-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player Comparison Thread - Part 2
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
Try 91.64 from rounds 12-22. Unless you mean rounds 13-22 and Adelaide's only final? Then he averaged 84.09.
What about this then? Over rounds 1-12 he averaged 110.08. Wouldn't that make more of a case of picking him early rather than upgrading to him later in the year??
You'd hope that people would research any player they pick, rather than taking notice of one posters comment which are clearly made out of context (and not 100% correct)
He scored 908 points in his last 11 matches. 908/11 = 82.5.
I know, he was my captain for all 12 of those weeks
. From averaging 110 to 82 is a sharp dip though, if anyone is going to consider him as an option I'd hope they've considered why that drop occurred.
- Jul 15, 2008
- 371
- 238
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Marty Clarke
vs
Jed Adcock
vs
Bachar Houli?
vs
Jed Adcock
vs
Bachar Houli?
houli
Crows were something like 8-3 after 11 rounds. When the Crows are winning, Thompson is almost always scoring well.
This year the Crows have a much harder draw than last year so I'd advise staying away from Thompson.
Looking at the crows draw, i think he might start slowly and be a cheap upgrade target mid year hopefully.
Hey guys,
This could be really crucial to selecting my team. Here goes:
S. Lucas - worried about he'll be able to recapture his high DT'ing form
S. Hill (freo) - how many games will he play? how good will he be?
L. Montagna
OR
C. Masten - will he be able to earn himself keeper status?
T. Collier - similar issues to hill
T. Tuck - will he play the first third of the season?
ALL HELP APPRECIATED
thanks.
This could be really crucial to selecting my team. Here goes:
S. Lucas - worried about he'll be able to recapture his high DT'ing form
S. Hill (freo) - how many games will he play? how good will he be?
L. Montagna
OR
C. Masten - will he be able to earn himself keeper status?
T. Collier - similar issues to hill
T. Tuck - will he play the first third of the season?
ALL HELP APPRECIATED
thanks.
- Aug 23, 2007
- 3,907
- 24
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Rory Sloane
Ummm easily the 2nd option.
That's interesting because I'm leaning heavily towards the first option. I suppose it really breaks down to Tuck & Masten vs Montagna & Lucas. Montagna avg about 95 two years ago so he has a fairly high ceiling and Lucas is a best 22 player (the same can't necessarily be said for Tuck).
Can you let me know why you think it's such an easy decision?
catsdynasty
Team Captain
I have been tossing up between these to for a while and can afford either Brent Harvey or Daniel Gia. Who do you think is the smarter option, I'm leaning on Boomer as I know what he can do. Yet I also know what Gia can produce. So who do you think is the smarter option??
Cheers,
Cheers,
id be going woth grimes and kornes
however i think i like cross this year more so than kornes. im sure neither will dissapoint tho.
Juddtastic
Team Captain
I have been tossing up between these to for a while and can afford either Brent Harvey or Daniel Gia. Who do you think is the smarter option, I'm leaning on Boomer as I know what he can do. Yet I also know what Gia can produce. So who do you think is the smarter option??
Cheers,
It's hard to split these two IMO, i think over the course of the year both players will average something very similar and their prices for this year obviously reflect that..
There was a thread earlier this year documenting how Harvey has a slowish start to the year which could be a deciding factor in your decision as he is a little more likely to become cheaper earlier in the year thus making a good upgrade option once you start using your trades
ZIEBELL OR HENTSCHEL big debate
in my opinion i think hentschel is better as he is more guaranteed to play first 11 games and can bag a couple of cheeky 5 goal games and should play more game time and his coach isnt dean laidley and adelaide have a great medical team so he should be taken care of after 2 years
in my opinion i think hentschel is better as he is more guaranteed to play first 11 games and can bag a couple of cheeky 5 goal games and should play more game time and his coach isnt dean laidley and adelaide have a great medical team so he should be taken care of after 2 years
personally id go cross and gia.
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
What do people think of these players for the 7th back? Looking to get a 2nd player under $190k - already got Raines.
Collier v Grimes v Hill
Also, interested on people's thoughts on Swan v Kornes.
I think Kornes is a little underpriced, but then it's hard to go past Swan. Both durable, but who's got the more potential?
Collier v Grimes v Hill
Also, interested on people's thoughts on Swan v Kornes.
I think Kornes is a little underpriced, but then it's hard to go past Swan. Both durable, but who's got the more potential?
- Status
Similar threads
- Sticky
