Bumped Omg not andy collins

[Tigerforlife78]

My personal highlight so far is we should have kept Collins and traded Rance.

I forgot how shit Rance was at one point lmao

Ahh the days of Dimma explaining Rance brain fades Glad I wasn't a poster then, I might have a few extra things to own up for .........

 

[tigs2010]

I will be very shitty with the RFC if this happens. Some people are right to say Collins has not achieved anything yet, but I still think he has the potential to be a very very good player for us in the future.

bad move by Richmond if true.

There was a time when Groupie made non-trolling posts lmao

 

[tigs2010]

In 2010, the only player to get more tackles then Simpson at Richmond was Tuck. And the only players at RFC to top Carrazzo and Gibbs in tackles were Tuck and Jackson.

So good one!

Btw, thanks for Collins, haven't heard to much of the guy but sounds like he has better character and footballing ability than Grigg the unskilled money chaser. If you're looking to build good club culture Grigg will not be doing you any favours.

Lmao righto old chap

Dat Carltank culture building.

 

[Tigerforlife78]

There was a time when Groupie made non-trolling posts lmao

Well thats smacked me, night done, Groupie_ was sober once

 

[tigs2010]

Straight swap, nothing else. Official.

Thanks guys.

No. Thank you. Was our pleasure.

 

[tigs2010]

I feel for you fans. They trade a contracted guy who loves the club and his team mates for a guy who wants to leave his team mates for more cash. As for talent level of players I also think Collins suits you guys better with his skill level which compliments Martin, Foley, Cotch, Tuck etc. I think Hartley and Cameron have gotten a bit cute with this.

Seemed to work in the end. Reckon Hirdy got a bit "cute" with his injection program but maybe one day it will turn out ok.

 

[tigs2010]

You've been Swanned.

Would love to give you guys some good word on Grigg but I've never rated him cause he's unskilled. But now he is unskilled and a turncoating, money chasing dog. Have fun with that.

Hahahahahaha oh boy this is one rage filled post. Just wanted to check that you're ok 5 years down the track?

Let's recap shall we?

The only team that has been swanned is Carlton.

They've also gone for the double and Trigg'd themselves

And for the trifecta, Grigg would be your best mid and with no forward line or back line he would be your best player by default.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Have the Andy Collins fan club recovered yet?

For safety's sake take Vincent's.

 

[Boston tiger]

Probably would have won a premiership by now if we had kept Collins. As it is we haven't won a final with Grigg.
These threads are great.

 

[_RT_]

The amount of posters in this thread that should be going through deleting posts is astounding. Collins went on to do sweet FA for Carlton and is no longer on an AFL list, while Grigg has become an important player in our line up. I can see something similar happening if we end up trading McBean to get Yarran.

 

[Bic]

I'm going to get Collins number on my jumper.

lol

 

[Lsta062]

The amount of posters in this thread that should be going through deleting posts is astounding. Collins went on to do sweet FA for Carlton and is no longer on an AFL list, while Grigg has become an important player in our line up. I can see something similar happening if we end up trading McBean to get Yarran.

I can't. I can see Yarran become a serviceable player for Richmond, but I can't see McBean do nothing for Carlton. He'll probably end up in their best 22 and become a reliable and consistent forward

 

[Groupie_]

There was a time when Groupie made non-trolling posts lmao

had no clue was just following all the other sheep

 

[Old M8]

F*ck this, I'm writing a letter to the club if this goes through.

Did they respond?

 

[Pklz]

No. Thank you. Was our pleasure.

Don't rate Grigg any more than I did in the past. Probably think less of him of his ability now really. But that probably just shows I was overrating both his and Collins abilities.

Happy for you guys to get the most out of him but he's not exactly the player I'd start bumping threads about

 

[Groupie_]

Don't rate Grigg any more than I did in the past. Probably think less of him of his ability now really. But that probably just shows I was overrating both his and Collins abilities.

Happy for you guys to get the most out of him but he's not exactly the player I'd start bumping threads about

Grigg would be your best player. We've finally un carltooned him

 

[Pklz]

Grigg would be your best player. We've finally un carltooned him

Please.

Not a trade that anyone at Carlton would have lost sleep over after all these years.

 

[Groupie_]

Please.

Not a trade that anyone at Carlton would have lost sleep over after all these years.

Yeah but a trade you lost and a player that would be one of if not your best

 

[Pklz]

Yeah but a trade you lost and a player that would be one of if not your best

We lost the trade, yes. But he wouldn't be in our best players. In my opinion he wouldn't be in your top 12 players either.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

While Grigg is no world beater he does a very serviceable job as a run with player.

If Dennis Armfield is still on your list and getting games then Grigg would get games for Carlton

 

[_RT_]

While Grigg is no world beater he does a very serviceable job as a run with player.

If Dennis Armfield is still on your list and getting games then Grigg would get games for Carlton

Now now don't upset the trolls

 

[tigs2010]

While Grigg is no world beater he does a very serviceable job as a run with player.

If Dennis Armfield is still on your list and getting games then Grigg would get games for Carlton

Grigg would have been Carlton's second highest vote getter in the brownlow in 2012 behind Judd. Judd is gone and Grigg has improved. Therefore he'd be their best

 

[tigs2010]

Don't rate Grigg any more than I did in the past. Probably think less of him of his ability now really. But that probably just shows I was overrating both his and Collins abilities.

Happy for you guys to get the most out of him but he's not exactly the player I'd start bumping threads about

Probably should watch more footy then. Goal kicking taggers aren't exactly common.

Please.

Not a trade that anyone at Carlton would have lost sleep over after all these years.

Well yeah that Swann bloke left. And I'd imagine people still at Carlton have plenty of their own shit to lose sleep over

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Ok fess up.Who changed their name from Mario Speedwagon?

 

[Mogwai]

If Carlton had kept Griggs they wouldn't have gone for Wood for a second ruckman