List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[danielnajdek]

We’ve literally got Melbourne’s F1 (potentially a top 5 pick) + 28 for 13 on the table. Even if we don’t have Norths F1 that’s an incredible offer.

Look Noble is a decent player and I would want him, but that’s negligence by us if we don’t take that offer if yours is only 13 & 23 for Noble & F1.

We could get Melb F1 + 28 and then offer you 23 for Noble, and we still come out of that way better even if you don’t ask for 23.

And if you want to hold Noble sure that’s fine, but again, we have a potential top 5 pick plus a 2nd rounder on the table for just 13. We have to take that.

We wont take 23 for Noble. Perhaps you shouldn't be chasing players under contract then trying to get them for nothing.

 

[Jen2310]

If only

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

maynard? Beau?
Both from SA
Trying to figure out the rung between elite thats the player isn't, and fringe player which you wouldn't get anything for.

 

[3rdMan]

We’ve literally got Melbourne’s F1 (potentially a top 5 pick) + 28 for 13 on the table. Even if we don’t have Norths F1 that’s an incredible offer.

Look Noble is a decent player and I would want him, but that’s negligence by us if we don’t take that offer if yours is only 13 & 23 for Noble & F1.

We could get Melb F1 + 28 and then offer you 23 for Noble, and we still come out of that way better even if you don’t ask for 23.

And if you want to hold Noble sure that’s fine, but again, we have a potential top 5 pick plus a 2nd rounder on the table for just 13. We have to take that

What makes it incredible? Only your assumption Melbourne could drop down near bottom four. I could tell you Collingwood could do that.

Suns are currently involved in a multi club deal where every club wants something from the other. You'll need a compelling reason to blow that up and move to separate deals. Not sure this is it.

 

[Matt_352]

maynard?
Trying to figure out the rung between elite thats the player isn't, and fringe player which you wouldn't get anything for.

Whoever it is I think it's stupid idea

 

[GCS in 11]

You really banking on Melbourne falling that far? Petracca and Oliver turn up cherry ripe round 1 and they could be right up there again and you're looking at a teens pick anyway. Id say this is more of a chest puff to Collingwood to stump up more

I mean Melbourne was 14th this year and have all the signs of a club about to implode and finish bottom 4, especially if Oliver leaves. You are a good chance of rebounding back to top 4, especially if you get Houston.

Sure it’s still probability, but their F1 has much, much more value than yours (which is good for you for competing next year, just not for trade value)

 

[MooreDaicos]

maynard? Beau?
Both from SA
Trying to figure out the rung between elite thats the player isn't, and fringe player which you wouldn't get anything for.

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TradeDraft]

How much do the Suns pay you to come to this board to espouse your masturbatory conceptions ?

Suns have an Actual Fan?

 

[LuckyLee]

We wont take 23 for Noble. Perhaps you shouldn't be chasing players under contract then trying to get them for nothing.

Do you truly believe that we wouldn't take pick 23 for Noble as a stand-alone deal?

 

[Matt_352]

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Better not be someone key for our future like Ed

 

[Jen2310]

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

young player, or mid to late 20?

 

[HFF]

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

As in we are chasing or who you say is departing?

 

[Pistol Night]

I mean Melbourne was 11th this year and have all the signs of a club about to implode and finish bottom 4, especially if Oliver leaves. You are a good chance of rebounding back to top 4, especially if you get Houston.

Sure it’s still probability, but their F1 has much, much more value than yours (which is good for you for competing next year, just not for trade value)

Bit of a gamble to take to sacrifice a best 22 player that you've offered 3 years to. Noble and Rioli on back flanks would have Dimma thinking about a 4th flag and a 3rd wife

 

[danielnajdek]

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Why don't you just say the name. This cryptic bullshit is annoying af.

 

[JuniorB]

To be fair he has been known to go early.

"Aisho goin' nowhere".....so he does have game!

He's grown older and wiser.

 

[Pistol Night]

How much do the Suns pay you to come to this board to espouse your masturbatory conceptions ?

At least hes civil

 

[3rdMan]

I mean Melbourne was 11th this year and have all the signs of a club about to implode and finish bottom 4, especially if Oliver leaves. You are a good chance of rebounding back to top 4, especially if you get Houston.

Sure it’s still probability, but their F1 has much, much more value than yours (which is good for you for competing next year, just not for trade value)

Pies finished 9th and have an older list. I don't think there's much different in the prospects of Dees and Pies in 2025. Both are more likely to make the 8 than miss it, but it's an even comp

 

[GCS in 11]

How much do the Suns pay you to come to this board to espouse your masturbatory conceptions ?

I do it for free, we haven’t won anything for 14 years, this might be the first win we’ve had in that time and it’s only a trade

 

[LuckyLee]

It's not a beloved player.

On SM-A135F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Lipinski!

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

I mean Melbourne was 14th this year and have all the signs of a club about to implode and finish bottom 4, especially if Oliver leaves. You are a good chance of rebounding back to top 4, especially if you get Houston.

Sure it’s still probability, but their F1 has much, much more value than yours (which is good for you for competing next year, just not for trade value)

To be fair this is sort of true.

I think the think holding this Melb/GCS deal out is that the Suns know that Rioli + Noble zipping off the HB line will be a sight to see.

 

[Pistol Night]

I do it for free, we haven’t won anything for 14 years, this might be the first win we’ve had in that time and it’s only a trade

At least you've stemmed the flow of players wanting to leave. Luko aside. Got a solid core now

 

[celestial]

Let's just avoid pick 13 , and use F1 to get picks and manoeuver around to get a better draft hand. There are creative solutions to get a very good hand if Collingwood can just open their eyes and not get sucked into pick 13 sweepstakes.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Geez this might not end up happening at all. Noble stays and no Houston.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Geez this might not end up happening at all. Noble stays and no Houston.

What? Houston is incoming and Noble gone.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Wtf are Hawks thinking trading pick 14 in a strong draft for Blues future picks? Weird

 

[LuckyLee]

Geez this might not end up happening at all. Noble stays and no Houston.

Yep. To our detriment. Our window is right now. Load up and go for it. Houston would significantly improve our chances.