-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ivan Maric ( includes Welcome to Richmond Ivan Maric )
- Thread starter UpTheGuts
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: What is Maric Worth
mate we have bigger trolls amongst our own
i dont know what UTG's agenda is but he's going hardcore and pushing for a 'maric for our 2nd rounder' as a great deal
mate we have bigger trolls amongst our own
i dont know what UTG's agenda is but he's going hardcore and pushing for a 'maric for our 2nd rounder' as a great deal
Re: What is Maric Worth
some players who have gone around 35 in recent drafts.
06 tippett morton goldsteien, j kennedy, reimers, garland,
07 greenwood, dawson simpson, sam reid, scott thomson, chris mayne, brendan
white cross,
08 j roughead l jones, shiels, bennell, a smith, z clarke, broadbent, robinson, banfield,
09 astbury, macmillan, sam reid, christenson kennedy, vardy. gawn.
10 green, howe, mccarthy, newton, horlin-smith,hallahan, taylor, parker, michie fasolo,
unbelievable people want to forgo a crack at similar for an unproven 26 yr old who has done absolutely nothing apart from play the odd decent game here and there.
want a ruckman well lets see in the above mentioned. vardy, z clarke, j roughead, t goldstein, m gawn, d simpson seems to me if we want to target A DECENT RUCKMAN its around this pick 35 that we do it.
while we could do with an experienced ruck to help in the short term it is not imperative that we get one because of where we are at as far as rebuild goes.
our second rnd pick in any draft compromised or not is extremely valuable.if we are to take an iffy ruckman or unproven one which maric is it shoukld not be with this pick.
as stated before we could go and get seaby or blake for nothing who will do the same job in the interim as maric will.
some players who have gone around 35 in recent drafts.
06 tippett morton goldsteien, j kennedy, reimers, garland,
07 greenwood, dawson simpson, sam reid, scott thomson, chris mayne, brendan
white cross,
08 j roughead l jones, shiels, bennell, a smith, z clarke, broadbent, robinson, banfield,
09 astbury, macmillan, sam reid, christenson kennedy, vardy. gawn.
10 green, howe, mccarthy, newton, horlin-smith,hallahan, taylor, parker, michie fasolo,
unbelievable people want to forgo a crack at similar for an unproven 26 yr old who has done absolutely nothing apart from play the odd decent game here and there.
want a ruckman well lets see in the above mentioned. vardy, z clarke, j roughead, t goldstein, m gawn, d simpson seems to me if we want to target A DECENT RUCKMAN its around this pick 35 that we do it.
while we could do with an experienced ruck to help in the short term it is not imperative that we get one because of where we are at as far as rebuild goes.
our second rnd pick in any draft compromised or not is extremely valuable.if we are to take an iffy ruckman or unproven one which maric is it shoukld not be with this pick.
as stated before we could go and get seaby or blake for nothing who will do the same job in the interim as maric will.
- Banned
- #161
Re: What is Maric Worth
Lol how am i a troll !!
I am only saying what i believe and thats maric isnt a good ruckman as stated in a previous post guys like goldstein, simpson etc and even your own batchelor and astbury were around these picks
I dare amybody to compare seaby, blake , grahams statts at afl level to maric and tell me how he is a better ruckman
Hitouts to advantage arr his only claim to fame but jeesus if you only tap it 15 times a game and get half to hit its target thats 7 a game hardly 2nd or 3rd round value there.
Any good vfl sanfl wafl ruckman would do the same
Maric is a spud pure and simple if the tigers want to get anywhere you need ti get a top ruckman but if it isnt this year wait untill 1 becomea available then go hard.
Its not like you will be playing off in a grannie in the next 3-4 years.
Gc gws will be struggling to keep all the top line rucks in 2 years
Throw everything at them including uptheguts who is plain as day a crows troll
Lol how am i a troll !!
I am only saying what i believe and thats maric isnt a good ruckman as stated in a previous post guys like goldstein, simpson etc and even your own batchelor and astbury were around these picks
I dare amybody to compare seaby, blake , grahams statts at afl level to maric and tell me how he is a better ruckman
Hitouts to advantage arr his only claim to fame but jeesus if you only tap it 15 times a game and get half to hit its target thats 7 a game hardly 2nd or 3rd round value there.
Any good vfl sanfl wafl ruckman would do the same
Maric is a spud pure and simple if the tigers want to get anywhere you need ti get a top ruckman but if it isnt this year wait untill 1 becomea available then go hard.
Its not like you will be playing off in a grannie in the next 3-4 years.
Gc gws will be struggling to keep all the top line rucks in 2 years
Throw everything at them including uptheguts who is plain as day a crows troll
Re: What is Maric Worth
the one thing i like about maric is he not unco like gus, seaby or blake, and actually looks like he could become a decent player, whereas the others do not.
the one thing i like about maric is he not unco like gus, seaby or blake, and actually looks like he could become a decent player, whereas the others do not.
- Banned
- #165
Re: What is Maric Worth
He is 25 and croation decent
Great clubman that gives his all but its not much good definately a trier but a workman.
Too short, no leap , average kick he is only good around the throw ins and not very good in the center
He might be a great guy and all but a pretty average ruckman that will struggle at the highest level
So wht get him , you already have one of these on your list.
He is 25 and croation decent
Great clubman that gives his all but its not much good definately a trier but a workman.
Too short, no leap , average kick he is only good around the throw ins and not very good in the center
He might be a great guy and all but a pretty average ruckman that will struggle at the highest level
So wht get him , you already have one of these on your list.
CallMeAl
All Australian
Re: What is Maric Worth
you got that from the crows board?
You'd know then that neil craig, the most sought after man in football, said he would be elite, and that he'd be a great man to have in the trenches beside you?
I think what most people are forgetting is that hartley and co think that he has a lot of improvement in him.
bottom line is barely anyone has seen him play many, if any games.
so no one knows.
how many times you seen him play?
enough to justify coming in here to tell us he's a dud?
you got that from the crows board?
You'd know then that neil craig, the most sought after man in football, said he would be elite, and that he'd be a great man to have in the trenches beside you?
I think what most people are forgetting is that hartley and co think that he has a lot of improvement in him.
bottom line is barely anyone has seen him play many, if any games.
so no one knows.
how many times you seen him play?
enough to justify coming in here to tell us he's a dud?
Re: What is Maric Worth
He's pretty much on the ball with his assumption of Maric ......... He is just an average ruckman that only gets a handfull of touches SANFL grade at best
Hate to say it but , I have to agree with Juddy on this one Callme al
He's pretty much on the ball with his assumption of Maric ......... He is just an average ruckman that only gets a handfull of touches SANFL grade at best
Hate to say it but , I have to agree with Juddy on this one Callme al
Re: Ivan Maric
So this begs the question ??
To add just a slight upgrade on what we already have (and thats in debate)
What would that tiny upgrade be worth seeing as we already have Dumb Gus Graham contracted for another 2 years !
Unless he comes PSD ................. DONT WANT HIM
So this begs the question ??
To add just a slight upgrade on what we already have (and thats in debate)
What would that tiny upgrade be worth seeing as we already have Dumb Gus Graham contracted for another 2 years !
Unless he comes PSD ................. DONT WANT HIM
- Moderator
- #170
Re: What is Maric Worth
After reading this thread, all the 1,000 word essays say the same thing. Just worded differently. I'm having trouble keeping up with the status quo between the 4567897643 Maric threads and am under the impression that not even an epic 17 book series written by Dan Brown and posted on BigFooty about how Maric only gets 10 hit outs a game and puts his left sock on before his right is going to affect anything from the price of apples in China to Maric joining the Tigers this week.
After reading this thread, all the 1,000 word essays say the same thing. Just worded differently. I'm having trouble keeping up with the status quo between the 4567897643 Maric threads and am under the impression that not even an epic 17 book series written by Dan Brown and posted on BigFooty about how Maric only gets 10 hit outs a game and puts his left sock on before his right is going to affect anything from the price of apples in China to Maric joining the Tigers this week.
- Banned
- #171
Re: Ivan Maric
Without knowing how much time he played in the ruck those stats don't mean much
Without knowing how much time he played in the ruck those stats don't mean much
- Banned
- #174
Re: Ivan Maric
why? how many goals per game do other ruckmen kick in the lower leagues? do you expect 40 hitouts along with 20+ goals? as i said the high goal count suggests that he was either a ruckman/forward (which accounts for his lower hitout stats) or that he at least offers something offensively as a ruck, which graham and browne dont. his stat average in the afl is very similar (except for the hitouts and goals) and if a ruckman kicked a goal a game you would say that is a good contribution.
why? how many goals per game do other ruckmen kick in the lower leagues? do you expect 40 hitouts along with 20+ goals? as i said the high goal count suggests that he was either a ruckman/forward (which accounts for his lower hitout stats) or that he at least offers something offensively as a ruck, which graham and browne dont. his stat average in the afl is very similar (except for the hitouts and goals) and if a ruckman kicked a goal a game you would say that is a good contribution.
Re: Ivan Maric
Its very hard to compare other afl listed ruckman with maric as there are none that have spent 6 years on a afl list that are not playing seniors AFL.
Logic tells you that when a AFL level ruckman comes down to a lower level he will be the Number ! ruckman in That team & 21 hit outs is Rubbish.
Also when an afl listed Ruckman Plays at SANFL level , even when resting for 5 mins a quater (20 mins ) a game you would expect him to easily kick 1 goal a game.
The statts indicate that he played Ruck, otherwise playing foward you would expect a AFL player thats 200cm & 98kgs to average at least 3 goals a game at such a low level.
So seeing as he spent most of 2011 at sanfl and to average 21 hit outs ................ HE REALLY IS RUBBISH
Its very hard to compare other afl listed ruckman with maric as there are none that have spent 6 years on a afl list that are not playing seniors AFL.
Logic tells you that when a AFL level ruckman comes down to a lower level he will be the Number ! ruckman in That team & 21 hit outs is Rubbish.
Also when an afl listed Ruckman Plays at SANFL level , even when resting for 5 mins a quater (20 mins ) a game you would expect him to easily kick 1 goal a game.
The statts indicate that he played Ruck, otherwise playing foward you would expect a AFL player thats 200cm & 98kgs to average at least 3 goals a game at such a low level.
So seeing as he spent most of 2011 at sanfl and to average 21 hit outs ................ HE REALLY IS RUBBISH
