Player X or Player Y (Part 3)

[sdsdsdsd]

Banner vs Jetta. Preferably someone that can comment on their likelyhood to stay in their respective teams. I am leaning towards Jetta as most of the swans board seem to think he is best 22.

To the person above me: Gumby.

Banner has the potential to get higher scores but I think Jetta is more safe. Line ball situation.

Bastinac vs Banner

 

[Jay-Z]

What's everone's prediction of Ballantyne's 2010 DT Average?

Somewhere between 50 and 100

 

[desTROY]

Thanks Tippaz

Gumbleton should play most games this year baring injury of course.

 

[MARK In TIME]

Perhaps a bit late but in regards to emergency players...

Gumbleton or Hitchcock? Who is probably going to score more?

 

[paddy13]

maguire and podsiadly

or

silvagni and gumby??

please give me ur thoughts!

 

[C-Dog]

maguire and podsiadly

or

silvagni and gumby??

please give me ur thoughts!

silvangni and gumby!

pav and pods or dangerfield and ballantyne?

 

[Valli]

Is Pods starting (on your team?) If not, then Pav and Pods, if so, I reckon go for Danger and Ballantyne.

Trengove or Morabito!!??

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Is Pods starting (on your team?) If not, then Pav and Pods, if so, I reckon go for Danger and Ballantyne.

Trengove or Morabito!!??

I had the sam choice and went Trengrove. Based on nothing really though, just a gut feel.

Last minute selection dilemma...

Goodes & NicNat

or

Didak & Renouf

???

 

[desTROY]

Goodes and Nicnat


Clarke or Sandilands???

 

[Papa Juggs]

Morabito for sure! Good luck.

 

[gocowsmoo]

Ablett + Ziebell/Hall/Medhurst + Wright
vs
Selwood + 2 of Ziebell/Hall/Medhurst (or 1 + Wright & extra $$)

 

[BluesMan]

Harvey v byrnes v lynch

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Am begging...please?

I had the sam choice and went Trengrove. Based on nothing really though, just a gut feel.

Last minute selection dilemma...

Goodes & NicNat

or

Didak & Renouf

???

 

[Moogs]

Clarke or Sandilands???

you mean Clarke or Fevola?

 

[BluesMan]

funny one moogs, OneEyedHawk I'd go goodes and nicnat

HArvey v lynch v byrnes

 

[footyfix]

Goodes and nicnat. Goodes is a durable champ nicnat is guaranteed every week. Didak has been known to struggle with a tag and Renouf, might not be around when some injuries are cleared up.

 

[Anzac16]

funny one moogs, OneEyedHawk I'd go goodes and nicnat

HArvey v lynch v byrnes

I would go Harvey out of them just because we know wat he can do, although if you have to money mabye go Higgins or Gia

Mine is Tippet + Lobbe (for DP)
OR
Gray and 77k

 

[Damon_3388]

Is paying the extra $32,300 for Rick Ladson really worth it in comparison to Beau Waters? Would I be correct in saying that $32,300 is the equivalent to 7.54 points (ie. Ladson would have to average 7.54 points more than Waters from the outset to be worth the cost)? I've based that on a $60,000=14 points measurement that I saw mentioned somewhere else. To be honest, at their best, I don't see one averaging significantly more than the other, but Ladson has more of a track record and a better injury record.

 

[gocowsmoo]

I would go Harvey out of them just because we know wat he can do, although if you have to money mabye go Higgins or Gia

Mine is Tippet + Lobbe (for DP)
OR
Gray and 77k

I'd go Tippet & Lobbe.
Concerned about Gray's ability to shake niggles.

Anyone for this one
Ablett + Ziebell/Hall/Medhurst + Wright
vs
Selwood + 2 of Ziebell/Hall/Medhurst (or 1 + Wright & extra $$)

 

[oohaahmarklecras]

just a quickie
JKT or bastinac or banner? for bench spot with shuey
duncan or gumby? for bench spot with hitchcock

 

[Spoony]

go for bastinac got the best job security.
Gumby for me because of job security although he is a big injury risk.

 

[BluesMan]

HArd one gocow, but id have to go with Ablett hall and wright. My opinion only here

 

[richskee]

Gumbleton Vs Rockliff???

Gumby is bloody risky imo but when will rockliff get a go???

 

[footyfix]

Last Q.. Boak, Cooney or Ball?

 

[gocowsmoo]

HArd one gocow, but id have to go with Ablett hall and wright. My opinion only here

Thanks Blues Man.
Have had Selwood, Medhurst, Wright & $$, but just liking having that extra super-premium in Ablett. Hall v Medhurst is a punt I guess.
It can only do my head in for another 15min, then its done.
Good luck all!