McCarthy, shulz, bennel, Jetta or carslile? Who is our priority?

[heath86]

It willl be exciting if we can get it done. I reckon our 2nd rounder and Zac should be more than enough. They may throw in their 3rd rounder to even it out?

 

[calaisking]

He's contracted. They don't have to trade him.

Wasn't Beams contracted? But as he wanted to go home, Collingwood/Brisbane worked out a trade

 

[FUS_RO_DAH]

Still reckon we should get Schultz though, really help with developing McCarthy.

This.

 

[Allikat]

Reckon they'll take Hannath for McCarthy?

 

[apuchar]

I hope WC keeps their snotty nose out of this.

 

[apuchar]

Wasn't Beams contracted? But as he wanted to go home, Collingwood/Brisbane worked out a trade

You do recall what Brisbane gave up to make that happen.

 

[Freoforever86]

Dunno why WCE would bother. They have Darling, Mcinnis, Kennedy, Gov, Lycett as tall options. They need mids etc..
Not sure he'd get a game in their fwd line ATM.

We are the only logical option & will have to pay overs. He slots straight into the 22.

Would have to give up a Clarke/Silvagni & 1st round + maybe future 2nd round.
Make it happen freo!

 

[Lach72]

Colin Young is a shit truck but he hasn't much to gain by lying as McCarthy is contracted to end 17:

"When asked by Channel Nine, McCarthy's manager Colin Young confirmed the 193cm forward had requested a move back to his home state.

However, the Giants denied McCarthy had requested a trade via Twitter."

 

[Freoforever86]

McCarthy is best mates with barass at WC sigh

Surely this deal may already be done. Agreed to terms awaiting a trade

I'm afraid it may take silvagni and Clarke

Or Clarke and a young mid. One of the hands off 3. Weller, Blakey or grey

Means nothing. Buddy & wellingham are best mates. Don't see buddy at WCE. They'll be same state so can hang haha

 

[apuchar]

Dunno why WCE would bother. They have Darling, Mcinnis, Kennedy, Gov, Lycett as tall options. They need mids etc..
Not sure he'd get a game in their fwd line ATM.

We are the only logical option & will have to pay overs. He slots straight into the 22.

Would have to give up a Clarke/Silvagni & 1st round + maybe future 2nd round.
Make it happen freo!

Because they are arseholes. Lets just hope they haven't got the money available.

 

[Lach72]

Youn do recall what Brisbane gave up to make that happen.

McCarthy isn't Beams quality...yet

 

[Freoforever86]

Colin Young is a shit truck but he hasn't much to gain by lying as McCarthy is contracted to end 17:

"When asked by Channel Nine, McCarthy's manager Colin Young confirmed the 193cm forward had requested a move back to his home state.

However, the Giants denied McCarthy had requested a trade via Twitter."

Same situation as Boyd. Except Boyd was higher profile. It'll get done or he will walk next year.

 

[Lach72]

Same situation as Boyd. Except Boyd was higher profile. It'll get done or he will walk next year.

End of 17

 

[GordonT]

Reckon they'll take Hannath for McCarthy?

Would you?

 

[E Shed]

It's going to be tough to get both Bennell and McCarthy with just draft picks and fringe players. Especially how shit this draft is.

Exciting times tho.

Hasn't Bennell ruled out coming back to Perth?

 

[Freoforever86]

End of 17

Well then instead haha

 

[Steinfreo]

I do Croz and 1st pick for McCarthy

 

[apuchar]

McCarthy isn't Beams quality...yet

I know but suggesting that we should play hardball and try not to give up someone like Clarke is farcical. They are holding all the cards, we are the ones that will have to make them happy. We should thank God if they even consider taking Clarke as part of the deal.

 

[Rob]

It willl be exciting if we can get it done. I reckon our 2nd rounder and Zac should be more than enough. They may throw in their 3rd rounder to even it out?

You reckon they might throw in Cameron as well just to sweeten the deal?

 

[apuchar]

You reckon they might throw in Cameron as well just to sweeten the deal?

Yeah that would be a first rounder and Clarke

 

[Leatherpoizoned]

I do Croz and 1st pick for McCarthy

I think is around what we will be looking at I think. Maybe a future pick in a stromger draft too. Worth it.

 

[glasto2010]

Sonny and sunshine in the forward line! Bright days for freo

 

[Righteo]

Don't need a million threads for this talk. McCarthy talk can go in the newly created thread and the rest can stay in here