Most overrated player from your own team

[Big Cox]

From Eagles its clearly Adam Hunter. Not a great defender. Cant play forward full time and is probably at a stage of his career where unless his form improves he will be moved aside by the likes of McKenzie Staker and co from the Eagles. His career is at the crossroads. Cant believe how much opposition fans rave on about him. Lynch is better than him but you wouldnt realise it

 

[Bring-Back-Powell]

Brock McLean based on his last 3 weeks.

 

[VoR]

Rowan bloody Jones!!!

God, I hate him...he's a ****ing joke of a player, the whole crowd is screaming 'HANDBALL' whenever he gets the ball. How get get a game week in week out is beyond me.

 

[Big Cox]

Brock McLean based on his last 3 weeks.

Jared Rivers from Melbourne. Injury on legs

 

[becky]

Andrew Welsh.

First class dud.

 

[Milkman]

From Eagles its clearly Adam Hunter. Not a great defender. Cant play forward full time and is probably at a stage of his career where unless his form improves he will be moved aside by the likes of McKenzie Staker and co from the Eagles. His career is at the crossroads. Cant believe how much opposition fans rave on about him. Lynch is better than him but you wouldnt realise it

There's a difference between being 'overrated' and being down on form.

Fickle.

 

[Cuzz09]

Rowan bloody Jones!!!

God, I hate him...he's a ****ing joke of a player, the whole crowd is screaming 'HANDBALL' whenever he gets the ball. How get get a game week in week out is beyond me.

Im pretty sure RoJo isn't OVER-rated - if anything he just isnt rated

 

[Milkman]

Rowan bloody Jones!!!

God, I hate him...he's a ****ing joke of a player, the whole crowd is screaming 'HANDBALL' whenever he gets the ball. How get get a game week in week out is beyond me.

That's why you aren't the coach.

 

[Jizza9]

At the moment Barry Hall.

 

[footy_4_life]

joel bowden !!!!!!!! enough said

 

[jules101]

Andrew Lovett - For the skill he has, the output isn't enough

 

[drew_j]

Andrew Lovett - For the skill he has, the output isn't enough

I didn't think anyone rate any Essendon players out side our supporters,.

 

[jules101]

Andrew Welsh.

First class dud.

Finished 6th best and fairest last year. Geez that makes everyone who finished below him pretty crap!

 

[Tonche]

Andrew Welsh.

First class dud.

No way.

 

[bluey17]

From Eagles its clearly Adam Hunter. Not a great defender. Cant play forward full time and is probably at a stage of his career where unless his form improves he will be moved aside by the likes of McKenzie Staker and co from the Eagles. His career is at the crossroads. Cant believe how much opposition fans rave on about him. Lynch is better than him but you wouldnt realise it

You're a moron Supporter since 2005?

 

[ToO]

Mark Coughlan

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

From Essendon would definately have to be Jobe Watson and David Hille
Watson too slow and Hille isnt a ruckmen
Adelaide - Scott Welsh - inconsistent

Brisbane - Cant think of anyone actually

Carlton - Lance Whitnall - shouldnt b captain

Collingwood - James Clement and Leon Davis - Clement plays loose. Shood be able to pick up 25 possesions as loose man. Davis is a flash in the pants

Fremantle - Jeff Farmer and Peter Bell - Farmer (same as Davis), Bell
reciever

Geelong - The whole team nah i dunno actually

Hawthorn - Trent Croad - most overrated player in the competition

Kangaroos - Shannon Grant and Brent Harvey - Grant and Harvey both receivers

Melbourne - Cameron Bruce and Aaron Davey - Bruce would be good if he could kick the ball and Davey cracks under pressure

Port Adelaide - No One

Richmond - Joel Bowden and Chris Newman - If anyone argues with this they have no idea. BIGGEST RECEIVERS IN THE COMPETITION always out the back for the cheap possesion

St.Kilda - Stephen Milne - only does something when the game is over

Sydney - Nick Davis and Heath Grundy - Davis only does something when he is on a shit defender and Grundy started well and where is he now

West Coast - Daniel Chick - done absolutely nothing this year at all

Western Bulldogs - Scott West - Easily

 

[becky]

Finished 6th best and fairest last year. Geez that makes everyone who finished below him pretty crap!

I don't care. he is a over rated dud in my opinion.

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

Jared Rivers from Melbourne. Injury on legs

One bout of OP and your calling him injury prone. Easily our best defender and in our top 5

 

[jules101]

I don't care. he is a over rated dud in my opinion.

Well dont let facts get in the way of your opinion...

 

[jules101]

From Essendon would definately have to be Jobe Watson and David Hille
Watson too slow and Hille isnt a ruckmen
Adelaide - Scott Welsh - inconsistent

Brisbane - Cant think of anyone actually

Carlton - Lance Whitnall - shouldnt b captain

Collingwood - James Clement and Leon Davis - Clement plays loose. Shood be able to pick up 25 possesions as loose man. Davis is a flash in the pants

Fremantle - Jeff Farmer and Peter Bell - Farmer (same as Davis), Bell
reciever

Geelong - The whole team nah i dunno actually

Hawthorn - Trent Croad - most overrated player in the competition

Kangaroos - Shannon Grant and Brent Harvey - Grant and Harvey both receivers

Melbourne - Cameron Bruce and Aaron Davey - Bruce would be good if he could kick the ball and Davey cracks under pressure

Port Adelaide - No One

Richmond - Joel Bowden and Chris Newman - If anyone argues with this they have no idea. BIGGEST RECEIVERS IN THE COMPETITION always out the back for the cheap possesion

St.Kilda - Stephen Milne - only does something when the game is over

Sydney - Nick Davis and Heath Grundy - Davis only does something when he is on a shit defender and Grundy started well and where is he now

West Coast - Daniel Chick - done absolutely nothing this year at all

Western Bulldogs - Scott West - Easily

Whats wih the font?
We suck without Hille in the team and would never win a clearance without Jobe

 

[becky]

Well dont let facts get in the way of your opinion...

Woewodin won a brownlow, he's still a dud by majority opinion.

 

[jonesy86]

Collingwood - James Clement and Leon Davis - Clement plays loose. Shood be able to pick up 25 possesions as loose man. Davis is a flash in the pants

leon davis...thats understandable

james clement...

 

[put me in coach]

Western Bulldogs - Scott West - Easily

WTF? Are you on drugs. West is an out and out Champion.

 

[jules101]

Woewodin won a brownlow, he's still a dud by majority opinion.

He wasn't a dud when he won the brownlow though was he?