Roast Negative only thread

[Mostyn]

Here's a thread for dispassionate, measured discussion of club stupidity.

No empty complaints, just classic Scorpus-isms that outline when the club has done something dumb against their own self interest.

Or maybe make complaints - whatever, I don't care, I'm not your mum.

I'll start. Signing an injured person to a six-month deal. If the player ALSO thinks it's surprisingly dumb, it was a bad decision.

 

[spenze]

Thread needs more cowbell

 

[George Kramer]

I like this new Moystn, better than those Kristof and Mego Red blokes.

Wow a positive and a negative post all in one.

 

[GROTTO]

Wait till they announce Sloane as captain of the Club for 2023.

 

[Big Dub]

I like this new Moystn, better than those Kristof and Mego Red blokes.

Wow a positive and a negative post all in one.

This is a negative only thread.

Enough with this positive sh*t.

 

[Ramify]

Here's a thread for dispassionate, measured discussion of club stupidity.

No empty complaints, just classic Scorpus-isms that outline when the club has done something dumb against their own self interest.

Or maybe make complaints - whatever, I don't care, I'm not your mum.

I'll start. Signing an injured person to a six-month deal. If the player ALSO thinks it's surprisingly dumb, it was a bad decision.

That time away from the board has done you the world of good brother.

And now that I finally have my safe space, I'm stuck for things to whinge about.

Kudos Kritsoff!

 

[Scorpus]

 

[Ramify]

Thread needs more cowbell

Here's a thread for dispassionate, measured discussion of club stupidity.

No empty complaints, just classic Scorpus-isms that outline when the club has done something dumb against their own self interest.

Or maybe make complaints - whatever, I don't care, I'm not your mum.

I'll start. Signing an injured person to a six-month deal. If the player ALSO thinks it's surprisingly dumb, it was a bad decision.

What are you talking about with "the player ALSO thinks it's surprisingly dumb " comment? Has he said this somewhere?

 

[Mostyn]

What are you talking about with "the player ALSO thinks it's surprisingly dumb " comment? Has he said this somewhere?

"Turner booted 4.1 and had 38 disposals against the Crows’ SANFL side in round 3 in April, but Adelaide’s mid-season interest surprised him because he had a foot injury."

 

[Anzacpaul]

We'll be a 7-12 side for at least 5 years yet, IF at least 1-2 of our current crop become bonafide guns.

If not see you in 10-12.

 

[Cap]

Wait till they announce Sloane as captain of the Club for 2023.

Captain for as long as the eye can see

 

[GROTTO]

Captain for as long as the eye can see

Till our next rebuild I would imagine if thats the case.

 

[Ramify]

We'll be a 7-12 side for at least 5 years yet, IF at least 1-2 of our current crop become bonafide guns.

If not see you in 10-12.

The list or the Coaching dept/Gameplan?

I don't understand watching Vanberlos career and thinking the guy would make for a good midfield Coach.
Yeah I get his attributes, his WC record etc. I just always viewed him as a very dumb footballer, hence his forte as a defensive/run-with mid.
Reckon Dmac had more creativity.

Dood, Just isn't an inspiring choice as Captain. I've spammed the board plenty enough about this.

We shouldn't have given up 5 for Rankine. It was lazy.

I'm going to pace myself here.

 

[GROTTO]

We'll be a 7-12 side for at least 5 years yet, IF at least 1-2 of our current crop become bonafide guns.

If not see you in 10-12.

I dont expect us to be a Premiership threat till around late 2020s.

 

[Cap]

Till our next rebuild I would imagine if thats the case.

So 2024

 

[Sanders]

Publicly offering pick 5 as a starting offer for Rankine, and then adding more to close

 

[1990crow]

Playing James Rowe for a large proportion of the second half of 2022 despite knowing full well he would be delisted.

 

[krrzr]

Thilthorpe dropped after round 1
Playing players wrong positions - Dawson at HB / Hately on the wing
Playing Crouch
Promising Strachan a block of games
No replacement for Butts when out with COVID
Playing Crouch (again)
Drafting an injured 25y/o
Rewarding Murphy/McHenry despite horrible form
Playing Doedee while injured
Playing Rowe despite knowing he will be delisted
Delisting Turner despite good form, What was the point in drafting him?

 

[jenny61_99]

Jesus, as if we need to encourage MORE negativity in here. FMD.

 

[George Kramer]

Jesus, as if we need to encourage MORE negativity in here. FMD.

Blasphemy is a negative as is this type of attitude.

When’s the last time you posted in the positive thread?

 

[jenny61_99]

Blasphemy is a negative as is this type of attitude.

When’s the last time you posted in the positive thread?

why bother? There is a core group of whingers and the whole board gets sucked into the spiral. Nobody is happy unless they’ve gotten something to bitch and complain about. Hell, you’ve even turned Kristof to the dark side!

 

[jenny61_99]

Blasphemy is a negative as is this type of attitude.

When’s the last time you posted in the positive thread?

 

[George Kramer]

why bother? There is a core group of whingers and the whole board gets sucked into the spiral. Nobody is happy unless they’ve gotten something to bitch and complain about. Hell, you’ve even turned Kristof to the dark side!

The funny thing is these whingers as you call them are actually balanced, it’s just there’s been a hell of a lot to be negative about since 2017. I’m sure we wouldn’t be whinging if the club had won a flag recently, it’s been 25 years right? Having a Mary Poppins view about the club isn’t contributing much

 

[Stephen2]

I still don't know the difference between Taylor & Turner. Can the club please rename players to make it easier for me? Ty.

 

[thebirdman 24]

Playing James Rowe for a large proportion of the second half of 2022 despite knowing full well he would be delisted.

So frustrating. Pretty much everyone knew he was getting delisted but we kept playing him like he was a retiring champion.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app