Who is this Gellong you write of, back to school for you mate!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Roast Joel Selwood - A Cheat?
- Thread starter The Panther
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Who is this Gellong you write of, back to school for you mate!!
Don't know if he is a cheat, but he definitely loves to duck into tackles and run at players with his head still down, frustrated me and every Collingwood supporter at the ground to know end, it got to the point where you just expected free kicks to get awarded to him. Not his fault though, he is a good player who takes advantage of the rules, it is the umps that need to be onto it.
At least Leigh Brown buried him on one occasion, he is someone you wouldn't want to duck against as the big fella would probably snap your neck.
The player that annoys me the most though is Stevie J, he is a worse diver than didak, who for the most part hasn't really dived this year. The thing that stood out was when he dived from contact made by Didak himself. It didn't matter as Chapman got a goal anyway but it was still funny to see SJ make a fool of himself.
At least Leigh Brown buried him on one occasion, he is someone you wouldn't want to duck against as the big fella would probably snap your neck.
The player that annoys me the most though is Stevie J, he is a worse diver than didak, who for the most part hasn't really dived this year. The thing that stood out was when he dived from contact made by Didak himself. It didn't matter as Chapman got a goal anyway but it was still funny to see SJ make a fool of himself.
- Banned
- #28
Definitely a cheat.
A player lands a fair tackle on him around the torso and he lets his legs go from under him allowing him to slide down and make contact with his head/neck on the tacklers arms.
It is cheating, cowardice and flog like all in one. Couldn't of been happier when he decided to try out some tough stuff on Beams in the last quarter in the wrestle and Beamsy put the little girl on the ground suitcase style.
A player lands a fair tackle on him around the torso and he lets his legs go from under him allowing him to slide down and make contact with his head/neck on the tacklers arms.
It is cheating, cowardice and flog like all in one. Couldn't of been happier when he decided to try out some tough stuff on Beams in the last quarter in the wrestle and Beamsy put the little girl on the ground suitcase style.
Yeah I think it's a bit unfair calling him a cheat, he's not the one giving himself the free kicks. Sure I got frustrated but really if you take a step back and watch him play there's not too much to dis-like the way he goes about it.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #30
Another cheating tactic Geelong employ is Ling continually holding his opponent off the ball. He held Pendlebury at least 5 times last nite & was only paid one freekick against him.
I watched his tactics closely & have no doubt that if Selwood was the one receiving the treatment, he would be hamming it up more than a soccer player at the WC.
I watched his tactics closely & have no doubt that if Selwood was the one receiving the treatment, he would be hamming it up more than a soccer player at the WC.
mrmagoo
Debutant
He's been getting away with it for ever. So IMO he is'nt a cheat. What it shows is that the umpires are hopeless. If they did'nt award him free kicks then he would stop doing it.
The Friday night match between scum 1(Carlton) and scum 2(Essendon) where Mitch Robinson ran head first into Hille and was awarded a free kick and Hille was reported is proof of how hopeless most of the umpires are.
Dave06
Team Captain
Taking pot shots at type-o's - you are a superstar mate. Your clearly superior intellect makes a mockery of the rest of us.
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
It's the umpiring that has to change and they have to realise that it's Turtle Selwood initiating the head high contact.
I don't mind if they have their head over the ball and the tackle starts high, but when you are tackled fairly then Turtle Selwood ducks his head and slides his shouders through the tackle so his head is near the tacklers arms some leeway needs to be given. The tackler needs to be given some time to adjust his tackle, just like they are given some beneft of doubt when a player doesn't take full possesion of the ball.
I don't mind if they have their head over the ball and the tackle starts high, but when you are tackled fairly then Turtle Selwood ducks his head and slides his shouders through the tackle so his head is near the tacklers arms some leeway needs to be given. The tackler needs to be given some time to adjust his tackle, just like they are given some beneft of doubt when a player doesn't take full possesion of the ball.
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
Don't know about you country boys but in the big smoke we have this thing called question marks. Also I note a case of incorrect use of a comma there. If you're going to bag someone for something, you've got to know the ****ing basics junior.
Just got to love someone like Harry O's approach to winning the hardball.
He picks the ball up off the ground and immediately straightens up, turning his body sideways to protect his head, he then backs himself to take on any possible tacklers without trying to play for a free kick.
That's the difference between someone playing the game in the right spirit rather than trying to abuse the rules like Selwood.
He picks the ball up off the ground and immediately straightens up, turning his body sideways to protect his head, he then backs himself to take on any possible tacklers without trying to play for a free kick.
That's the difference between someone playing the game in the right spirit rather than trying to abuse the rules like Selwood.
The Royal Sampler
Floreat Pica, Bitch!
He's not a cheat, it's his natural arc.
... of his neck...
... downwards before contact...
... of his neck...
... downwards before contact...
Magma
TheBrownDog
Quick question. If someone like Dane Swan or Alan Didak did this, would you agree with them being accused of a cheat?
If anything, I see it as smart play. If you're able to do something within the rules to get more of the ball, more power to you.
If anything, I see it as smart play. If you're able to do something within the rules to get more of the ball, more power to you.
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
Like a turtle
Cmon photoshoppers selwoods head on a turtle can't be too difficult, thanks boys
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #39
If they did it on the same occurance of Selwood, I'd take issue with it. Would you do the same if Kurt tried to do what he did in the dying stages of the 1SF every week?
Didaks diving and softness has been well criticised on this board, this is an area he has improved on though I should add, so its not as though we turn a blind eye towards our own players doing these types of things.
Even in this thread most people have said it is the umpires that need to change not Selwood, so don't try and play the hypocrisy card.
Even in this thread most people have said it is the umpires that need to change not Selwood, so don't try and play the hypocrisy card.
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
No because we are biased.
trentmac21
Debutant
Gee the way you girls whinge you'd have thought that Geelong won last night. FFS you won, you should be enjoying that instead of hiding behind a computer screen, taking pot shots at a GUN player.
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
Tissue?
Want to see a whinger watch Joel whinge and moan to the umpires when they started correctly calling his turtle impression play on
I'm not sure what the inbred country hick town version of that paragraph is but I'm sure you and your wife/sister will get get it eventually
Where would you like us to be if we are posting on bigfooty
This sentence can be used against anyone who has ever posted something about anyone on the internet ever.
I don't think players would appreciate it if fans started following them at training and at their homes telling them what they think which would be the alternative.
bouncing back
Team Captain
what about some humility instead of whacking an opposition player you grandstand muppets. you'd have him in your team in a flash if he was available.
It reminds me of the KB ruling which forever changed the holding the man, holding the ball interpretation. KB abused the rule and Selwood is doing the same. Make it simple-if you duck, drop your knees or head butt your opponents chest or knee it is PLAY ON regardless of high contact. That will put an end to the ducking and dropping to knees.
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
Richmond supporter telling us about humility?
You get the irony right, next you'll be telling us how best to make the finals
pinkcococupcake
Team Captain
This so called 'Turtle' will KILL you in the GF, cannot wait!!!!
daics_35
Club Legend
If the umpires get sucked in then it will be the umpires who will cost us a grand final if we are to make it. You might not even make the grand final how can you be so confident.
- Status
Similar threads
