Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[nottenthagain]

Carlisle is one of the most talented KPP's in the AFL. He's worth a top 10 pick and a decent player, or 2 picks in the teens.

more evidence proving why Essendon are hard to trade with. Delusional

If you could get a late first rounder you should jump at it.... any thought of a player coming the other way is fantasy

 

[eth-dog]

more evidence proving why Essendon are hard to trade with. Delusional

If you could get a late first rounder you should jump at it.... any thought of a player coming the other way is fantasy

Why would a professional recruiter waste their time on BigFooty? A late first round pick? I'm not the delusional one, I've seen several WB supporters agree that their first pick and someone like Fletcher Roberts would be a fair trade.

Also, in the two trade and FA periods this saga has been going on, we've had 5 recruits from trade and FA. There are currently 7 players on our list from other clubs, one of whom was taken via the Rookie Draft. You were saying?

 

[nottenthagain]

Why would a professional recruiter waste their time on BigFooty? A late first round pick? I'm not the delusional one, I've seen several WB supporters agree that their first pick and someone like Fletcher Roberts would be a fair trade.

Also, in the two trade and FA periods this saga has been going on, we've had 5 recruits from trade and FA. There are currently 7 players on our list from other clubs, one of whom was taken via the Rookie Draft. You were saying?

I'm sure plenty of players see it as a great opportunity for game time.... especially with possibly less competition in the near future. I was more so inferring that a pick that high AND a player was above the market value - no matter what the Dogs supporters say. That's my opinion. I'd possibly offer the Swans first pick but there would be no player attached to it.... it's semantics though, we'll need all of our picks this year.

when you're done with your court case come and see us though, we should be able to package something up for you.

 

[SherbertLemon]

I'm sure plenty of players see it as a great opportunity for game time.... especially with possibly less competition in the near future. I was more so inferring that a pick that high AND a player was above the market value - no matter what the Dogs supporters say. That's my opinion. I'd possibly offer the Swans first pick but there would be no player attached to it.... it's semantics though, we'll need all of our picks this year.

when you're done with your court case come and see us though, we should be able to package something up for you.

The lure of COLA no doubt.
Are you blokes even allowed to trade this off season?

 

[lets_fly_up]

I'm sure plenty of players see it as a great opportunity for game time.... especially with possibly less competition in the near future. I was more so inferring that a pick that high AND a player was above the market value - no matter what the Dogs supporters say. That's my opinion. I'd possibly offer the Swans first pick but there would be no player attached to it.... it's semantics though, we'll need all of our picks this year.

when you're done with your court case come and see us though, we should be able to package something up for you.

love how everyone acts like they are their teams actual recruiters

but seriously doubt sydney could afford the $$$ he would be wanting lol

 

[nottenthagain]

The lure of COLA no doubt.
Are you blokes even allowed to trade this off season?

We can... but I've heard we can only trade players on under $340k per year - lord knows how they came up with that figure

 

[schmuttt]

Carlisle is worth a 1st rounder, but on his form this year not much more than that. I think he is a very 'talented' player but his performance has been pretty average this year honestly.

 

[WN123]

more evidence proving why Essendon are hard to trade with. Delusional

If you could get a late first rounder you should jump at it.... any thought of a player coming the other way is fantasy

What is delusional is claiming an opinion in a post on Bigfooty as EVIDENCE that Essendon are hard to trade with.

 

[eth-dog]

What is delusional is claiming an opinion in a post on Bigfooty as EVIDENCE that Essendon are hard to trade with.

Because apparently I'm Adrian Dodoro

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

 

[Bishop]

Is it a worry for Essendon that Carlisle, Hurley and Hooker should all be down back- but they can't fit them all in?

Carlisle would be worth a first rounder, a 'swing man' like him with the skills to play at both ends will be handy, can always work on the goal kicking...

I'd trade him if I was Essendon, but you'll be needing a key forward at some point, but Carlisle definitely has big trade bait.

 

[Cudi]

I think many on here that have assumed him to be leaving are going to be sadly mistaken.

I expect an announcement to stay at Essendon in the next couple of months. The recent media about tothis situation is a fair way off the mark.

Doesn't sounds that way from this:

https://7bcmtransfers.digitalpigeon...oMw/file/615874d0-0849-11e5-92db-0601433dbb10

Obviously still might say but I think a lot would agree he sounds on his way out from what his manager said above.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Doesn't sounds that way from this:

https://7bcmtransfers.digitalpigeon...oMw/file/615874d0-0849-11e5-92db-0601433dbb10

Obviously still might say but I think a lot would agree he sounds on his way out from what his manager said above.

Will be played down back while us Essendon supporters have to watch him dominate at another team while we enjoy our bag of chips that we got for him.

FML.

 

[Cudi]

And will get a bag of chips in returns just like Ryder fml

I'd give our first rounder in a heart beat, I reckon that be around 8-12. That's pretty fair.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

I'd give our first rounder in a heart beat, I reckon that be around 8-12. That's pretty fair.

Would take that but I hope he stays.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Would take that but I hope he stays.

I'll give you Treloar for him...

 

[Pannalstaroz]

I'll give you Treloar for him...

Sold

 

[Two Planks]

I'll give you Treloar for him...

The problem is Carlisle won't go to GWS and Treloar won't go to bombers.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Sold

If he wants to go back to Melbourne and Essendon could match the Collingwood offer...

 

[inamedthegiants]

The problem is Carlisle won't go to GWS and Treloar won't go to bombers.

And the fact that I have absolutely no authority to trade out our players would also come into calculations I'd imagine...

 

[Boristown]

Geez, I hope he doesn't go to the Dogs. Exactly what they need to go to the next level.

 

[Two Planks]

And the fact that I have absolutely no authority to trade out our players would also come into calculations I'd imagine...

That to !!!!

 

[Pannalstaroz]

The problem is Carlisle won't go to GWS and Treloar won't go to bombers.

But other than that, it's perfect

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Geez, I hope he doesn't go to the Dogs. Exactly what they need to go to the next level.

To be honest that's true, would allow Roughead to be the floating ruckman, and playing CHB for the team he grew up loving would bring out the best in him IMO>

 

[stefoid]

To be honest that's true, would allow Roughead to be the floating ruckman, and playing CHB for the team he grew up loving would bring out the best in him IMO>

I wonder what it would be like to have a genuine goal to goal line?