The Legals tend to make decisions that would enlarge their financial coffers. The end result would have little to do with it
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Judd to contest suspension!!
- Thread starter Makka
- Start date
- Tagged users None
The Legals tend to make decisions that would enlarge their financial coffers. The end result would have little to do with it
They should throw the book at him; they gave him an easy out, and a tame suspension, his arrogance to challenge it is breathtaking.
It will indeed.
If there is a loophole and he somehow gets off, the damage to his reputation will be incalculabe.
Would have been much better to have taken the two weeks and given the public their pound of flesh.
Desperado...why don't you come to your senses...etc
WTF ???
Don't you think you are going a little over the top ??
Advisors to Judd - 'Do you realise if you lose this appeal a bunch of flogs on BigFooty are going to post that they don't like you'.
Judd - Noooooooooooooooo - call off the appeal !!
Exactly what they will argue.
How can this be 'Low Impact'. there wasnt any impact. No damage done. just Judd trying being a bit silly....
If i ruffle someones hair after they miss a shot for goal then...
- Intentional - yes
- High - Yes
- Low Impact - Yes.
So 3 week suspension??
THE MRP have suspended on hearsay. How can u suspend someone for hands on the face?? Thats what i hear people arguing?? If there was no gouge ( which we have established there wasnt ), then hands on the face is not a reportable offence.. Not saying it wasnt stupid...but ive seen people rub there hands in peoples faces after they have tackled them and got holding the ball etc... Not gouging and not reportable...
Look forward to seeing him round 1
- Feb 11, 2009
- 367
- 3
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Banned
- #109
This is simply step two of a simple, six-step process.
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=15653211&postcount=406
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=15653211&postcount=406
How does the existence of a loophole increase damage to his reputation compared with pleading guilty?
It does not make sense!
Completely agree and love it
I also love seeing all these JEALOUS supporters from other clubs kick up a stink about it haha!
yeah, really arrogant to second guess the MRP cause they never get it wrong and everyone should just cop whatever they offer. How dare the club exercise their right to challenge the suspension? Bloody Carlton ...
rickster, I'd think if Rischitelli 'blacked out' Judd would be de-registered for life.
Have you not sensed that nearly the entire football world (with the exception of Gary Lyon and some Carlton supporters) is against him here? Christ, even a significant minroty - pehaps even a majority - of Carlton supporters on this board think this is a dumb move.
Given his history of poking and prodding around the head and facial region and the feeling that he "got away with something previously" he'd be much better off to give the public its pound of flesh.
If he gets off, he'll have to put up with barbs and accusations for the balance of his career and I'm not talking about your regular idiots over the fence either. Brand Judd will be damaged, perhaps irreparably.
He got a memo from Adrian Anderson: "Challenge, we'll take care of it"
And so he should have been but he did'nt did he?
It was an attempt! and Judd said himself that he thought it was "dumb" and I assure you so does every other Carlton supporter,
You cannot suspend a player for touching another player's head, if something had of happened to Rischitelli fair enough punish Judd but NOTHING did happen, Fine the man for attempting something stupid and move the hell on!
lolz.
judd must be embarrased by his explanation to the media, he is going to be called the karate kid for the rest of his career, whether he gets off or not.
total lolz.
players at the brownlow should shout out 'karate kid', whenever he gets a vote.
judd must be embarrased by his explanation to the media, he is going to be called the karate kid for the rest of his career, whether he gets off or not.
total lolz.
players at the brownlow should shout out 'karate kid', whenever he gets a vote.
Much as I'd love to see Carlton punished, I tend to agree (except for the last bit). Only warranted a reprimand and warning for mine. A fair dose of tall poppy syndrome in evidence here.
I think you'll find it is "high contact" as is anything above the shoulders. Face or not is irrelevant.
Grimreepah
BigFooty One Armed Man
Seems strange to admit it and then contest it. There has already been a fair amount of public condemnation of this act, so if he gets off it will cause a bit of a backlash.
Looking forward to the 2010 draw giving us a round 3 match with the Juddless Blues.
yer that was funny..
I wonder if Judd's defence will smear Rischitelli's character during the tribunal hearing? Has Judd asked Campbell Brown for a character reference this time around?
Similar threads
- Poll
