Opinion Non-Crows AFL 9

Which team will finish the 2024 season higher ranked?


  • Total voters
    56
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I read it just fine.

Liar Lying GIF by Australian Survivor
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Spelling mistake. Thanks will fix.

His statement of what action he would take is really irrelevant to the total point.

Adelaide is seen by other club leadership as compliant. A.k.a they are good boys and girls who do as they are told by leadership.

If that doesn't concern supporters that the club isn't fighting hard enough behind the scenes we clearly have different expectations of what a good football club does.
I think its all big words from someone with no skin in the fight. Where did Eddie take on the AFL and win while he was Collingwood president? Didn't the magpies just lose a whole heap of seating allocation for its members at the MCG?
 
Could be a couple of upsets this round, wouldn’t surprise me if the hawks beat the suns in tassie or eagles beat Richmond in Perth
Blues are riding for a fall too
 
I think its all big words from someone with no skin in the fight. Where did Eddie take on the AFL and win while he was Collingwood president? Didn't the magpies just lose a whole heap of seating allocation for its members at the MCG?

I reckon if you were at AFL House you’d be much more comfortable delivering bad news to the Crows than to Collingwood.
 
Could be a couple of upsets this round, wouldn’t surprise me if the hawks beat the suns in tassie or eagles beat Richmond in Perth
Suns-Hawks is in GC.

If the Eagles bring the same effort as the Swans game, they could get easily get it done.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I don't think Clarkson's slur and Finlayson's are equivalent, either.

Clarkson's should have been vastly higher in its punishment, but Finlayson's was probably the worst aggressive slur you could target to a gay man or woman.

I get frustrated how quickly people want to dismiss the comparison to Tex. I personally don't feel racist or homophobic slurs are any different from one another.
Also in the Walker case, his comment was ABOUT another person where the Clarkson and Finlayson comments were directly TO another person. Both are wrong but one of these examples has far less aggression involved.
 
I reckon if you were at AFL House you’d be much more comfortable delivering bad news to the Crows than to Collingwood.
If anything, on the give a shit factor the dial might be moved from 0 to 0.5

If this happened to Collingwood and Eddie was president, this wouldn’t be in the courts. That’s pretty much certain. What, does he think they’d overturn the result?
 
A homophobic slur is a homophobic slur - no matter who it is directed towards.

Is it the same though? If it’s the pure equal of racism, as many believe, then you’re saying that calling a white person a derogatory term for a black person is equally as bad as directing it to a black person. That sounds idiotic to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top