Dunn - Well Done
Cancelled
- Banned
- #426
How bad is the Brennan injury?? anyone know??
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player Comparison Thread - Part 2
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Adcock + Swan + 15K
or
Lockyer + J.Selwood/S.Tuck + 65K
or
Lockyer + J.Selwood/S.Tuck + 65K
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
I'd go option 2. Adcock is no guarantee to score well and be a keeper, and I think Selwood could easily average 95-100 this year. Sure you got those money amounts right?
- Jul 15, 2008
- 371
- 238
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Sam Fisher vs Brendan Goddard?
Both have potential to rack up huge scores this year.
Both have potential to rack up huge scores this year.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 37,308
- 34,471
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Atletico
Raines v Yarran/Sidebottom v N Krakouer
bombers own
Senior List
Adcock or Malceski+cash?
Raines is in a different position but i understand what you are doing. I believe Raines is the safest option.
I have both, but I would pick Goddard ahead because he has a huge body which helps him in the midfield. Gets a lot of the ball in the midfield and it was proven last year. He also will kick goals and get cheap kicks.
Malceski is probablly the better option. I don't see why much will change for Adcock this year. Macleski is fit and may be back to his 2007 form.
kornes + gia + skipworth
v
Corey v Pavlich v Rich
v
Corey v Pavlich v Rich
j.selwood + s.tuck
vs
Bartel + Maten
Oh, and i already have Ablett
vs
Bartel + Maten
Oh, and i already have Ablett
Then Selwood, Tuck. If you already have Ablett than you don't really need Bartel as a captaincy option, and the first option gives you two keepers which have the potential to elevate to premium level. Masten is a much riskier proposition.
I dont know if Tuck is a potential premium. He will be lucky to average 80, which is what Masten will be shooting for too. Plus Masten' spot in the 22 is secure, Tuck could lose his at any stage.
That said I would go Bartel. If you already have Ablett, it makes your side too top heavy. Coud you get a Swan/Kornes type + Masten and use the spare cash to upgrade someone else?
That said I would go Bartel. If you already have Ablett, it makes your side too top heavy. Coud you get a Swan/Kornes type + Masten and use the spare cash to upgrade someone else?
Just to clarify, it is Tuck from Richmond not from Hawthorn.
One more question from me:
Malceski + Krakeour
or
Lockyer + Ziebell
Haha whoops. Teach me to only skim read. 
In that case, go Selwood + Tuck. Those are two legitimate keepers, and like I (and S-KFC) said you dont need Bartel as a captain, you already have Ablett.
I wouldnt go either out of those two new options. Maybe Lockyer, but im not sold on him.
In that case, go Selwood + Tuck. Those are two legitimate keepers, and like I (and S-KFC) said you dont need Bartel as a captain, you already have Ablett.
I wouldnt go either out of those two new options. Maybe Lockyer, but im not sold on him.
Yeah, neither. Maybe Newman + Ziebell? Provides that extra security that you will need in your backline.
But Newman is more of a sc player and won't improve much. Not a keeper imo.
Also, if i go with ziebell, then i would have 2 rookies starting in the forward line. I am finding this really tough lol.
I have 500k to buy a player in the backline and forwardline. I am looking to get a medium/keeper in the backline and a forward who will play on a regular basis. I am quite worried about having two rookies in the forward line. I am in desperate need of help lol.
Not a keeper? Even if he doesn't improve from last years average, he is still very much a keeper in my eyes.
Ablett is also more of an SC player. Being a good DT'er and a good SC'er are not mutually exclusive.
this one is a bit complicated:
b.reilly+r.houlihan+cockie+c.pearce (last 2 on bench)+9k
vs
Masten+ N.Krakouer+Davenport+Petrenko +25k???
b.reilly+r.houlihan+cockie+c.pearce (last 2 on bench)+9k
vs
Masten+ N.Krakouer+Davenport+Petrenko +25k???
What makes you value Lockyer as a keeper over Newman?
Edit: My own conundrum:
Didak vs Sylvia
On face value no comparison. But the cash saved allows me to swap Ziebell to the forwards (instead of starting an 86ker) and pick up an Otten/Polkinghorne type. Bit safer with the rookies and it frees up some more cash. Im confident Sylvia can average 85-90 which puts him as a lower end keeper.
Thoughts?
Edit: My own conundrum:
Didak vs Sylvia
On face value no comparison. But the cash saved allows me to swap Ziebell to the forwards (instead of starting an 86ker) and pick up an Otten/Polkinghorne type. Bit safer with the rookies and it frees up some more cash. Im confident Sylvia can average 85-90 which puts him as a lower end keeper.
Thoughts?
veszpremi or lucaS?
Ben the Gooner
Stand by Hird
Lucas. Guaranteed spot, and proven scoring record.
Which ruckman (bar Cox) should I pick, bearing in mind I have a fair few Dons alread?
Which ruckman (bar Cox) should I pick, bearing in mind I have a fair few Dons alread?
judd vs palmer vs pendlebury vs dal santo vs van berlo vs boak
Sylvia averaged 93 in the last 7 games last year (IIRC), so he can definitely become a keeper this year. Didak is a safer bet but it depends if you think Otten/Polkinghorne are more likely to play than your other rookies.
- Status
Similar threads
- Sticky
