Jeremy Cameron

[Watson_my_mind]

bombersno1 You talk as if Cameron doesn't want to go to Saints or Dogs or clubs like these because they aren't in premiership contention or on a rung below? Cameron will put the dogs into the top 8 by himself..

 

[MaddAdam]

Would take a bit more from North though i.e. your first rounder. Fyfe is still just 22, he has near Judd-like value (not as decorated but he'll be a year younger than Judd was when he left). No way do Freo give him up for just Black and Swallow.

This deal is moot though - if Swallow is traded I'll eat my hat. When was the last time a club traded its captain voluntarily (i.e. not including Judd in 2007)?

Yeah, my view is the sooner we take the captaincy off the Bible thgumper and give it to Jack Ziebell, the better, but that's wildly off topic.

 

[yaco55]

I hope that clubs haven't over-rated Cameron, as has the media and the general public. Cameron played in a poor team and therefore he wasn't given the oppositions full attention as you can let one or two players go in a poor team. It's been a different story in 2014 - Lot more work put into his game, and his form has been average.

It will be interesting to see how much teams give up for Cameron - I actually see him as being the number two forward ( a good one at that ). I guess that Freo would be my number one contender.

 

[Blackas87]

Exactly....so basically let Gibbs go...and then GWS gets two picks in the top 10 for Cameron. Burgoyne trade type. Melbourne are a chance to get that too with Frawley.

Frawley is a free agent, if he is going to leave Melbourne it isn't going to a club worse than us, if he even hears his name mentioned in a trade to GWS he'll just sign somewhere else.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

I hope that clubs haven't over-rated Cameron, as has the media and the general public. Cameron played in a poor team and therefore he wasn't given the oppositions full attention as you can let one or two players go in a poor team. It's been a different story in 2014 - Lot more work put into his game, and his form has been average.

It will be interesting to see how much teams give up for Cameron - I actually see him as being the number two forward ( a good one at that ). I guess that Freo would be my number one contender.

Not really the case for mine. What is the case is how they structured up benefited him greatly. They pushed high, left him one on one and counter attacked with pace often leaving him with huge amounts of space to work in either to the front or behind. This year they structured up more conventionally and he has struggled finding that space, still I don't think them throwing him into defence is really helping.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Not really the case for mine. What is the case is how they structured up benefited him greatly. They pushed high, left him one on one and counter attacked with pace often leaving him with huge amounts of space to work in either to the front or behind. This year they structured up more conventionally and he has struggled finding that space, still I don't think them throwing him into defence is really helping.

Not to mention the eardrum situation.

 

[Syd]

Goodes and O'keefe retiring at the end of the year?

Yuck

Plus Shaw

And we have an excess of good Mids coming through to trade

Cameron, Tippett and Franklin forward line

 

[Lach72]

Getting players willing to move will be an issue

 

[Wallaby]

I reckon the AFL and co might do a little re-think re the COLA for the Swans.............................

 

[Rioli magic]

Frawley is a free agent, if he is going to leave Melbourne it isn't going to a club worse than us, if he even hears his name mentioned in a trade to GWS he'll just sign somewhere else.

The suggestion was if Frawley were to leave, Melbourne would be compensated with a 1st round pick.

They could then use that compensation pick + their normal draft pick in a trade.

 

[legend166]

Giants should just say "Sorry mate, you're a required player. Take your chances in the PSD but we've got the first pick so we'll take you again."

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Giants should just say "Sorry mate, you're a required player. Take your chances in the PSD but we've got the first pick so we'll take you again."

Unlikely that they'll have the first pick in the PSD at the end of 2015 when he comes out of contract. Possible given their recent form, but unlikely.

 

[BG32]

Welcome to the dees

 

[Aussie Joe]

Not many clubs willing to give up what Giants need. With Judd, we hadthe what WCE needed. With Cameron, I doubt it. I don't think we will give up a Kennedy type player again. Back then we were desperate for some leadership. Although we are probably desperate for a KPF, GWS would want a Murphy/Gibbs/Kruezer and 1st round pick. It will be too rich for our blood.

I see the Bombers or Dees giving them a talents player and 1st round TBH.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

is Brisbane in Victoria ?

 

[Perthmadcatter]

Giants should just say "Sorry mate, you're a required player. Take your chances in the PSD but we've got the first pick so we'll take you again."

Would probably result in 10 Victorian teams going 0-5-17, that's 0 wins, 5 losses and 17 nil all draws to get the number one PSD pick

 

[Vindicater]

A deal involving

Carlisle (KPD), Melksham (Midfield) and our end of 1st round pick?

Probably need to include a better midfielder than Melksham. Zaka maybe?

 

[FuManchu]

~3 million on 3 players i don't see how anything could go wrong with that

Imagine if all of them were in a car driven by Buddy or Hannebery!

 

[manboob]

Don't see why GWS would be interested in Carlisle, is an average player no better than what they already have in those positions.

 

[eth-dog]

Don't see why GWS would be interested in Carlisle, is an average player no better than what they already have in those positions.

Bloke would be their best defender? Go and revisit what he did first half of last year.

Carlisle + Pick 19 + Zaka for Cameron. Cameron + Daniher forward line.

 

[DerpWerls]

Straight swap for Dustin Martin over here

 

[FRUMPY]

Not many clubs willing to give up what Giants need. With Judd, we hadthe what WCE needed. With Cameron, I doubt it. I don't think we will give up a Kennedy type player again. Back then we were desperate for some leadership. Although we are probably desperate for a KPF, GWS would want a Murphy/Gibbs/Kruezer and 1st round pick. It will be too rich for our blood.

I see the Bombers or Dees giving them a talents player and 1st round TBH.

Id happily give up kruezer in a package deal for cameron. Kruezer has done bugger all at carlton and is totally expendable. For instance, id give up Kruezer+Lucas+first draft pick for cameron

 

[Lets Roar like '44]

Sounds like a bit of a sook to me. Played with a heart the size of a peanut on the weekend.

 

[Suma Magic]

The big question is:

Which gun player from a Vic team would want to move to GWS?

Probably no one.

GWS won't trade him this year.

 

[JohnnyFontane90]

Sounds like a bit of a sook to me. Played with a heart the size of a peanut on the weekend.

can you blame him? probably most talented forward 'prospect' in the country, and the team puts up 41 pts while he rots in defence.