If the draft was now! top 10.

[NathanMurray]

(Assuming freo,richmond ect. win more games, and melbourne dont...)

Pick1- Melbourne
Pick2- Melbourne
Pick3- Fremantle
Pick4- Richmond
Pick5- Nth Melbourne
Pick5- West coast
Pick6- Hawthorn
Pick7- Sydney
Pick8- Port Adelaide
Pick9- Essendon
Pick10-Carlton


Who'd go where?

Thoughts?[/LEFT]

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

Melb - Scully
Melb - Butcher
Freo - Lucas
Richmond - Trengrove
North - Stevens
WCE - Morabito or how every you spell it.
That's my top 6.

 

[cAsEy_18]

Yeah, i was gonna ask, assuming we have about pick 8-10, who do you guys reckon we'd be looking at? Probably key forward or midfielder.

 

[cannons]

Melb - Scully
Melb - Butcher
Freo - Lucas
Richmond - Trengrove
North - Stevens
WCE - Mortiabo or how every you spell it.
That's my top 6.

That's fantastic

Other than that, I think your list is pretty reasonable. The only real question mark surrounds Melbourne, and whether or not they will go with Butcher or another midfielder to complement Scully.

 

[Demonheart]

I doubt that Melbourne will take Butcher at 2, there would have to be a big turn around in form for this to happen. I'd expect us to take either Trengove or Morabito.
If it does happen like this then it would be interesting to see where Butcher does end up. Richmond perhaps?

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3- Fremantle - Kane Lucas
Pick4- Richmond - Jack Trengove
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Gary Rohan
Pick5- West coast - Anthony Morabito
Pick6- Hawthorn - Allen Christensen
Pick7- Sydney - Matthew Panos
Pick8- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick9- Essendon - Dylan McNeil
Pick10-Carlton - Daniel Talia

 

[Chris who]

wait up what about eagles tanking their way to 2 and 4 ?

 

[Ysaye]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3- Fremantle - Anthony Morabito
Pick4- Richmond - Jack Trengove
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick5- West Coast - Mitch Duncan
Pick6- Hawthorn - Koby Stevens
Pick7- Sydney - Gary Rohan
Pick8- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick9- Essendon - Ben Cunnington
Pick10-Carlton - Jack Fitzpatrick

 

[Cruiser23]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3- Fremantle - Anthony Morabito
Pick4- Richmond - Jack Trengove
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick5- West Coast - Mitch Duncan
Pick6- Hawthorn - Koby Stevens
Pick7- Sydney - Gary Rohan
Pick8- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick9- Essendon - Ben Cunnington
Pick10-Carlton - Jack Fitzpatrick

Dustin Martin?

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3- Fremantle - Kane Lucas
Pick4- Richmond - Jack Trengove
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Gary Rohan
Pick5- West coast - Anthony Morabito
Pick6- Hawthorn - Allen Christensen
Pick7- Sydney - Matthew Panos
Pick8- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick9- Essendon - Dylan McNeil
Pick10-Carlton - Daniel Talia

don't think McNeil is top 10 but i think he will get picked up in the later rounds.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

I dont see Lucas as the type Fremantle would go for. Could go for a KPF.

 

[Burzum]

I dont see Lucas as the type Fremantle would go for. Could go for a KPF.

Jack Fitzpatrick?

 

[DCFCFAN84]

Pick1 - Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2 - Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3 - Fremantle - Jack Trengove
Pick4 - Richmond - Anthony Morabito
Pick5 - Nth Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick5 - West Coast - Mitch Duncan
Pick6 - Hawthorn - Koby Stevens
Pick7 - Sydney - Matthew Panos
Pick8 - Port Adelaide - Jack Fitzpatrick
Pick9 - Essendon - Luke Tapscott
Pick10 - Carlton - Gary Rohan

 

[Darkness Falls]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3- Fremantle - Anthony Morabito
Pick4- Richmond - Jack Trengove
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick5- West Coast - Mitch Duncan
Pick6- Hawthorn - Koby Stevens
Pick7- Sydney - Gary Rohan
Pick8- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick9- Essendon - Ben Cunnington
Pick10-Carlton - Jack Fitzpatrick

Two pick 5s?

 

[Ysaye]

Two pick 5s?

Haha! - that should teach me for copying over the OP's pick list and using that.

Not sure Dustin Martin is the type that recruiters will get excited about in the first round.

 

[ChipDouglas]

Haha! - that should teach me for copying over the OP's pick list and using that.

Not sure Dustin Martin is the type that recruiters will get excited about in the first round.

I would say recruiters are very excited by Dustin Martin as a prospect and there is a zero percentage chance he isn't a first rounder.

 

[Agetigers]

Pick1 - Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2 - Melbourne - John Butcher
Pick3 - Fremantle - Jack Trengove
Pick4 - Richmond - Anthony Morabito
Pick5 - Nth Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick5 - West Coast - Mitch Duncan
Pick6 - Hawthorn - Koby Stevens
Pick7 - Sydney - Matthew Panos
Pick8 - Port Adelaide - Jack Fitzpatrick
Pick9 - Essendon - Luke Tapscott
Pick10 - Carlton - Gary Rohan

If this happens i'll spew.

Pick 1- Melb: Scully
Pick 2- Melb-Trengove
Pick3- Freo- Lucas
Pick4- Rich- Butcher
Pick5- WCE- Morabito
Pick6- Haw- Gary Rohan
Pick7- Syd- Panos
Pick8- Port- Fitzpatrick
Pick9- Ess- Koby Stevens
Pick10- Carl- Ben Cunnington

 

[Joshen]

If this happens i'll spew.

Pick 1- Melb: Scully
Pick 2- Melb-Trengove
Pick3- Freo- Lucas
Pick4- Rich- Butcher
Pick5- WCE- Morabito
Pick6- Haw- Gary Rohan
Pick7- Syd- Panos
Pick8- Port- Fitzpatrick
Pick9- Ess- Koby Stevens
Pick10- Carl- Ben Cunnington

I would love it to happen but I can't see us making the top 8:

Therefore we would get pick 4,5 or 6.

 

[King Of The Hille]

If this happens i'll spew.

Pick 1- Melb: Scully
Pick 2- Melb-Trengove
Pick3- Freo- Lucas
Pick4- Rich- Butcher
Pick5- WCE- Morabito
Pick6- Haw- Gary Rohan
Pick7- Syd- Panos
Pick8- Port- Fitzpatrick
Pick9- Ess- Koby Stevens
Pick10- Carl- Ben Cunnington

id love that

 

[Super Hans]

Does anyone know what pick Ah Chee will go?

 

[jimmy181]

Pick 1- Melb: Scully
Pick 2- Melb-Morabito
Pick3- Freo- Lucas
Pick4- Rich- Butcher
Pick5- WCE- Trengove
Pick6- Haw- Gary Rohan
Pick7- Syd- Talia
Pick8- Port- Panos
Pick9- Ess- Dustin Martin
Pick10- Carl- Koby Stevens

 

[melbournemartin]

Melbourne is far from settled in taking Butcher.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Pick1- Melbourne - Tom Scully
Pick2- Melbourne - Kane Lucas
Pick3- Fremantle - John Butcher
Pick4- Richmond - Koby Stevens
Pick5- Nth Melbourne - Jack Trengrove
Pick6- West coast - Anthony Morabito
Pick7- Hawthorn - Gary Rohan
Pick8- Sydney - Mathew Panos
Pick9- Port Adelaide - Luke Tapscott
Pick10- Essendon - Ben Cunnington

 

[LuKe2428]

Ok with people saying Trengove could come to Richmond can someone please tell me a bit about this kid. Does he have good skills? (something we lack bit time). Is he hard at the ball?. Just after a bit of info.
Thanks in advance

 

[hamush]

if freo win the spoon will they get pick 1 or 2?