Christ and they talk about Victorian bias.

That's just SA's media being their usual 24-36 hours behind every other state.
Heck, they only congratulated West Coast a few days ago!

 

[ScottMaginness]

Yes. Let’s just see what we have to play with, but there remains a potential big trade, stress potential, that could involve him. But, from what I am told GW, is very, very excited about gaining Jack.

Thanks for the updates. My first reading of the above was that the "big trade" had the potential to cause a lot of stress, and I was thinking "gee haven't we had enough stress already" and then I read it again the right way. I probably need a break from reading this thread !

 

[Burtman]

The movie Gladiator is on 7mate, and I keep thinking about that ‘unleash hell’ of the ‘it’s happening’ gif...

After yesterday and today’s trade news I was thinking this

 

[Topiary]

I rate Scrimshaw but there's a lot of stuff on the GC board that isn't positive regarding workrate. This usually happens when a player wants to leave (see Wingard). I would be ecstatic to have Scrim, rated him since his draft year. What do you reckon will get the deal done (is pick 35 enough?)

Let’s not sugar coat this, this kid has substantial ability, but an attitude that shall we say allowed to dominate his effort in GC. But he wanted to get home, to get to his childhood beloved club, to get to a true professional environment, we will be chucking him a huge opportunity that hopefully with his new found maturity, will blossom.
I can let you in on a little story with Jack, when we confirmed with him we were keen to move on him, within two weeks of the conclusion of the season his form at NEAFL went through the roof. Let’s hope it is a good omen. GW had him very, very high in 2016. I mean very high.

 

[Chambo78]

That's just SA's media being their usual 24-36 hours behind every other state.
Heck, they only congratulated West Coast a few days ago!

To be fair, Rowey on 5AA had the Burton plus 15 mail the day before it came out. Another SA journo broke the Shiel deal too before Jon Anderson.

 

[Changa10]

Any updates he’s given you on if we can get the Chad deal done.?

No, my info is just just some texts between old school mates, as they are obviously interested in their mates future. Hopefully my mates son will be here tomorrow so I can ask him to see what further details he can get then.

 

[WWSD]

It's only J.Ralph but he just said the following:

- T.Scully to Hawthorn for only pick 53. Scully comes cheaply because of his ankle injuries (and salary cap relief), but it's a steal. Leon Cameron said in the past that Scully is the best 2-way runner by a country mile. Scully rates elite in almost every category.

 

[TallyHawk]

Yes. Let’s just see what we have to play with, but there remains a potential big trade, stress potential, that could involve him. But, from what I am told GW, is very, very excited about gaining Jack.

Likely to be a three way trade Hawks, Port, & Suns. Port will get pick 3, Hawks get Scrimshaw and Wingard, Suns get a stack of draft picks.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[artman]

How much would Patton be worth? I think 4th rounder or worse. Very risky with a big contract.