Pick the next 5 brownlow's.

[liam_13]

2011-ryan griffen
2012-chris judd
2013-gary ablett
2014-scott pendlebury
2015-jack redden

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

2011 don't care
2012 don't care
2013 really don't care
2014 couldn't care less
2015 who gives a f%@k

 

[liam_13]

Or some middle of the road player who nobody rates just bursts out of the blocks to become a superstar?

It's hard enough to tell who is going to win the Brownlow this year or the next, let alone 5 years down the track. Thread belongs on the dung heap.

Jesus christ, its just a prediction thread.

If you don't want to predict anything and just be a knob why bother posting?

 

[LordJimmy]

In b4 Judd every year joke.

****

Anyway:

2011: Dane Swan
2012: Scott Pendlebury
2013: Dustin Martin
2014: Dustin Martin
2015: Dustin Martin

 

[Donakebab]

Jesus christ, its just a prediction thread.

If you don't want to predict anything and just be a knob why bother posting?

Something wrong with pointing out the obvious? It's like asking who will win the rising star in 5 or 10 years time, impossible to tell.

 

[AG]

Something wrong with pointing out the obvious? It's like asking who will win the rising star in 5 or 10 years time, impossible to tell.

Maybe guess the first name of them then?

2011 - Dyson Heppell
2012 - Bob
2013 - James
2014 - Nathan
2015 - Adam

 

[cancat]

2011 Chappy
2012 Judd
2013 Ablett
2014 Ablett
2015 Ablett

 

[Super Hans]

2011-Judd/Pendles
2012-Simon Black
2013-Ablett
2014-Ryan Griffen
2015-Joel Selwood/Dustin Martin

 

[Danair]

2011 - Pendlebury
2012 - Murphy
2013 - Pendlebury
2014 - Scully
2015 - D Swallow

 

[Belnakor]

They'd have to be pretty damn good indeed to win a Brownlow within 5 years.

Judd won in his 3 year..

 

[WakeUpPies]

Judd
Goodes
Judd
Goodes
Judd

lulz

2011 - Scott Pendlebury
2012 - Scott Pendlebury
2013 - Ablett
2014 - Dustin Martin
2015 - Boak if he leaves Port

 

[Mayes]

Pendlebury
Hodge
Murphy
Dangerfield
Swallow

 

[Pie eyed]

2011: Scott Emblebury
2012: Scott Pendleton
2013: Scott Emberton
2014: Scott Emblebury (Dual)
2015: Scott Swan/Dane Pendlebunton (Tie)

but only if Briedis is presenting.

 

[Anth_5]

Judd

2015 - Boak if he leaves Port

I LOL'd

 

[Looney]

How many times has Judd been BOG this year? Apart from last week he hasn't reallly stood out.

 

[Goo]

How many times has Judd been BOG this year? Apart from last week he hasn't reallly stood out.

Not particularly relevant.

 

[Strahany]

2011 - Judd. Demetriou gets all players leading him suspended - one for looking at an umpire aggressively

2012 - Judd. Plays 10 games after a groin injury (giggity) in the season break. Gets 3 votes each game just for turning up.

2013 - Kieran Jack. Demetriou accidentally highlights Jack's name for the brownlow at the beginning of the season after getting smashed drinking $10,000 bottles of wine on his new $4 Billion contract.

JUDD RETIRES EARLY.
DEMETRIOU INTRODUCES NEW "WHO WOULD HAVE SCORED VOTES" SYSTEM FOR PAST PLAYERS, COMPETING FOR THE SAME BROWNLOW WITH CURRENT PLAYERS.​

2014 - Judd. New record, winning with 61 votes - Demetriou thought it would be suss to award 3 votes in ALL games.

2015 - Judd. Demtriou gets caught out from last year due to the ridiculously high vote count. Judd wins with 15 votes after every other player miraculously finishes on 12 for the year.

 

[alex 17]

The games in big strife if Swallow wins one.

Seems like you dont rate Andrew Swallow? It would not surprise me in the slightest if he comes close or wins one in the next two or three years.

2011- Swan
After that who knows

 

[saintkildaman]

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Pendles
4. A.Swallow
5. S.Hill

 

[Poseidon]

1. Judd
2. Pendlebury
3. Murphy
4. Ablett
5. Hill

 

[Bubba_5]

2011 - Martin
2012 - Hill
2013 - Dangerfield
2014 - Swallow
2015 - Liberatore

 

[AG]

How many times has Judd been BOG this year? Apart from last week he hasn't reallly stood out.

Friday night was probably his first real clear BOG. Every other round apart form Essendon, he has been one of Carlton's best 2 or 3 imo. That's all he needs really. Murphy the only threat for him at this stage.

In all seriousness I think he will join the triple Charlie's this year.

 

[Poseidon]

In my opinion Murphy should be leading Carlton's B&F right now, but who knows what the umpires think.

 

[Prem87]

2011 - Judd
2012 - Judd
2013 - Shuey
2014 - Darling
2015 - Natainui

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Anyone consider the faint possibility that there might be some new, potentially quite good footballers coming into the league over the next few years that could well render this thread obsolete and futile?

The fact that Bartel and Ablett wouldn't have even been on Geelong supporters' radars as soon-to-be crowned Brownlow Medallists five years ago makes me think this is an exercise in futility. And Cooney was probably the same, can't really remember if he'd finally made the leap from a talented underachiever to a certified elite player by 2006.

EDIT: Probably should add Swan has been the favourite the past two years and he was a nobody in 2006.