Traded Jesse Hogan [traded with #65 to Fremantle for #6 and #23]

[Cobbler]

That comment was for Raffrox who suggested you guys keep your 2019 first and replace it with pick 22.

Ah ok.

 

[Cobbler]

Can’t see melbourne accepting a future 1st. Think Freo wold have to hand their pick over to even get the ball rolling (6 after lynch compo). Melbourne will want something to help them push towards the top next year.

Yes.
They do accept our pick 6 but it is ontraded to GC for May.

 

[Flea_29]

I'd argue Brisbane and Freo both paying overs, but they'd need to.

Might be more:
Brisbane Lose: Pick 5 and Pick 22

Fremantle Get: Hogan and pick 22
Fremantle Lose: Neale and 1st 2019

Melbourne Get: 2019 1st and May
Melbourne Lose: Hogan

Gold Coast Get: Pick 5
Gold Coast Lose: May

Slight adjustment.

I doubt Freo would need to lose a 1st rounder if Neale leaves.

Could look like this:
Bris Get: Neale, Pick 38
Brisbane Lose: Pick 4 and Pick 22

Fremantle Get: Hogan
Fremantle Lose: Neale

Melbourne Get: May & Pick 17/18 & 29
Melbourne Lose: Hogan

Gold Coast Get: Pick 4, Pick 22
Gold Coast Lose: May & Picks 17/18, 29, 38

 

[Slax]

Brisbane Get: Neale
Brisbane Lose: Pick 5 and 2019 1st

Fremantle Get: Hogan
Fremantle Lose: Neale

Melbourne Get: 2019 1st and May
Melbourne Lose: Hogan

Gold Coast Get: Pick 5
Gold Coast Lose: May

Who is being ripped off here (Melb for mine and maybe a little GC with only pick 5 for May) Maybe Freo to chuck in next years 2nd round to Melb or GC


btw I actually think this is stupid and have stated before that I hope Hogan stays at Melbourne who have done right by him on so many levels. Just a bit of fun making up trades.

No Melbourne get pick with May that high

Freo
In: Hogan & Pick 5
Out: Neale & Pick 6

Lions
In: Neale
Out: Pick 5

Melbourne
In: May
Out: Hogan

Suns
In: Pick 6
Out: May

 

[Taylor]

Too much risk this season, too high a price.

 

[Dargonian]

Yes.
They do accept our pick 6 but it is ontraded to GC for May.

You’ve got Gold Coast receiving 5 and is also Brisbane losing pick 5? Either way melbourne would ask for Freos or Brisbane’s first instead of the future first. So they can go all out next year.

 

[CWaffles]

No Melbourne get pick with May that high

Freo
In: Hogan & Pick 5
Out: Neale & Pick 6

Lions
In: Neale
Out: Pick 5

Melbourne
In: May
Out: Hogan

Suns
In: Pick 6
Out: May

No way we straight swap Hogan for May.

 

[Cobbler]

You’ve got Gold Coast receiving 5 and is also Brisbane losing pick 5? Either way melbourne would ask for Freos or Brisbane’s first instead of the future first. So they can go all out next year.

My golly.

YES. I have exactly that. You do realise Melbourne need to pass the pick on to secure May??

They are given essentially 2 x firsts for Hogan. Keep the 2019 1st and ontrade the 2018 first from Brisbane.

Thought it was simple to read.

 

[Taylor]

Melbourne should offer Hogan a three year extension worth $3,000,000.

 

[CWaffles]

Melbourne should offer Hogan a three year extension worth $3,000,000.

If he really wants to go home then I am happy for him to leave this year, would rather he go now rather than when the team is settled and playing good football.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

This thread is going to get epic with potentially 4 clubs involved in a trade and all over/under valuing the player they are losing/gaining

 

[Cobbler]

Melbourne should offer Hogan a three year extension worth $3,000,000.

Get on board Taylor and stop looking up navicular stress fractures. Get some optimism in this place.

Hogan gonna be purple people!!!

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Can’t see melbourne accepting a future 1st. Think Freo wold have to hand their pick over to even get the ball rolling (6 after lynch compo). Melbourne will want something to help them push towards the top next year.

Spot on

 

[Dargonian]

My golly.

YES. I have exactly that. You do realise Melbourne need to pass the pick on to secure May??

They are given essentially 2 x firsts for Hogan. Keep the 2019 1st and ontrade the 2018 first from Brisbane.

Thought it was simple to read.

I’m saying Freo keep the 2019 first.
Instead cough up their pick and Brisbane’s pick and one of those gets Ontraded for May. I didn’t think it was that hard to understand.

 

[master bate]

Assuming it nets us Steve May I'd probably settle for pick 5 or 6 or whatever it is that goes to the Suns and Ed Langdon.

Can we tempt Freo to take Dom Tyson for their 3rd round pick as well? They'll need ready made midfielders. Trade that to North for Preuss.

 

[raffrox]

Assuming it nets us Steve May I'd probably settle for pick 5 or 6 or whatever it is that goes to the Suns and Ed Langdon.

Can we tempt Freo to take Dom Tyson for their 3rd round pick as well? They'll need ready made midfielders. Trade that to North for Preuss.

Ed Langdon?

Nice try.

 

[Paracleet]

So Melbourne trade him out while he is at his lowest value (problematic foot injury). Freo look to trade him in under contract spending high end currency in a rebuild without seeing if said problematic footy injury is recovered from.

This deal is definitely not happening. Stop trolling us media.

 

[Cobbler]

I’m saying Freo keep the 2019 first.
Instead cough up their pick and Brisbane’s pick and one of those gets Ontraded for May. I didn’t think it was that hard to understand.

Oh ok.

Well nah. We currently have pick 5 then 77. We'll need to hold onto some 2018 draft pick gains.

If we get 4 and 22 for Neale, cant give up 4 and 5 for Hogan. Still only have pick 22 and 77.

 

[Tulip]

Melbourne
In: May
Out: Hogan

This would be the worst deal, honestly.

 

[manny100]

If Lever worth 2 first rounders (plus later swaps) Dees would be looking at that just as a first glance. No way just one first rounder will do it. Depends on how badly Freo want it done. Lobb another alleged Freo target looks set for WCE. Lobb however not in the same class as Hogan.
I do not think Dees will want him gone so it will have to be a to good to refuse offer for both Hogan and the Dees. Roos said recently Hogan can play anywhere and could even be a gun CHB. Now Weideman looks to have a future Goodwin has options with Hogan should he stay.
We will just have to wait and see. Could be 'fake news'.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I've solved it guys, we can close thread (I've edited a trade I posted before)

Freo
Out: Neale,
In: Hogan

Suns:
Out: May, 17 (WC pick)
In: 5, 22

Melb
Out: Hogan
in: May, 17

Brisbane
In: Neale
Out: 5, 22

Edit: Unless the new list manager is a complete muppet, under not circumstance will Melbourne get 5 & 6 for Hogan given our current draft position and his injury history.

 

[Dargonian]

Oh ok.

Well nah. We currently have pick 5 then 77. We'll need to hold onto some 2018 draft pick gains.

If we get 4 and 22 for Neale, cant give up 4 and 5 for Hogan. Still only have pick 22 and 77.

aWhy why Freo be worried about a high draft pick this year though? If you can get Hogan pull the trigger on that. Guess you could trade a future 2nd to GC to get a pick this year. Or try and squeeze it out of Brisbane maybe.

 

[tombomb]

Gotta love Johnny Ralph piggy backing off a different paper breaking the story and trying to turn it into his own.

 

[tombomb]

So we are to believe that Melbourne are going to offload the pick they get for Hogan, onto GC, in exchange for May? At least when the media make up rumors could they at least come up with a realistic trade scenario? There is a 3 year gulf between these guys (favoring Hogan). Hogan was twice the player May was this year, Hogan has twice the talent May has, and Hogan plays a FAR harder position than May, and, quality forwards are worth MORE. There is not a man born from his Mother that would straight swap Hogan for May, yet we are supposed to believe this trade is done. I have about had the media.

I thought that there was some sort of contractual obligation for every HS trade story by Jon Ralph and Jay Clark to reference the North Melbourne 'war chest'. Even if it is just to say they are 'war chesting' elsewhere, they should be mentioning it.

 

[manny100]

This would be the worst deal, honestly.

Totally agree, from memory we gave up pick 3 and pick 13 with 20 back and Dom Barry. He was 17 years old and not eligible to play AFL. So given his progress a minimum 2 early 1st rounders would be required for a to good to refuse trade.