Umpires…I watched a rovers game early in the season and they looked like they were very old and couldn’t keep up with the game. Will the league use GV umpires for the finals with more available.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Picola & District Discussion 2022
- Thread starter theintimidator
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Flyasone1405
Rookie
- Mar 27, 2018
- 33
- 21
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Hearing some whispers that Finley and Barooga are wanting to join the pdfnl.
Any truth to this?
Any truth to this?
Running on Empty
Rookie
- Jun 4, 2021
- 29
- 30
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Not sure if GV Umps would be a good idea, from the games I watched they don't play the stand on the mark. Like it or love it there would be too many 50's awarded imo
Cheap Kicks
Debutant
The comp would have to split if that occurred too many teams, unless there were clubs that fold which hopefully doesn’t occur.
Multiple people were at finals at the weekend who have watched games in neighbour leagues during the year and commented positively on the umpiring. Sure they are like footballers and make mistakes , but there has seemingly never been greater satisfaction in umpiring . Spoke to many clubs and they believe umpiring has improved and continues to improve every year .
What did u think of the umpires
You’d suspect one of them replaces Yarroweyah.
Whats the crack
Team Captain
- May 7, 2017
- 360
- 132
- AFL Club
- Sydney
No chance
Cheap Kicks
Debutant
If any club would I would think Tally would be one that suits probably.
But I was thinking after 2 years of interrupted Footy seasons why would clubs want to change leagues? You'd think just getting back on the park and some normality would be best for all.
Big comp when you add the 3 from
the KDL and the clubs from golden Rivers rumoured to be joining . Assume it will be 2 x 11 team comps ?
Flyasone1405
Rookie
- Mar 27, 2018
- 33
- 21
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
2 x 11 team comps
Div 1 & 2.
Relegation system with bottom two from div 1 dropping down and top 2 from div 2 going up.
Total club points system based on each team finishing position after finals.
Running on Empty
Rookie
- Jun 4, 2021
- 29
- 30
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I would think the "roar" would be on the money for finals with a weekly pool of 28 umps you would expect that hopefully the best 2 umpires do the game
Which 3 clubs from the KDL??
Geography may suggest Wakool, or maybe Macorna. That would have to mean an East/West or North/South split.
Wakool to Tungamah - 195km one-way
Macorna to Tungamah - 207km one-way
Hay to Tungamah - 251 km one-way
Roota, does Macorna have to do many long distance treks in the GRFNL apart from the trip to Hay (237km one-way) at the moment?
Wakool to Tungamah - 195km one-way
Macorna to Tungamah - 207km one-way
Hay to Tungamah - 251 km one-way
Roota, does Macorna have to do many long distance treks in the GRFNL apart from the trip to Hay (237km one-way) at the moment?
Wakool don’t exist anymore so that rules them out.
Macorna to Moulamein is about 120kms
Macorna to Ultima is about 110kms
Macorna would be a better fit in the Loddon Valley league to be honest
Tally, Dookie, Shepp East?
The influence of younger players in PDFNL finals can never be underestimated . Younger players for Katunga were great all game whilst Tungamah’s youngest player threatened half way through and then had massive influence in the last in normal time and the two in extra time, including kicking the last .
Well done by both sides great game, played within the right spirit, hard but nothing untoward .
Cheap Kicks
Debutant
It must have been a great watch! Finals are a fantastic time of the year. I would have loved to see an upset!
I am looking forward to today's game think it should be a ripper so making the trip to have a look.
Whats the crack
Team Captain
- May 7, 2017
- 360
- 132
- AFL Club
- Sydney
And you would have gotten to see the super powerful waaia side. Far too quick and well drilled and it's theirs to lose if the weather is clear
Cheap Kicks
Debutant
They were slick! Good luck getting them I feel after a week off now to rest up.
Cheap Kicks
Debutant
This weekend's matches should be an interesting battle.
Katandra and Katunga will be a tight game, Katunga had a tough and tiring game v Tungamah might actually help Katandra having the week off and being fresh.
Strathy v Katty seems like Strahty has had the wood over Katty even in previous years when Katty was probably stronger think Strathy will get over the top of them and feel Strathy has more dangerous players across the park
Katandra and Katunga will be a tight game, Katunga had a tough and tiring game v Tungamah might actually help Katandra having the week off and being fresh.
Strathy v Katty seems like Strahty has had the wood over Katty even in previous years when Katty was probably stronger think Strathy will get over the top of them and feel Strathy has more dangerous players across the park
Flyasone1405
Rookie
- Mar 27, 2018
- 33
- 21
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
And then there were 4…. Who wins from here?
chippy
Rookie
I’m tipping tungamah v waaia grand final. Flip of the coin on the winner I’m leaning towards tungamah in a thriller.
