List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[unplugged]

Still makes too much sense to do a 3 way trade.

But otherwise

Noble, F1, 36

For 13, 23, 41

???

 

[swoop42]

GC will want it involved in the deal. Lukosius deal gets really ugly for them if it's separate.

Why?

I can't see how it greatly changes what PA or GC will be prepared to give up or ask for in regards to trade or salary contributions.

Port have been given permission to use a future 1st round pick regardless of any deal involving Houston I believe, while I thought it had been reported that GC wanted to keep any deal for Lukosius separate.

At the end of the day if you're right and GC believes they can benefit from Lukosius being included in a 3 club trade, they should be more pliable in any deal for 13, 23 and Noble.

Trades don't need to be won like it's a game of football IMO. They should be about acting in good faith, balance and trying to achieve the fairest result for all.

 

[tmpies01]

lol it’s just done for theatre. No big trade will get done until prime time on Wednesday night. The same thing happens every year

Yeah has that feel about it. No players traded again today… only chaos lol. It’s obvious this is all set up to keep eyes and ears on next week…

 

[Basil brush]

Still makes too much sense to do a 3 way trade.

But otherwise

Noble, F1, 36

For 13, 23, 41

???

I like it.

All comes down to what port want for Houston

 

[3rdMan]

All the clubs involved already know everything he’s saying, as do the media. Doesn’t affect the trade one iota in my humble opinion.

I don't have a problem with what Leppa has said, assuming that it's calculated.

If its defensive, wanting to respond to media claims of "selling the future farm", or to show the complexities hoping to tamp down backlash if the deal fails, then it's not great.

The former is more likely I feel, but this is Leppa's first deal in the role, so we'll see how it plays out.

 

[NMBB]

Doesn’t affect the trade one iota in my humble opinion.

We don't do humble opinions here...

 

[Everybody Panic]

Glad we're into Humphries. Keep in his ear for the future. Worst case scenario we keep Noble or get an okay draft picks. Perryman already a positive. Richards is annoying. Very good prospect at next year's draft. We don't have to overpay. I think Port and Suns will try and squeeze and we have no need to worry.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Wouldn't have thought it's that much to think on.

 

[Pie_high]

we’d likely cave-in and accept because we really don’t want to keep Noble against his will.

I'd be happy to keep Noble if we don't land Houston.

 

[HFF]

Port Adelaide also need some form of draft capital in this years pool.
Especially if they’re to send their future 1 to Port for Lukosius

Suns basically have a call to make that has ramifications on getting their man and offloading one of their men too

 

[tmpies01]

Maybe this will make us cough up more.

 

[3rdMan]

Still makes too much sense to do a 3 way trade.

But otherwise

Noble, F1, 36

For 13, 23, 41

???

Something like that. I just don't think the other pick 13 deals are strong enough for Suns to walk away from the multi team deal. Maybe we end up accepting 29 rather than 23.

Melbourne's the only chance, depends what Suns want to do with the second rounder and whether 28 vs 36 makes much difference, or whether they think we'll move up the ladder and the Dees will be significantly lower.

 

[WakeUpPies]

I’m sure our senior brigade would love a couple of 17/18 year olds over the best half-back in the league.

 

[Pistol Night]

I'd be happy to keep Noble if we don't land Houston.

Don't you like Collingwood?

 

[HFF]

If they trade 13 out to the Dees and we pull Noble off the table…
They’ll be overpaying even more than ever for Rioli out of desperation …
Crazy times ahead

 

[Jen2310]

Never seen so much attention over 1 pick.

 

[Pistol Night]

I’m sure our senior brigade would love a couple of 17/18 year olds over the best half-back in the league.

Win another flag and we can poach some young talent anyway.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Going to be pretty ****ing annoyed if we come out of this without 13 or Houston

 

[Jen2310]

Clubs will convene over the weekend and work on deals, so come monday I reckon we may have more clarity on whats going on with this pick and these deals

 

[HFF]

Maybe this will make us cough up more.

Or maybe that will make them cough up more for Rioli when we pull Noble off the table and keep him.

Which means Richmond will bleed them even more and they’d end up with even less in the end

 

[Bramax]

Don't you like Collingwood?

Not as much as us.
Besides, not landing Houston makes Noble a required player. I’m Leppa is telling GCS this.

 

[Chameleon75]

Going to be pretty ****ing annoyed if we come out of this without 13 or Houston

if we get 13 we get Houston, if we don’t get Houston it’s because we didn’t get 13.

 

[3rdMan]

Never seen so much attention over 1 pick.

Blues just traded for pick 14, I'm not sure why the Dees, Dogs, Swans weren't pushing for that pick. Seems at least Dees and Swans could have outbid them.

 

[Jen2310]

Blues just traded for pick 14, I'm not sure why the Dees, Dogs, Swans weren't pushing for that pick. Seems at least Dees and Swans could have outbid them.

Its like nobody knew that pick was on the table so quick. Smart by carlton. Everyone else werent' paying attention.

 

[Pie_high]

Don't you like Collingwood?

Why not? Noble is one of my favourite players. Has limitations but always gives 100%.

Sure Houston would be an upgrade, but IF we don't get him, I'd welcome John back with open arms.