Confirmed Jack Carroll - signs with St Kilda

[THE_GUN]

Depends how likely the club sees Warner, other potential targets, or the viability of guys like Hutchinson or Chesser to play in the middle

Saints may have promised him guaranteed midfield time, we may not have been keen to do that.
Or maybe McQualter just wasnt keen on a guy with Carrolls attributes

I think you are being Bias here in thinking the eagles had that call

I personally think SoS convinced him he has a better future at St Kilda or gave him a longer contract

3 years $500k would have got him to the eagles and the club should have made sure he was an eagle

 

[jumperfan]

I think you are being Bias here in thinking the eagles had that call

I personally think SoS convinced him he has a better future at St Kilda or gave him a longer contract

3 years $500k would have got him to the eagles and the club should have made sure he was an eagle

Maybe he just likes Melbourne and didn't want to go back to Perth?

 

[stallon]

I think you are being Bias here in thinking the eagles had that call

I personally think SoS convinced him he has a better future at St Kilda or gave him a longer contract

3 years $500k would have got him to the eagles and the club should have made sure he was an eagle

I did say that maybe the saints promised him more game time

I just dont think we were that keen on him. Hes a nice top have player for sure, good depth but realistically is probably a 20-25 player on a list at best