Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[buddymania]

Hayes + Selwood/Stanton
vs
K.Cornes + Gibbs

 

[drd23]

Harvey v Didak v Johnson

 

[Buddyman]

Harvey v Didak v Johnson

Depends on what you want. Personally i would either get Didak or none of them, consider this Didak predicted average 100 i like the average but isn't exactly durable and i think that is nearly as gold as a trade. Harvey very durable should average 90-95 but i can't see the ball getting in his hands much if the roos play like that, solid option though.
Steve Johnson, pred average 95 i think he would of been the pick of the bunch but i'm having second thoughts with him seeming to still have a niggle or two, not playing a nab game isn't exactly great but if he plays 1 or 2 consider strongly!

Mackie v Lockyer!

 

[kangaroos3]

Im stuck on whether to have Charman or Minson as my back-up ruckman.

Any thoughts to help me out?

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Im stuck on whether to have Charman or Minson as my back-up ruckman.

Any thoughts to help me out?

I don't like either, I'd go with Maric who is around the same price. I guess if I had to I'd go with Minson over Charman.

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Im stuck on whether to have Charman or Minson as my back-up ruckman.

Any thoughts to help me out?

I honestly hate the idea of having to end up upgrading my second ruckman because it is a waste of one or two trades. Charman and Minson may allow you to upgrade players in other positions, but the rucks are extremely important. This is why I have Cox and Hille. If you really want one of Minson and Charman, I would go with Minson because he is a better dt'er in my opinion.

 

[wallcob]

foley v masten v c. morton?

i can see an upside to all three but cant decide.

my current midfield is

swan
kornes
gibbs
x
skipworth
rich

 

[drd23]

For the second Ruck spot:

Simmonds v Sandilands v Fraser

 

[chadleverington]

Midfield bench spot. Zaharakis V Swift V Davenport

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Midfield bench spot. Zaharakis V Swift V Davenport

Wait until the round one teams are released.

 

[mrpig]

For the second Ruck spot:

Simmonds v Sandilands v Fraser

Sandilands

 

[swans4eva]

Ok this is a tough one
Thornton+Goddard+Adcock
vs
Houli+Gram+King

What is thought of Adcock and Thornton?

Also Do u reckon i will be safe with my 2nd ruckmen, being cordy, Currie and Natuanui.
I have cox as my first

 

[Athomas]

Ok this is a tough one
Thornton+Goddard+Adcock
vs
Houli+Gram+King

What is thought of Adcock and Thornton?

Carlton's Thornton!? Stay clear. Only had some good games as Scotland was out and he was the quarterback for a bit. He takes the best or 2nd best forward usually.

I have Adcock atm, but don't really want him, don't think he can average much more then last year,

 

[Lakey91]

Sandilands

Care to elaborate?

 

[spence]

Didak v Giansiracusa?

 

[SydneySwans]

Didak v Giansiracusa?

Didak only really became a quality dter last year whereas g has been consitent over the last few years.
Didak has the potential to average alot higher than g but has a higher risk

although it is nab cup didak looks the goods and will probably keep his form going from last year didak for me


adcock vs drummond v houli??

 

[rdangelo]

Hi everyone,

I have a tough one that I cant work out at all.. my mind changes all the time.

Masten / Hille / Riewoldt or Richo

vs

J. Selwood / Lade or Ottens / J. Brown

Positions 2 and 3 look pretty clear to me I think. I just don't know if what I gain there will be lost by including Masten instead of Selwood. With tags going to Kerr and Priddis, Masten looks set to get a lot of the ball.

Thanks in advance

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

adcock vs drummond v houli??

Drummond will probably average the most, but how many games will he play? I currently have him because if he can play 20 games he will be very good so I'd take him, but he is a massive risk. Adcock is a safe bet but I can't see him averaging that much.

 

[kangaroos3]

Hmm who would be a better option out of;

Dane Swan and Mathew Kruezer

or

Brent Harvey and Will Minson?

I can see upsides both ways but im leaning toward option 2 because both mids will get a solid score most weeks but minson is a little more reliable IMO, but im not 100%

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Swan and Foley

vs

Boyd and Knights

I really can't decide?

 

[kangaroos3]

Swan and Foley

vs

Boyd and Knights

I really can't decide?

Either option is good but IMO i would go option 2.
Simply because neither player in option 2 will get the number 1 tag from the opposition.

 

[Dugong]

Hmm who would be a better option out of;

Dane Swan and Mathew Kruezer

or

Brent Harvey and Will Minson?

I can see upsides both ways but im leaning toward option 2 because both mids will get a solid score most weeks but minson is a little more reliable IMO, but im not 100%

Personally I'd go option 1......Swan, consistently scores higher and Kreuzer should have a better year this year. I've never really been sold on Minson

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Either option is good but IMO i would go option 2.
Simply because neither player in option 2 will get the number 1 tag from the opposition.

Yeah, that's what I'm going for, but I do need a captain option in the mids so I'm still unsure.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Hmm who would be a better option out of;

Dane Swan and Mathew Kruezer

or

Brent Harvey and Will Minson?

I can see upsides both ways but im leaning toward option 2 because both mids will get a solid score most weeks but minson is a little more reliable IMO, but im not 100%

Option 1, I can see Kreuzer imporving his scores enough to be able to trade him out for someone reasonable, so I'd go with that.

 

[Saint KFC]

Corey, T.Tuck, Skipworth v Swan, Robinson, Harvey