1st one, not a fan of mayne. I'd pick Hunt over Kennelly though
1. Dangerfield vs Ballantyne
2. Medhurst vs Hall vs Betts (I need two these)
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y (part 2)
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
1st one, not a fan of mayne. I'd pick Hunt over Kennelly though
1. Dangerfield vs Ballantyne
2. Medhurst vs Hall vs Betts (I need two these)
Tough One. I like danger simply because he is set to receive some mid field this year. I think this will give him some opportunity to get some bigger scores. Probably couldnt go wrong with either tho.
If you wanna be different go ballantyne, more teams will have danger
And here is one more thing, do you still looking for Reliable Investment investment company
Has probably been done before but:
Pav or RoK?
Pav or RoK?
RoK has had a much better preseason with an avg of >100 whereas Pavlich has had an average of <50! I'd go RoK, or if you want a cheaper option go Lockyer. Lockyer's had a better preseason than Pav and is ultra reliable in terms of injuries etc.
Mine: Malceski vs Kennelly? (Already have Hunt and Waters and not sold on Ladson).
Kennelly then. Mal is a silly risk if you have Hunt and Waters already in the side.
3 of Kennelly, Ladson, Hunt, Waters. At the moment im thinking of leaving out Ladson. I just know the one I leave out will be the best pick.
JohnHawk04
Debutant
I have Hunt and Waters so I have to recommend them. Ladson should play 22 games this year barring injury, but so will Kennelly. In fact I think Kennelly and Ladson are hard to split scoring wise. So I would save the money and choose Ladson.
Ladson, Masten, Mayne
vs
Hunt, Trengove, Gia
2nd option. Easily.
Bare with me on this one...
A) Ziebell, Swan, Mackie, Ladson, Gumby (B), Nason (B)
B) Pav, Boyd, Harbrow, Hunt, Pods (B), Silvagni (B)
I just made the change from A to B with the motivating factor to get Zeibell (who I'm not all that sold on) out and replace him with Pav. Obviously lose Swan as the captain option and Bartel would become the number one choice. The other changes were minor downgrades in order to free up cash.
So, A or B?
A) Ziebell, Swan, Mackie, Ladson, Gumby (B), Nason (B)
B) Pav, Boyd, Harbrow, Hunt, Pods (B), Silvagni (B)
I just made the change from A to B with the motivating factor to get Zeibell (who I'm not all that sold on) out and replace him with Pav. Obviously lose Swan as the captain option and Bartel would become the number one choice. The other changes were minor downgrades in order to free up cash.
So, A or B?
- May 30, 2009
- 4,657
- 3
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Victory, Newcastle United
- Banned
- #986
I would go B as IMO it is more value and has more consistancy
Pendelbury vs Mitchell
Gumbleton vs Rockliff (Bench)
Frozenwaste
Senior List
Trengove+Higgins vs. Rockliff+Boyd
- Oct 27, 2009
- 10,131
- 20
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #989
Hard choice. If Rockliff is selected which i think he will then i'd go with the second option.
Gia v Pav.
BIG FAT BOB
Club Legend
Two mid-rangers who may make the leap to premium/keeper status:
Tippet and Gray
or
An established expensive premium and an expensive cash-cow:
Pav/J.Brown and Dangerfield
???
Thanks in advance for any thoughts..
Tippet and Gray
or
An established expensive premium and an expensive cash-cow:
Pav/J.Brown and Dangerfield
???
Thanks in advance for any thoughts..
Moses01
Club Legend
Veteran
Port Adelaide - Jack Watts Player Sponsor 2018
Port Adelaide - Jesse Palmer Player Sponsor 2017
Port Adelaide - Riley Bonner Player Sponsor 2016
Port Adelaide - Nathan Krakouer Player Sponsor 2015
Port Adelaide - Brendon Ah Chee Player Sponsor 2014
Port Adelaide - Jarrad Redden Player Sponsor 2014
Port Adelaide - Matthew Broadbent Player Sponsor 2013
- Feb 28, 2010
- 1,518
- 961
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Banner v Jetta v Shuey
pick 2..
pick 2..
Hammers_Saints
All Australian
Dal Santo or Vince?
Sherman vs A.Selwood vs J.McVeigh
Got a really good gut feeling about all of these guys.. not the sort of priced guys you want to be filling your team with but i've got 414K left for a midfielder and want to take a punt on atleast one of them. I think they'll all improve on their averages by atleast around 10 points.
Sherman - One of Voss' favourites from what i've heard, and his scores towards the end of last year were impressive, no doubt in my mind that he'll improve.
A.Selwood - If he is given more of a free run in the midfield, and allowed to play without being a defensive stopper, he will bring his form from pre-season into the real season.
J.McVeigh - Already have ROK and Goodes in my team.. but tbh i'd hate to have 3 Sydney blokes in my team. At around 350K, im finding this guy very hard to ignore.
ATM.. im thinking
Sherman > J.McVeigh > A.Selwood
Got a really good gut feeling about all of these guys.. not the sort of priced guys you want to be filling your team with but i've got 414K left for a midfielder and want to take a punt on atleast one of them. I think they'll all improve on their averages by atleast around 10 points.
Sherman - One of Voss' favourites from what i've heard, and his scores towards the end of last year were impressive, no doubt in my mind that he'll improve.
A.Selwood - If he is given more of a free run in the midfield, and allowed to play without being a defensive stopper, he will bring his form from pre-season into the real season.
J.McVeigh - Already have ROK and Goodes in my team.. but tbh i'd hate to have 3 Sydney blokes in my team. At around 350K, im finding this guy very hard to ignore.
ATM.. im thinking
Sherman > J.McVeigh > A.Selwood
i'm just finalising my forwards and am torn on the following:
Option 1: Goodes (f) and Montangna (M)
or
Option 2: Brown (f) and Ablett/Swan
or should i be looking a Bob Murphy instead of either of the above two?
I already have Reivoldt, ROK, Buddy Pav and Gia.
Appreciate some feedback (with explanation)
Go Team!!
Option 1: Goodes (f) and Montangna (M)
or
Option 2: Brown (f) and Ablett/Swan
or should i be looking a Bob Murphy instead of either of the above two?
I already have Reivoldt, ROK, Buddy Pav and Gia.
Appreciate some feedback (with explanation)
Go Team!!
Frozenwaste
Senior List
I'd personally go with Gia, as Pav has to rely on the Fremantle mids. And although they are improving, they're not exactly the best in the competition.
Renouf or Hille?
Frozenwaste
Senior List
IMO it'd be the way you had it. Had Sherman for a large part of the pre-season, even named my team after him. Then i'd go McVeigh, although i couldn't see Selwood getting the tag in front of Kerr etc.
- Status
