News James Peatling chooses Adelaide

[PaythePerryman]

Given how lowly the Giants board rates him, future 3rd should be enough.

According to them, Shiel replacing Peatling improves them.

Legit every Giants fan I've met....and the club wanted to keep him.
Let's not pretend we didn't want him. I'd still love him to change his mind.

 

[crow2crow]

Crows being prepared to accept 25 (admittedly, 28 by the time we traded it) straight up for ANB, but playing hardball for a F2 over Peatling is interesting. I guess ANB has many more runs on the board, but still.

Sounds like GWS aren't too upset about it.

two reasons
1. like me, theyre yet to be convinced peatling is an a or b grade mid
2. hes is ooc

 

[Mutineer]

Legit every Giants fan I've met....and the club wanted to keep him.
Let's not pretend we didn't want him. I'd still love him to change his mind.

Pity your coach and list management didn't rate him enough until it was too late?

 

[GrommoT]

We don't need to trade our future 1st.
Better business is to keep our future 1st & use our future 1st.
...

 

[fuic08]

Legit every Giants fan I've met....and the club wanted to keep him.
Let's not pretend we didn't want him. I'd still love him to change his mind.

You think he's worse than Dylan Shiel though. That's not a high rating.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Whoops!

 

[Colonial]

You think he's worse than Dylan Shiel though. That's not a high rating.

No one thinks that.
Shiel would be an option out of the middle for speed and a welcome home.

But Peatling is a local and his effort, pressure and defence is A+.

To me now he will always be Judas and I want to boo the hell out of him. Gutted he is going.
You got a talent coming in.

 

[fuic08]

No one thinks that.
Shiel would be an option out of the middle for speed and a welcome home.

But Peatling is a local and his effort, pressure and defence is A+.

To me now he will always be Judas and I want to boo the hell out of him. Gutted he is going.
You got a talent coming in.

This is literally on your board with multiple likes.


Don't have to convince me, Peatling is much better than Shiel.

 

[Colonial]

This is literally on your board with multiple likes.
View attachment 2135731

Don't have to convince me, Peatling is much better than Shiel.

We are dealing with a local turning his back.
Shiel has speed over Peatling, effort about equal, but pressure and defence Peatling is ahead.
Of course my opinion.

 

[Pugsley]

Shiel is cooked.

 

[fuic08]

We are dealing with a local turning his back.
Shiel has speed over Peatling, effort about equal, but pressure and defence Peatling is ahead.
Of course my opinion.

Well I was just refuting your claim that no one thinks Shiel is better.

 

[Colonial]

Well I was just refuting your claim that no one thinks Shiel is better.

We don’t. As I said, dealing with a local leaving and lashing out.

 

[George Kramer]

Well I was just refuting your claim that no one thinks Shiel is better.

Does it matter what GWS are writing on their board?

 

[dylan123]

Does it matter what GWS are writing on their board?

It's the actual true measure of a players worth.