Most Hated Club/Biggest Rivalry - Who Is It?

[Doc1763]

Carlton

Why? 1970, 1979, 1981 and their narcissistic, dirt-bagging, born to rule supporters.

For me, no other club comes close.

 

[barrackers]

Last week North, this week Adelaide…

In terms of clubs I enjoy beating

1) Essendon - family
2) Geelong - a lot of w***ers I’ve known follow them
3) Carlton - enough said
4) Tuggers - enough said


There’s something about PA too, but they’re only relevant once or twice a year when they whinge about wanting to wear a jumper that is simply too similar to ours.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Carlton - Pond Scum

 

[Anzacday]

Thought you might be interested to look back at previous opinions so merged them.

 

[loki04]

Still Essendon.

Richmond have a special mention too.

 

[manicpie]

I hate each and every one of the campaigners equally

 

[Carringbush2010]

Richmond
Essendon
Carlton

Blose
Tuggas
Bomb outs

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

Pretty much hate all of the Carlcoast Tigerbombers. But WCE simply because that was STILL a cheating block by Rioli and without that they wouldn't have scored again.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

1. Carltank
2. The Capulets
3. People who say “irregardless”, “normalcy”, or “healthful”.

Those last two are cromulent words though.

On SM-G981B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

It will always be Carlton.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Those last two are cromulent words though.

On SM-G981B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Not even remotely cromulent.

 

[Rhysoid]

Grew up hating Carlton the most (28 years old) but it's hard when they haven't been relevant for >20 years

Now Richmond is up there with utterly hateable characters like Tom Lynch, Jack Reiwoldt, Dimma Hardwick. Not to mention their bandwagon fans, I remember all of the Richmond fans coming out of the woodwork after they left 9th place behind and they couldn't have been more arrogant.

Special mention to Port Adelaide for bringing up the prison bars every year and being insufferable.

F*** West Coast and Willie rioli

15

Willie Rioli

Age

29

Ht

175cm

Wt

78kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.0

3star

K

8.0

3star

HB

4.1

3star

M

3.3

3star

T

2.8

4star

G

1.2

4star

No current season stats available

D

11.0

3star

K

7.4

3star

HB

3.6

3star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.8

4star

G

0.6

3star

.

 

[Corby_4]

West Coast are up there for mine, only because I live here and have to put up with their obnoxious, one eyed supporters.
Otherwise Blues, Bombers and Tigers naturally.

 

[Corby_4]

Grew up hating Carlton the most (28 years old) but it's hard when they haven't been relevant for >20 years

Now Richmond is up there with utterly hateable characters like Tom Lynch, Jack Reiwoldt, Dimma Hardwick. Not to mention their bandwagon fans, I remember all of the Richmond fans coming out of the woodwork after they left 9th place behind and they couldn't have been more arrogant.

Special mention to Port Adelaide for bringing up the prison bars every year and being insufferable.

F*** West Coast and Willie rioli.

Don't forget Sniper Cotchin.
He's on par with Lynch imo.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

How funny is it that when this poll was created in 2014, the Tigers were so irrelevant they were put in the other category. HAHA

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Agreed, but having grown up in Geelong on a diet of 3GL and Geelong advertiser bias and having seen first-hand the influence that that club has upon the community in oh so many negative ways Geelong top the heap by a significant margin.
I wish some intrepid non-biased journalist would examine Geelong's salary cap and whether certain businesses have non-productive employees on their books. I know it used to happen. I suspect that it still does.
I nearly puke whenever a commentator calls then a great club. They are parasites

Yes people should've cottoned on to the Costa living.

 

[WalterBlaknWhte]

Yes people should've cottoned on to the Costa living.

Yeah, seemed to have been a lot of cabbage to go around

 

[Dynamics]

Carlton.

It's always Carlton.

It will always be Carlton.









Carlton.

 

[Adversity10]

It's mainly due to the supporters, I can't stand Carlton fans they're extremely nonsensical, they cannot fathom they've been terrible for 20 years.

They pop up like seagulls chasing a chip when they start to look up and about, but few hard seasons and losses and the membership is in the microwave. They turn on their own so quickly, They are an absolute joke of a AFL "powerhouse"

 

[Monco Matt]

Carlton is the easy choice for obvious reasons, the history of '70 '79 & '81 and I agree of course. But, Carlton have been basically an irrelevant basket case for well over 20 years now. For me right now it is Geelong. 2007 PF, 2009 PF, 2011 GF, 2020 SF all sting and all are fresh in my mind, especially 2011. We would have won 2007 by the way if not for Gazza and his arrogant flog mates. Plus, the Cats are such a pain in the ass, even when you have them on the ropes out for the count the bastards just keep coming at you. Always feels great to beat them, we need to do it again soon. How good did that 2019 QF feel?

 

[adammania9]

Unrivalled:
1. Carlton - those grand finals came long before me. Doesn’t matter, that club is disgusting and rooted in cheating and deceit. F* everything about them

Hate:
2. Richmond - DH supporters didn’t deserve a dynasty. Could have lived with one flag. No supporter group has their heads more firmly up their asses

3. West Coast - even before 2018 I hated this noisy, overrated football club. They’re talked up as an on field juggernaut but they’re far from it. Arrogant, w***er supporters.

4. Essendon - so irrelevant that I almost feel sorry for them. Nothing to like about them.

5. St Kilda - stupid, irrelevant football club and always will be. Will never, ever feel sorry for them or their fair weather supporters

6. Brisbane - perhaps a little salty over two certain grand finals, but they’ve always had a large portion of DHs playing for them. Watching them fail miserably in finals has been a pleasure

7. Port Adelaide - hate how irrelevant they are. Think they’re a big deal but nobody would blink if they disappeared forever. Piss off.

Don’t care for:
GWS Giants
Western Bulldogs
Sydney Swans
Hawthorn

Indifferent toward:
Adelaide
Fremantle
Gold Coast
Geelong

Don’t mind:
North Melbourne
Melbourne

 

[La Dispute]

It's mainly due to the supporters, I can't stand Carlton fans they're extremely nonsensical, they cannot fathom they've been terrible for 20 years.

They pop up like seagulls chasing a chip when they start to look up and about, but few hard seasons and losses and the membership is in the microwave. They turn on their own so quickly, They are an absolute joke of a AFL "powerhouse"

2003, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2005, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2007, 15th of 16 = New club membership record
2018, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2019, 16th of 18 = New club membership record
2020, 11th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record
2021, 13th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record

Predictably the membership has spiked again this season as Carlton has climbed up the ladder, but our supporters are fiercely loyal and invested every year.

 

[Adversity10]

2003, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2005, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2007, 15th of 16 = New club membership record
2018, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2019, 16th of 18 = New club membership record
2020, 11th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record
2021, 13th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record

Predictably the membership has spiked again this season as Carlton has climbed up the ladder, but our supporters are fiercely loyal and invested every year.

A shame your average attendance for mentioned years didn't exactly stack up.

 

[Countrypie]

Yes people should've cottoned on to the Costa living.

Got it in one....but it dates back further. Long before Frank's time and long before the salary cap, they bled businesses dry to pay their heroes. It nearly killed my father who was a loyal employee of one such business

 

[Countrypie]

2003, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2005, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2007, 15th of 16 = New club membership record
2018, wooden spoon season = New club membership record
2019, 16th of 18 = New club membership record
2020, 11th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record
2021, 13th of 18, COVID impacted = New club membership record

Predictably the membership has spiked again this season as Carlton has climbed up the ladder, but our supporters are fiercely loyal and invested every year.

I'll give you that...but you'll never explain away Elliott or Harris. They have tarnished your mob forever in my eyes. I had great admiration for those Carlton teams of the early 70's. Jezza may have been the best of his time. Crosswell, McKay, Doull, Keogh, Ashman-all champions...but your admin were a pack of flogs.