MRP / Trib. Lynch To Tribunal

[SunshineBoy]

That weasel was playing judge and jury on AFL360 tonight, tried to crucify Lynch

Low life grub , pedo

 

[Groupie_]

That weasel was playing judge and jury on AFL360 tonight, tried to crucify Lynch

does anyone remember what he was like when dunnyfield knocked out vlas and got off

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Just got blocked by John Ralph , I tweeted him to suck on a bag of dicks and to get Gerard to help him

Probably got offended after you suggested Gerard to help him.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Moral of the story is don't delibrately look to block a forwards run to the ball and you won't get knocked the * out.

Spot on coach. That and that alone would’ve been my defence tonight.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

stooged myself for a second scrolling to the bottom of this thread

 

[Groupie_]

Probably got offended after you suggested Gerard to help him.

"I can do it myself"

 

[Livonski]

yep, same with the mackay bloke, christian needs to go, just a spoon fed puppet for the AfLs agenda.

Disagree.
Christian sends these sorts of cases to the tribunal to generate “case law “
That is to get the incident actually argued with evidence submitted.
It’s a much better system than ticking boxes which as _RT_ has pointed out could lead to suspension. Which would’ve been a travesty.

 

[Groupie_]

Disagree.
Christian sends these sorts of cases to the tribunal to generate “case law “
That is to get the incident actually argued with evidence submitted.
It’s a much better system than ticking boxes which as _RT_ has pointed out could lead to suspension. Which would’ve been a travesty.

the afl make him do it for the theatre when theres a bigger club involved

 

[tiggywigs]

You're allowed to brace for contact, however IMO the MRO believes that Lynch chose to bump instead of contesting the mark. Had he done that and made contact with Keath it would be classed as no other way to contest the ball and bad luck for Keath.

As for being graded as severe, the MRO seem to label every concussion incident as severe as a means to establish some consistency in results.

As for the comparison with Cameron/Andrews, like Lynch Cameron never actually contested the mark and instead opted to take out the opponent, the fact he did it with an raised elbow is why he copped 6 weeks (IIRC). Lynch will probably cop 4 like Broad did and I have no issue with that, even if Lynch wasn't injured with the foot.

The AFL is going to continue trying to eliminate unneccary head contact where it can, unfortunately there will be incidents like what happened with Tom McCartin last night that are a result of contesting the ball, but when players are not choosing to contest the footy and simply bump an opponent players are going to run the risk

So...where did the Tribunal go wrong?

 

[Al Heimer]

First thing Benny needs to do when he takes over is to sack that shit sack of stacked up shit Christian.


On SM-J250F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Noidnadroj]

What was his alternative to vanish into thin air?

He should’ve continued going for the mark. As you said Lynch should have done. It’s all academic … tribunal agreed with all of us and disagreed with yours and Christian’s assessment of the incident. Sanity fortunately prevails.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[kozi]

Wankley tomorrow

"State of the tribunal"

 

[Groupie_]

First thing Benny needs to do when he takes over is to sack that s**t sack of stacked up s**t Christian.


On SM-J250F using BigFooty.com mobile app

nah stand rule

 

[guruisatiger]

haha, take it to safeway carpark

gone in 60 seconds

Right outside the plough

 

[Defibrillate]

does anyone remember what he was like when dunnyfield knocked out vlas and got off

Remember it very clearly. Said it was “a football action, and clearly no case to answer”. What struck me was how quickly he just dismissed it and moved on. There was no discussion at all - Robbo queried it - but he basically shut it down immediately and dismissively moved on like the wise elder he thinks he is. This was the same year he'd defended Gaz Jnr three weeks in a row for high hits (and he was upset when he finally got suspended). His partisanship clearly clouds his judgement - and his blithe acceptance of the Stewart sanction confirms that.

I can't watch him anymore.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

Disagree.
Christian sends these sorts of cases to the tribunal to generate “case law “
That is to get the incident actually argued with evidence submitted.
It’s a much better system than ticking boxes which as _RT_ has pointed out could lead to suspension. Which would’ve been a travesty.

the club can just appeal anyway then right?

the MRO has guidelines that say if the player is contesting the ball and in a reasonable way they can be excused from shit like this. dumb ****s like me watched a 360p youtube video, rewound a couple times and figured out that was the case here in 2 minutes

the MRO only sends this stuff through to tribunal coz 1 he probably gets told what to do by the afl gods above 2 theatre as groupie said and 3 to avoid backlash when he inevitably ****s one up too badly coz his dog ate the rulebook

 

[Boston tiger]

They owe us a final and the bastards know it.

 

[kozi]

hopin i get a chance to use this, if not i can use it for the next lynch murder trial


View attachment 1656949

This is f*n gold

 

[GoTigers2015]

Lynch 2 AFL Media / MRO 0

In 2020, the media frenzy against Lynch lead the most ridiculous tribunal appearance which was thrown out in record time.
Hurley faked high contact during the Dreamtime game after Lynch had fending him off with contact to his shoulder.

No wonder Dimma got angry at the media with questions about collision with Alex Keith. Won't hear any of those media parasites apologise.

 

[Waca Jr]

Might call Whankley's show tomorrow and ask him how he likes to eat his bag of dicks

 

[kozi]

Might call Whankley's show tomorrow and ask him how he likes to eat his bag of dicks

let us know before so we can tune in

 

[SavDog23]

Could this be the start of a miraculously turnaround by the AFL where we finally get sucked off by umps and media?

Or are we gonna get ****** so hard by the umps on friday that Dimma finally loses it in the presser and goes on a rampage that leaves no-one standing.

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

we made up the foot broken thing on purpose for sympathy

big sexy will play on friday night

That would be so unbelievable

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

Suck a bag of dicks whankley, you low life grub

What did Skeksis campaigner say

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

does anyone remember what he was like when dunnyfield knocked out vlas and got off

I think he said, 'football incident' or 'action' he was very definitive
Slobbo bought it up about 18 months later in a round about way .. cant remember how he said it, because he is slobbo
**** them both.. dumbcampaigners