Speculation Jake Waterman trade value?

Remove this Banner Ad

If Saad was pick 8 or whatever then Waterman is that and more, no?

Rankine went for 5 so maybe that is overs (my mistake) but I think a top 10 is very fair for a clearly talented bloke

He’s playing as the spearhead in a side with Allen - and Allen for mine is a blue chip forward
 

Log in to remove this ad.

CatsDoItBetter said:
Top 5 pick for Waterman! Is everyone here talking about the same player?
That would be wild, he’s 26 and this will be the first season he’s kicked over 40 goals.
Click to expand...
The Crows literally offered the Dees 2 first round picks for Petty of all players last year.

Wouldnt be that wild tbh, some might be desperate
 
Jibroni said:
I would offer a pick between 20 and 25 otherwise why bother.

Harrison Petty (when fit) is a better player.
Click to expand...
Harrison Petty is a backman and looking at his goal kicking when playing forward it is rubbish.
You can't compere a backman with a forward.
Waterman is a lot better kick for goal
 
TiAn_ said:
Pretty sure this thread is specifically for discussing his trade value. Eagles supporters think a top 5-6 pick. I don’t think anyone with a first round pick currently would do it.

Which of those clubs are trading which of those picks for him?
Click to expand...
TiAn_ said:
I genuinely can’t imagine any of these picks being traded for him.

View attachment 2049057
Click to expand...

Youre either trolling or just have NFI.

The Dees were offered 2 first round picks for Harrison Petty last year. The Pies paid their F1 for Schulz. Liam Henry went for a 2nd round pick. Ratugolea went for essentially pick 25.

All of those trades from last year dictate that Waterman is easily worth a good first rounder. EASILY.

Plenty of clubs need a KPF. At least 5 clubs there need a KPF either to lead their fwd lines or to help their struggling KPF(Max King at the Saints for example).
 
stallon said:
Youre either trolling or just have NFI.

The Dees were offered 2 first round picks for Harrison Petty last year. The Pies paid their F1 for Schulz. Liam Henry went for a 2nd round pick. Ratugolea went for essentially pick 25.

All of those trades from last year dictate that Waterman is easily worth a good first rounder. EASILY.

Plenty of clubs need a KPF. At least 5 clubs there need a KPF either to lead their fwd lines or to help their struggling KPF(Max King at the Saints for example).
Click to expand...
 
stallon said:
Youre either trolling or just have NFI.

The Dees were offered 2 first round picks for Harrison Petty last year. The Pies paid their F1 for Schulz. Liam Henry went for a 2nd round pick. Ratugolea went for essentially pick 25.

All of those trades from last year dictate that Waterman is easily worth a good first rounder. EASILY.

Plenty of clubs need a KPF. At least 5 clubs there need a KPF either to lead their fwd lines or to help their struggling KPF(Max King at the Saints for example).
Click to expand...

Ok, so should be easy for you then, which clubs and which picks in that list for Waterman?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

TiAn_ said:
Ok, so should be easy for you then, which clubs and which picks in that list for Waterman?
Click to expand...
Just go through the teams yourself, all the ones that dont have 2 actual AFL level KPFs will be interested.

Whether they have the correct pick(s) currently is irrelevant, they can make it happen if they want it enough.
 
stallon said:
Just go through the teams yourself, all the ones that dont have 2 actual AFL level KPFs will be interested.

Whether they have the correct pick(s) currently is irrelevant, they can make it happen if they want it enough.
Click to expand...

Tigers, Roos and Saints aren’t trading out of their picks, so put a line through a first from them. The declining Dees rolling the dice with pick 11 for 5 years of Jake Waterman? Seems highly unlikely. I just don’t see it.
 
TiAn_ said:
Tigers, Roos and Saints aren’t trading out of their picks, so put a line through a first from them. The declining Dees rolling the dice with pick 11 for 5 years of Jake Waterman? Seems highly unlikely. I just don’t see it.
Click to expand...
Youre looking too much at the picks they currently have, not what can be done if they were interested

Why wouldnt North try to split their pick? Theyve got enough top end mids, and with Comben playing well they have ok KPD stocks.
Their biggest need is probably a KPF to partner with Larkey. If they try to draft one itll be years before theyre ready.

Tigers and Saints are unlikely, theyre desperate for elite draft talent.
If however things happen as theyre projected and they trade out or lose some players to FA, theyll have a way to get suitable picks if they wanted to do a trade without compromising their first pick.

The Dees might not go down that path, but if thats the case then theyre are conceding they wont win anything with May and Gawn, and will need to go through a rebuild of sorts.
If they could recruit Waterman and an average ruckman who is floating around they could extend their window. Petty to cover May and Waterman to be their KPF alongside JVR.
Considering they have a decent bunch of kids coming through as it is they might take a punt on more success.

Hawthorn are there too, they just lost Mitch Lewis to yet another long term injury, theyve got Chol who is their chop out ruck, and Dear who is a first year player covering their KPF spots atm. They could easily be in the market if they knew Waterman was up for grabs.

Collingwood are the other one who need a KPF, they have next to nothing to trade with though. If they can find something then im sure theyd be in the market too, they might need a KPD first though.
 
stallon said:
Youre looking too much at the picks they currently have, not what can be done if they were interested

Why wouldnt North try to split their pick? Theyve got enough top end mids, and with Comben playing well they have ok KPD stocks.
Their biggest need is probably a KPF to partner with Larkey. If they try to draft one itll be years before theyre ready.

Tigers and Saints are unlikely, theyre desperate for elite draft talent.
If however things happen as theyre projected and they trade out or lose some players to FA, theyll have a way to get suitable picks if they wanted to do a trade without compromising their first pick.

The Dees might not go down that path, but if thats the case then theyre are conceding they wont win anything with May and Gawn, and will need to go through a rebuild of sorts.
If they could recruit Waterman and an average ruckman who is floating around they could extend their window. Petty to cover May and Waterman to be their KPF alongside JVR.
Considering they have a decent bunch of kids coming through as it is they might take a punt on more success.

Hawthorn are there too, they just lost Mitch Lewis to yet another long term injury, theyve got Chol who is their chop out ruck, and Dear who is a first year player covering their KPF spots atm. They could easily be in the market if they knew Waterman was up for grabs.

Collingwood are the other one who need a KPF, they have next to nothing to trade with though. If they can find something then im sure theyd be in the market too, they might need a KPD first though.
Click to expand...

The Roos and Hawks would have to trade down, but if they split their picks I feel like they’d both still want to use a higher pick on young talent. Collingwood have an F1 but I don’t see them doing that again. Melbourne would be the best candidate given their needs but they appear to be regenerating their list and trading out of 11 would seem out of step.
 
TiAn_ said:
The Roos and Hawks would have to trade down, but if they split their picks I feel like they’d both still want to use a higher pick on young talent. Collingwood have an F1 but I don’t see them doing that again. Melbourne would be the best candidate given their needs but they appear to be regenerating their list and trading out of 11 would seem out of step.
Click to expand...
I think you just dont want to see it :sweatsmile:

KPFs who can be top 5 in the coleman despite playing 2 games less than everybody around them, while also playing in a bottom 3 team dont come on the market too often. Waterman is 3rd for average goals per game. Imagine if he played in a good team with some of the service Curnow or Hogan get?

Imagine if Larkey was available last year? Would have been some insane offers
What about if Oscar Allen was on the market last year after really only 1 year as the main guy? top 5 picks would have been on the table

Why cant Waterman be in the same category?

He might not want to go anywhere but guarantee clubs will be after him

Fun fact that isnt really relevant: Larkey, Waterman and Lewis were all in the same draft, within a few picks of each other in the 70s
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Speculation Jake Waterman trade value?

Similar threads

eth-dog
Speculation Jake Stringer
2 3
Replies
58
Views
3K
Wild Bill
Wild Bill
The Nostradamus
Recommitted Jake Waterman [signed 2 year deal]
2
Replies
25
Views
2K
Ge3ks
Ge3ks
Purple7x08_24
Opinion Hypothetical Mid season Trades
Replies
20
Views
1K
CasuallyDressed
CasuallyDressed
Makeshift Park
Opinion How many current players are actually worth a top 3 pick in a trade?
2 3
Replies
52
Views
2K
Sirlemsip
Sirlemsip
Obeanie1
  • Locked
Pick 1 2023 Trade value - What would it take?
384 385 386 387 388
Replies
10K
Views
280K
Lore
Lore
MarcMaverick
Mid-Season Trading and AFL
2 3 4
Replies
75
Views
4K
go_the_dockers
go_the_dockers
MarkJohnson#1
Opinion Trade Week Terminology
2
Replies
35
Views
2K
Rohan25
Rohan25

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top