LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
kouta 4 president said:
Um...how about NO! The only Carlton player who would be anywhere near that list is Fevola!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
My Top 50
- Thread starter SouthSwans
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Um...how about NO! The only Carlton player who would be anywhere near that list is Fevola!
So
Chad Cornes
Shaun Burgoyne
Brendon Lade
Warren Tredrea
Should all easily be in the top 50 looking at some of the players you got in there.
Or is there a hatred towards port adelaide? Seen by the "Carlton will beat Port" thread.... just maybe...
for the record
Chad Cornes >>>> Kane Cornes
Shaun Burgoyne >>> Kane Cornes
Warren Tredrea >>>> Kane Cornes
Chad Cornes
Shaun Burgoyne
Brendon Lade
Warren Tredrea
Should all easily be in the top 50 looking at some of the players you got in there.
Or is there a hatred towards port adelaide? Seen by the "Carlton will beat Port" thread.... just maybe...
for the record
Chad Cornes >>>> Kane Cornes
Shaun Burgoyne >>> Kane Cornes
Warren Tredrea >>>> Kane Cornes
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
- Thread starter
- #28
Kane Cornes >>>>>>>>>>>> Chad Cornes, Brendon Lade (who are stiff) >>>>>>> Shaun Burgoyne >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bar of Soap >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Tredrea
O'Keefe, R
Glass, D
Bassett, N
Thompson, N
McGregor, K
Newman, C
Johnson, B
Prestigiacomo, S
Robertson, R
Johnson, M
McDonald, J
Stenglein, T
and many more on your stupid list
Infact, if i were to say "i'll trade you Chad Cornes for R. O Keefe" or "Chad Cornes for S.Prestigiacomo", i know almost every single opposition coach would say "done deal" without even thinking twice
Your list sucks btw, plenty of other good players from other teams that are easily better than your team. Heck, I could probably make a team out of players not in your top 50, and beat your top 50.
Glass, D
Bassett, N
Thompson, N
McGregor, K
Newman, C
Johnson, B
Prestigiacomo, S
Robertson, R
Johnson, M
McDonald, J
Stenglein, T
and many more on your stupid list
Infact, if i were to say "i'll trade you Chad Cornes for R. O Keefe" or "Chad Cornes for S.Prestigiacomo", i know almost every single opposition coach would say "done deal" without even thinking twice
Your list sucks btw, plenty of other good players from other teams that are easily better than your team. Heck, I could probably make a team out of players not in your top 50, and beat your top 50.
- Banned
- #32
deeps said:
That last comment is terrible. The list is a good attempt. Put your side out there and see how you go.
Kings Army said:That last comment is terrible. The list is a good attempt. Put your side out there and see how you go.
Yup, was in the process of making it
B: Gilbee D. Wakelin A.Hunter
HB: Nicoski C.Cornes S.Burgoyne
C: Licuria M.Coughlan L.Power
HF: D.Wells W.Tredrea D.Giansiricusa
FF: S.Milne M.Richardson G.Ablett Jnr.
R: B.Lade S.Black L.Ball
INT: N.Davis , A.Mcleod, T.Simmonds, A.McPhee
Now techincally, he should be able to make two teams out of his list...and they should both win against my above team comfortably. Seeing as he has the best50 players...
I reckon this above team would give his best 22, and his second 22 a very very good run for their money.
He's obviously not going by this seasons form, as Matthew Lloyd is on his list...so i'm guessing he's going on past few seasons form, which is fair enough.
EDIT: I left our riewoldt, etc. that you said were hard done by...so you got 55 of the so called 'best players'
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
- Thread starter
- #34
Team 1
B: Clement, Glass, Edwards
HB: Goodes, Croad, P Bell
C: Goodwin, Judd, Ricciuto
HF: J Brown, Hall, Embley
F: Bradhnson, Pavlich, Buckley
R: Cox, West, Hodge
Int: Cousins, N Thompson, Williams, Harris
Team 2
B: Newman, Rutten, Bassett
HB: Bowden, Presty, McDonald
C: Bolton, Kerr, Dal Santo
HF: O'Keefe, Rocca, Robertson
F: Didak, Lloyd, Akermanis
R: Everitt, Johnstone, Mitchell
INT: Hird, Kirk, K Cornes, Bruce
B: Clement, Glass, Edwards
HB: Goodes, Croad, P Bell
C: Goodwin, Judd, Ricciuto
HF: J Brown, Hall, Embley
F: Bradhnson, Pavlich, Buckley
R: Cox, West, Hodge
Int: Cousins, N Thompson, Williams, Harris
Team 2
B: Newman, Rutten, Bassett
HB: Bowden, Presty, McDonald
C: Bolton, Kerr, Dal Santo
HF: O'Keefe, Rocca, Robertson
F: Didak, Lloyd, Akermanis
R: Everitt, Johnstone, Mitchell
INT: Hird, Kirk, K Cornes, Bruce
SouthSwans said:SS's Top 50
1 - Judd, C (WCE)
2 - Hall, B (Syd)
3 - Brown, J (BL)
4 - Goodwin, S (Ade)
5 - Pavlich, M (Fre)
6 - Ricciuto, M (Ade)
7 - Cox, D (WCE)
8 - West, S (WB)
9 - Hodge, L (Haw)
10 - Kerr, D (WCE)
11 - Edwards, T (Ade)
12 - Johnstone, T (Mel)
13 - Johnson, B (WB)
14 - Embley, A (WCE)
15 - Cousins, B (WCE)
16 - Hird, J (Ess)
17 - Bolton, J (Syd)
18 - Bowden, J (Ric)
19 - Lloyd, M (Ess)
20 - O'Keefe, R (Syd)
21 - Robertson, R (Mel)
22 - Goodes, A (Syd)
23 - Dal Santo, N (StK)
24 - Glass, D (WC)
25 - Buckley, N (Col)
26 - Kirk, B (Syd)
27 - Mitchell, S (Haw)
28 - Johnson, M (Ess)
29 - Cornes, K (PA)
30 - McDonald, J (Mel)
31 - Rutten, B (Ade)
32 - Bruce, C (Mel)
33 - Rocca, A (Col)
34 - Bassett, N (Ade)
35 - Stenglein, T (WCE)
36 - Bell, P (Fre)
37 - Thompson, N (Kan)
38 - Clement, J (Col)
39 - Croad, T (Haw)
40 - McGregor, K (Ade)
41 - Williams, M (Haw)
42 - Akermanis, J (BL)
43 - Didak, A (Col)
44 - Everitt, P (Haw)
45 - Carr, J (Fre)
46 - Harris, B (WB)
47 - Newman, C (Ric)
48 - Johnson, B (Col)
49 - Bartel, J (Gee)
50 - Prestigiacomo, S (Col)
Stiff: Riewoldt (StK), Archer (Kan), Fevola (Car), Ball, (StK), Richardson (Ric), McLeod (Ade), Barry (Syd), Whitnall (Car)
Thoughts?
Big Nick behind these battlers. Worst list ever!
Few querries in there, not totally sure what you are basign criteria on? This season or overall?
I will be doing my annual top 50 come the split round based purely on the performances from 2006.
I will be doing my annual top 50 come the split round based purely on the performances from 2006.
- Apr 8, 2006
- 42,412
- 44,281
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Dallas Cowboys and Texas Longhorns
Mark Johnson? Haha. Worst 50 perhaps.
Dream Boat
Rookie
SouthSwans said:
that is the worst top 50 i've seen...
the top 15 are ok but as for the rest... that is teerible. the callibre of players you have left out is amazing... just wondering if you are watching the right sport????????
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
- Thread starter
- #40
You do yours then. So willing to criticize but not willing to make suggestions.
It's impossible to make a decent top 50 unless you watch every game and every team closely, every week.
juddy_Like
Norm Smith Medallist
SouthSwans said:
OUT: bell, thompson, carr, aka and mark johnson (hes not in the top 100).
IN: riewoldt (top 20), fev (top 25) mcloud (top 40) whitnall, barry (top 50 or 52)
SouthSwans said:
My thoughts, your an idiot. Lloyd has played bugger all games and gets number 19! Hayes played 9 and should be there based on your silly list.. riewoldt behind prestigiacomo.. what a joke.. fevola is killin i this year in a sh*t side as is whitnall.. you absolute idiot
Erm, why the hell are people putting MATTHEW LLOYD on their lists when he is injuried and hasn't played much at all?
Players with long term injuries should be exempt. Unless you want to play them with their injuries, in Lloyd's case, on one leg.
Players with long term injuries should be exempt. Unless you want to play them with their injuries, in Lloyd's case, on one leg.
I always respect posters who post these up. Criteria is slightly confusing, but good list no doubt. Good to see the under-rated players in there. McDonald maybe a bit high, but yeah, good effort mate.
Also, where is Lenny Hayes? Riewoldt, Fev and McLeod mistakes, but oh well.
Also, where is Lenny Hayes? Riewoldt, Fev and McLeod mistakes, but oh well.
