Hmm you can justify 18 goals for picks 6 and 23 if you'd like, but it's certainly a worse trade than Schultz. At least the Pies can say they made an error after winning a flag.
No. He must have had a brilliant season for Fremantle.
Hogan had cancer and his father died when he was at Melbourne. He went to Fremantle, partied hard and played awful football, so was traded for very little. I can come up with hypotheticals as to why Schultz has been a dud trade and it’s not Collingwood’s fault, but I won’t. I’ll assess the trade on the football that has actually been played.
Hogan had a navicular injury that sat him out for most of his time at Freo
The equivalent of pick 5? What? It's pick 10 + pick 34
How is that worse?
The points have relevance if you need them. The Dockers don't have a F/S or academy player and nor do the Pies. Offer up 10+34 to Melbourne for pick 5 and see what they say. Those picks don't equal pick 5.
I would've given Ginni away for a can of Coke last year. The off-field dramas weren't worth it for a player who struggled to break into our side, and when given the opportunity, most games had no impact.
Jack bowes and pick 8 for a third round pick?
Truly believe they did that knowing they dbe stripped of 2 years of draft picks without it.
People say this, and his form is hit and miss, but he's 9th for coaches votes this year at Geelong. Ahead of some decent players who have played all year like Duncan and Blicavs.
