Oppo Camp James Aish, (Traded to Freo 2019)

[Thatsmyname]

We're not losing Aish, we're keeping Grundy

*chants rhythmically*

 

[Anzacday]

I'm a fan of Aishy.
That said, I can't see anything wrong with what's transpired.
Longmuir would know he has one year to go and approached him with a longer term deal.
His Manager sought some comfort and we couldn't give it.
Aishy thought about his options and decided to take the deal.
All power to him and I wish him well.

 

[jerms]

I'm a fan of Aishy.
That said, I can't see anything wrong with what's transpired.
Longmuir would know he has one year to go and approached him with a longer term deal.
His Manager sought some comfort and we couldn't give it.
Aishy thought about his options and decided to take the deal.
All power to him and I wish him well.

There's a reason your mob were top of my best oppo supporters ladder recently.

 

[Anzacday]

Many memories of him standing under a high ball and not flinching.
Can't find the video of one of my favourite moments...

 

[TradeDraft]

I'm a fan of Aishy.
That said, I can't see anything wrong with what's transpired.
Longmuir would know he has one year to go and approached him with a longer term deal.
His Manager sought some comfort and we couldn't give it.
Aishy thought about his options and decided to take the deal.
All power to him and I wish him well.

Helps that Longmiure being at Collingwood and knowing the Situation we where in and Took Advantage of it

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Could but Would you want to stay at a Club that has Put you out there for Trade?

So, after all that, we finally agree, it was his decision to leave

See, we got there in the end

 

[TradeDraft]

So, after all that, we finally agree, it was his decision to leave

See, we got there in the end

Yes but was the Clubs Fault he is in this Situations that he did not want in the 1st Place

 

[ClaytonM]

Yes but was the Clubs Fault he is in this Situations that he did not want in the 1st Place

Shame on the club for drafting Grundy, Moore and JDG who have all turned out to warrant/demand lots of dollars. We should draft spuds who will not cost us much in future.

 

[Nuwanda]

Yes but was the Clubs Fault he is in this Situations that he did not want in the 1st Place

That’s footy. Players need to secure their future and footy clubs have a duty to members to put themselves in the best possible position to win a premiership.
Last 2 years we have played off in a GF and a PF. Can’t complain with that. To stay up you need to change up your list and keep the most important at players.
This is a good result for Aish. He gets a long term contract most likely at good $$$ and plays under a coach who he knows well and who knows him well. It must feel good for Aish to know that Longmuir wanted him and was willing to sign him up for 3 years.

The Pies have done what we should expect them to do. I like Aish, but his injuries and his pace have been an issue.

 

[TradeDraft]

That’s footy. Players need to secure their future and footy clubs have a duty to members to put themselves in the best possible position to win a premiership.
Last 2 years we have played off in a GF and a PF. Can’t complain with that. To stay up you need to change up your list and keep the most important at players.
This is a good result for Aish. He gets a long term contract most likely at good $$$ and plays under a coach who he knows well and who knows him well. It must feel good for Aish to know that Longmuir wanted him and was willing to sign him up for 3 years.

The Pies have done what we should expect them to do. I like Aish, but his injuries and his pace have been an issue.

I agree he be feeling good at Freo as has a Coach that has Backed Him In to be a Best 22 Player.

With Hill leaving there is a Spot on a Wing for him

 

[surfer1]

Is it official yet?

 

[sirlothie]

Is it official yet?

Yeah Ned Guy said he will not be at Collingwood next year. Just a matter of formalities now.

 

[TradeDraft]

Yeah Ned Guy said he will not be at Collingwood next year. Just a matter of formalities now.

So IF trade not done we Release him?

 

[sirlothie]

So IF trade not done we Release him?

I think he means it's going to happen, by the deadline it is agreed it will happen, probably just sorting out minor details. Sorry mate.

Ned Guy said Aish has requested a Fremantle trade and he will make it happen.

 

[TradeDraft]

I think he means it's going to happen, by the deadline it is agreed it will happen, probably just sorting out minor details. Sorry mate.

Ned Guy said Aish has requested a Fremantle trade and he will make it happen.

Not IF Freo not pay up.

Does not have to go thru with it.

I agree it happens and Future Picks be Involved

 

[sirlothie]

Not IF Freo not pay up.

Does not have to go thru with it.

I agree it happens and Future Picks be Involved

If Ned had a press conference to say it will happen, it will happen. .01% chance it does not happen now.

They just arguing the price but they will agree on something.

 

[TradeDraft]

If Ned had a press conference to say it will happen, it will happen. .01% chance it does not happen now.

They just arguing the price but they will agree on something.

Never say Never

 

[sirlothie]

Never say Never

Keep your cool a bit if it happens if you can but I know it will piss you off.

 

[TradeDraft]

Keep your cool a bit if it happens if you can but I know it will piss you off.

I just want to get an Answer either Way.

I am expecting the Trade to Happen but just hope its not for Nothing

 

[sirlothie]

I just want to get an Answer either Way.

I am expecting the Trade to Happen but just hope its not for Nothing

Only half an hour now and you will know.

 

[didaksrightfoot]

I just want to get an Answer either Way.

I am expecting the Trade to Happen but just hope its not for Nothing

I think most of us want to make sure its for nothing - and Ned Guys comments suggest the club feel the same way.
The presumed salary cap pressure isn't really a factor until 12 months from now - there is nothing forcing us to push him out the door now. But trading now does make future decisions a bit clearer.

Now its about waiting to see what we can get in return. Im hoping for pick 22, but lets see. If its a 3rd rounder or lower, then i hope we say no (unless we do have serious cap pressure right now)

 

[mocamagic]

Like Dave I hope the Aish deal falls through
He was considered good enough to play in last year’s GF and this year he was brought back for the Prelim
despite limited preparation
He’s not a star but still has his best football ahead of him
I will be happy if he stays

 

[jerms]

I imagine the holdup here may be because we want the flexibility to live trade our future 1st to get another swing before Henry if he's not bid on before 12 - trading out any futures may prohibit this, so it could be something like one of our future 2nds for your future 3rd and future 4th. We don't have much late this year, guessing our 58 isn't enough, and we wouldn't be up for moving our 22.

 

[sirlothie]

I imagine the holdup here may be because we want the flexibility to live trade our future 1st to get another swing before Henry if he's not bid on before 12 - trading out any futures may prohibit this, so it could be something like one of our future 2nds for your future 3rd and future 4th. We don't have much late this year, guessing our 58 isn't enough, and we wouldn't be up for moving our 22.

Yeah they will be trying to find some middle ground between those 2 picks, something that equates to the value of about pick 30 would be fair I think. Pick 22 is a bit overs.

 

[TradeDraft]

17 Minutes to go