Free Agency Isaac Cumming - Joins Adelaide as UFA

[Crow till I die]

That's a can of worms I dont want to open in here but... genuinely debateable

He really was the BOG in winning them a flag on the day. Johannison got it, but Boyd was really the difference maker. Its coming up 30 years since my side won a flag, i give up much to get in a player like that who wins us another flag

 

[manureid]

Maybe we bid Perryman up since he was reportedly link to them very early on so they can't get Cumming lol.

From what I gather from your supporters views on your list management team, this seems unlikely

 

[ABAB]

From what I gather from your supporters views on your list management team, this seems unlikely

We've greatly improved in last 4 years with our target and draft but there's players missing from 25-28 years old.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Oh thank ****.

Would've been okay to get for free but not keen on a pretty meh playing eating solidly into the salary cap at all.

Much prefer Perryman of the 2.

 

[ABAB]

Oh thank ****.

Would've been okay to get for free but not keen on a pretty meh playing eating solidly into the salary cap at all.

Much prefer Perryman of the 2.

You do know Perryman is reportedly offered a lot more than Cumming, 7 years at $850K.......

 

[Bring back Bas]

Oh thank ****.

Would've been okay to get for free but not keen on a pretty meh playing eating solidly into the salary cap at all.

Much prefer Perryman of the 2.

Is it confirmed where he is going?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I find it hard to imagine Port can get Cumming, Perryman and Luko, so a bit to play out I think on where all 3 land if in SA. Would imagine both clubs will end up with 1 or 2 of those 3.

My gut feel is the Crows land Cumming & Port Lukosius.

Crows apparently have the biggest offer on the table for Cumming.

Lukosius is close with Rozee & more of a need at Port.

. . But anything is possible in silly season.

 

[Crow till I die]

My gut feel is the Crows land Cumming & Port Lukosius.

Crows apparently have the biggest offer on the table for Cumming.

Lukosius is close with Rozee & more of a need at Port.

. . But anything is possible in silly season.

Yeah, like was discussed on the main board. If we end up with Cumming and ANB through trade / free agency but can hold onto pick 25, then it could be quite a nice off season with the pick 4 high end mid and pick 25 on a young ruck then Welsh with later picks. AND we maintain our F1 in that scenario.

 

[jackag24]

You do know Perryman is reportedly offered a lot more than Cumming, 7 years at $850K.......

Perryman is a better investment than Cumming when it's all said and done.

Drafted in the same year, Perryman has played almost 50 more games than Cumming.

Stats are pretty similar, Eye test says Cumming is potentially a better player but not much separates them honestly. I think you know what you're getting from both by now

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Feels a situation where if I’m Adelaide I’d rather Cumming and if I’m Port I’d rather Perryman

Adelaide just need a winger in general whereas I think Port need a utility who can play half back which would free up Bergman too at times

 

[Buget]

My gut feel is the Crows land Cumming & Port Lukosius.

Crows apparently have the biggest offer on the table for Cumming.

Lukosius is close with Rozee & more of a need at Port.

. . But anything is possible in silly season.

Adelaide picking up Cummings, ANB, Pick 4 (mid?) and Walsh would be a terrific off-season.

The only way Port would get Lukosius is if they trade Houston (who knows what’s going on there). The only way I can see them allowing Houston to go is if they get someone like Perryman.

It’s going to be an interesting off season.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Adelaide picking up Cummings, ANB, Pick 4 (mid?) and Walsh would be a terrific off-season.

The only way Port would get Lukosius is if they trade Houston (who knows what’s going on there). The only way I can see them allowing Houston to go is if they get someone like Perryman.

It’s going to be an interesting off season.

Future 2nd should do for Lukosius, given he has 2 years of his $950K contract left & Suns need the cap space.

Crows need to bring in net experience as we traded out last year & it cost us depth.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Adelaide picking up Cummings, ANB, Pick 4 (mid?) and Walsh would be a terrific off-season.

The only way Port would get Lukosius is if they trade Houston (who knows what’s going on there). The only way I can see them allowing Houston to go is if they get someone like Perryman.

It’s going to be an interesting off season.

Best off season of the year when you add Lukosius too. Best off season in a long time even by any club

 

[Alwaysacrow]

Adelaide picking up Cummings, ANB, Pick 4 (mid?) and Walsh would be a terrific off-season.

The only way Port would get Lukosius is if they trade Houston (who knows what’s going on there). The only way I can see them allowing Houston to go is if they get someone like Perryman.

It’s going to be an interesting off season.

Walsh who? What did I miss???

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Walsh who? What did I miss???

Assume a typo - Welsh.

 

[Buget]

Walsh who? What did I miss???

Assume a typo - Welsh.

Apologies…. Auto correct.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Feels a situation where if I’m Adelaide I’d rather Cumming and if I’m Port I’d rather Perryman

Adelaide just need a winger in general whereas I think Port need a utility who can play half back which would free up Bergman too at times

Yep, hence why the Crows have been into Cumming for 2 years and Port nearly 4 years with Perryman (mentioned on Gettable today that Port went hard for him in 2020 as well when last out of contract).

Cumming's manager said today he still hasn't made him mind up yet, but that does seem to be a bit of manager PR spin to ensure they maximise the cash. I think Port would only be realistically in the hunt if the Perryman deal fell through and they can up the cash offer (or even an extra year) for Cumming.

 

[Bevoman]

My gut feel is the Crows land Cumming & Port Lukosius.

Crows apparently have the biggest offer on the table for Cumming.

Lukosius is close with Rozee & more of a need at Port.

. . But anything is possible in silly season.

It's a free hit for the GWS pair, what ever it takes.

Luko is another issue

 

[Maximus 2011]

2nd round compensation for the Giants for Cumming?

 

[1990crow]

2nd round compensation for the Giants for Cumming?

Probably.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

weird tweet, he can just move wherever, not sure why you would say you are leaving but then not say to which club

Bidding war

 

[JPetro83]

My gut feel is the Crows land Cumming & Port Lukosius.

Crows apparently have the biggest offer on the table for Cumming.

Lukosius is close with Rozee & more of a need at Port.

. . But anything is possible in silly season.

Well, so far you got the Lukosius part correct. I wonder where this leaves the Cumming and Perry situation?

 

[TBM]

per Thrillthorpe7 - Tom Morris reporting that Cumming had medicals with both SA clubs yesterday... would expect a decision to be pretty imminent

 

[JPetro83]

per Thrillthorpe7 - Tom Morris reporting that Cumming had medicals with both SA clubs yesterday... would expect a decision to be pretty imminent

i got the feeling Perryman and Cumming both want to land at the Power.. the Crows are prob their last resort lol but port can probably on fit 1 of the 2 in. if the landed both plus Luko the Adelaide Footy Club should just fold. would be embarrassing.

 

[manureid]

i got the feeling Perryman and Cumming both want to land at the Power.. the Crows are prob their last resort lol but port can probably on fit 1 of the 2 in. if the landed both plus Luko the Adelaide Footy Club should just fold. would be embarrassing.

Zero chance Port are landing all 3. In fact, still think Perryman will go to Victoria and Cumming will go to the Crows. Landing Luko probably tightens the belt a little.