doodles98
Cancelled
- Aug 6, 2012
- 6,867
- 8,711
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
sorry if I gave you coitus interruptus ... please ... carry on... keep feelin it
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Hine you've done it again!
- Thread starter boxy99
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Totally agree, would hate to lose this guy to Carlton. It would burn me the most.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
- Thread starter
- #29
Yeah hats off to bucks! Although I don't think he would need to have the final say. He would just need to say Hine do your magic.
Bucks does deserves credit for bringing so much youth into the team and giving them game time when he could have stuck with older boys.
jock, ted & gerry.
as ive said elsewhere, this years draft will be boring. no hidden jewel. just 2 top 10 players that are relatively obvious.
damn
True, unless Hine rips out a name that's not even spoken about in the top 10 lol.jock, ted & gerry.
as ive said elsewhere, this years draft will be boring. no hidden jewel. just 2 top 10 players that are relatively obvious.
damn
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
Got to agree. Think Derek has picked-up some useful talent in addition to snaring a couple of very useful draft picks.
Winston_Smith
Club Legend
- Aug 24, 2013
- 1,234
- 3,719
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Been thinking this since this trade period started. Does anyone know was/is Hine close with MM like Butters, Daisy, et al?
Woods List Clogger
Cancelled
Completely agree, he's been overlooked.
2005 was a cracker year, but arguably next best two are the last two ( though perhaps its a tad premature to say that yet) and Rendell had a huge say with the three SA boys from last year.
2005 was a cracker year, but arguably next best two are the last two ( though perhaps its a tad premature to say that yet) and Rendell had a huge say with the three SA boys from last year.
Bard
Norm Smith Medallist
Reading up on Conlon has me interested. But I guess any KPF does
. Too bad we don't have a second rounder, as I think he'd be worth a punt at 31 or whatever we had (after compensation picks).
Bard
Norm Smith Medallist
Could be a good project player then. I'd be surprised if we didn't take him with our first rookie selection if still available, considering our needs for a KPF.
Cousin of Daicos
HEY MAGPIE ARMY!
Do people that peddle stuff like this even know what they're talking about?
Remind me what those 3 players cost us? If anything at all? Not every single coach is going to nail every single trade/drafting choice, but as long as the "mistakes" don't cost you anything, what's the problem?
Brody Grundy cost us pick 18.
Danny Roach cost us pick 7.
Young = Haven't seen enough to suggest it was an error signing him.
Lynch = Serviceable.
Russell = Tras/Delisted.
Too many doom & gloom people on here sometimes.
Lynch = Serviceable.
Russell = Tras/Delisted.
Too many doom & gloom people on here sometimes.
Not too many Breaker, just a loud and boring few posting negative sh1t at every opportunity
- Dec 12, 2010
- 4,989
- 5,282
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I think MM deserves some credit for this as well... Although the way some people on this board talk about him you wouldn't think so...
Most - apart from the Mick acolytes - would probably admit to being ambivelent about him.
Yes he did win us a flag and put us into position to win another few, but its very hard to forgive his egotistical grandstanding right on the eve of the '11 finals series which may have cost us back to back flags.
- Feb 13, 2013
- 2,694
- 2,651
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bears, Chicago Blackhawks
You should also mention they all cost us virtually nothing.
Lynch and Young had better seasons than Dawes and Wellingham
- Dec 12, 2010
- 4,989
- 5,282
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
It is not technically right to say he cost us back to back flags - he did get us the first one... The way you said it it sounds like you think he lost us two flags...
And some might argue that it was injuries (and a great team in Geelong) that cost us in '11. Some might even go as far as saying that it was Mick's coaching and gameplan that took us to the grand final that year. Maybe (I know this is a stretch) but just maybe some people might argue that the team's performance in 2011 had more to do with the senior coach than the recruiter...
I know, I know, some people are crazy.
It's all a matter of viewpoints JB I know from my viewpoint that the senior coach going onto a nationally televised football show and ripping into his own club on the eve of the finals is in fact unforgiveable. It's the act of a spoiled brat, not a senior and well respected coach. His outburst against Milne is another indicator of a man who believes himself untouchable, and don't get me started on his treatment of football journalists and the wider media family.
As for his time leading up to '10, no he didn't cost us any flags through poor coaching although his refusal to admit he was wrong in forcing a young Wes Fellows to ruck unsupported for most of his career is another indication of willful stubborness.
As to his match day coaching. . . WHAT matchday coaching??? Leaving an obviously wounded Reid on the rampaging Tomahawk???
Forgive my bluntness mate but as a matchday coach Mick STUNK.
So to wrap it up - great coach for bringing on young blokes (especially those not overburdened with natural talent), had the ability to engender loyalty. BUT has only one game plan with no fall back, refuses to make matchday moves when they are obviously necessary. Petulant, arrogant and self centered.
Thanks Mick for the flag, for which you will always have my respect but never darken my doorstep again.
Da Main Man
Club Legend
we should hire the GWS recruiter
Bent us over in the Shaw trade, they get Shaw plus part salary paid for a bloke no one ever heard of until this draft period!
what a gun recruiter!
(just sour, i'll get over it )
Bent us over in the Shaw trade, they get Shaw plus part salary paid for a bloke no one ever heard of until this draft period!
what a gun recruiter!
(just sour, i'll get over it
)
Similar threads
