Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[toxic]

Jolly by a country mile really like jolly SC scores and will take alot of the ruck work at the pies. I think they should fraiser up fwd as another good tall fwd instead of the inconsistant talls(brown,cloke,anthony) with wood backing up jolly. dont see clark rising his avg to much with other rucks back in the side

cheers & thanks - my thoughts are mitch clark earnt his rating being able too go forward but with Fev now there & J.Brown there he won't go forward at all, jolly looks super value to me and is in along with Natinui

 

[russea]

Lance Franklin, Robbie Gray, Daniel Giansiracusa, Shaun Higgins, or anyone else around that price range?

Ahaha that guys got u thinking huh
for me buddy first, then gia, grey,higgins

 

[toxic]

Lance Franklin, Robbie Gray, Daniel Giansiracusa, Shaun Higgins, or anyone else around that price range?

choose all 4 - what other forwards do you have???

all 4 will average around the 90-100 range i reckon,

 

[thomas_m18]

choose all 4 - what other forwards do you have???

all 4 will average around the 90-100 range i reckon,

Riewoldt, Pav, ROK, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff.

Doubt that any of these players need to be touched (besides possibly Rockliff)

 

[toxic]

for the record my "current" team is:

def: Lake, hodge,O'Brien, Kennelly, Garland, Petrenko, Waters Maguire & D.Grimes
Mid: Goddard, Mitchell, Deledio, Watson, Armitage, Matsen, Trengrove & L.Jetta
Rucks: Jolly & Ntainui, Skipper & Stanley (Stk)
For: O'Keefe, Harvey, Franklin, Gray, Hall, Dangerfield, Rohan, Rockliff & Podsiadly

thoughts?????

 

[russea]

for the record my "current" team is:

def: Lake, hodge,O'Brien, Kennelly, Garland, Petrenko, Waters Maguire & D.Grimes
Mid: Goddard, Mitchell, Deledio, Watson, Armitage, Matsen, Trengrove & L.Jetta
Rucks: Jolly & Ntainui, Skipper & Stanley (Stk)
For: O'Keefe, Harvey, Franklin, Gray, Hall, Dangerfield, Rohan, Rockliff & Podsiadly

thoughts?????

mabye post this in the rate my SC team thread

 

[Ed_Gein]

Toxic, to be honest, i'd work a way into throwing Goddard in the backline. There are too many top line mids to pass up on at the expense of having Goddard in the mids.

 

[toxic]

mabye post this in the rate my SC team thread

have done so....... thoughts?

 

[Sunday Red]

Barry Hall vs Chris Mayne +90k?

 

[thomas_m18]

Barry Hall vs Chris Mayne +90k?

Me likes Barry more.

I'm gunna see how he plays against St Kilda's defense, but I think he's a better choice.

 

[Frrost11]

I did have mayne but then i was tossing up between hm and ballentyne...and then i just throughthat in the garbage and have settled with hall because you cant go past his performances in the NAB! remember last years and the before BBB was low priced and went up 100k in no time until he was reported and what not both seasons! he is at a new club with a team who wants the flag this yr!(and can actually get it), i think BBB will be a differnet man(slightly less aggresive) this yr and it will result in 22 games with an avg of 80+ and that means 100k+!

Mine is M.Murpphy at 599K or Dal Santo at 625K....just dont know if im being a little biased by still having mruph in my mind?

 

[IDIG]

Cooney/Shoenmakers v Vince/Waters

Seem like my final two options. Cooney was yuck for me last year and Waters i'm worried about although if fit does have some definite upside.

 

[MattyC]

I would say vince and waters, assuming vince plays round 1. Cooney and schoenmakers are probably safer, but with much less upside. Depends how you play.

Mine is:

swan cross and mcintosh
vs
pendlebury mitchell and clark
vs
swan vince and clark

This is for M2, M3 and R2

 

[Impromptu]

Cooney/Shoenmakers v Vince/Waters

Seem like my final two options. Cooney was yuck for me last year and Waters i'm worried about although if fit does have some definite upside.

Cooney and Greenwood/Ladson (if possible).

swan cross and mcintosh
vs
pendlebury mitchell and clark
vs
swan vince and clark

This is for M2, M3 and R2

wow nice team......... pendlebury mitchell and clark

 

[toxic]

Cooney and Greenwood/Ladson (if possible).



wow nice team......... pendlebury mitchell and clark

drop clark for jolly and i'm impressed

 

[Hot Tiges]

Hmm, yeah Jolly for mine as well

7th spot on the fwd line here.. Take a punt on Rockliff and cash or just enough money for Yarran or T Walker.. Short on Ballantyne/Mayne which is annoying..last spot need to fix up till round 1.

 

[thomas_m18]

Sandi and Hille

OR

Cox and one of Leuenberger, Vickery and McEvoy?

 

[peteshep]

sandi and hille..

cox just doesn't seem to be the same this year.. could hit his straps midseason in which case he would be a good upgrade target.

Mine:

J.Brown and J.Ziebell

vs

L.Franklin or C.Sylvia or anyone else round that price and B.Hall

 

[jd2006]

sandi and hille..

cox just doesn't seem to be the same this year.. could hit his straps midseason in which case he would be a good upgrade target.

Mine:

J.Brown and J.Ziebell

vs

L.Franklin or C.Sylvia or anyone else round that price and B.Hall

Franklin and Sylvia and Hall.

Sylvia if he has his head screwed on is a very good player. Franklin is great value. Dont know if it was Hall or Sylvia or both.

Brown unsure on the Fev-factor and Ziebell good 2nd yr player but not of the Sylvia-Hall scoring capabilities

 

[Lane Dog]

Hi guys any thought? I am going with some young blokes to make some money.

Backs: Enright, Hodge, Gram, Ellis, Kennelly, Hunt, Waters,
INT: Maguire, Silvani

Mids: Goddard, Judd, Deledio, Cooney, Scully, Trengove
INT: Martin, Barlow

Rucks: Naitanui, Luenberger
INT: McEvoy, Trengove

Forwards: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Harvey, Giansiracussa, Rohan
INT: Gumbleton, Podsiadly

 

[Clutters]

There's a fair bit of talk on Zieball here, but I'm going with Mark Robinson's suggestion and leaving him out. I'm taking Dangerfield instead.

My question:
Adam Schneider or Shaun Higgins?

I've already got Baz Hall and Riewoldt in there too from those teams. Leaning towards Schneider on his NAB form (SCA 101) vs Higgins (SCA 67) but Higgins didn't seem to play a full match last weekend.

 

[marshie_blues]

Has to be higgins by an absolute mile!!!

Tippet (ruck) and Medhurst

vs

Naitanui and Tippet (forward)

 

[thomas_m18]

Has to be higgins by an absolute mile!!!

Tippet (ruck) and Medhurst

vs

Naitanui and Tippet (forward)

Hmmm, I think NicNat and Tippett. Medhurst's 2008 is probably a one-off, although he'll probably prove me wrong.

NicNat can improve, so he's the choice.

My Question:

Hille/NicNat + Sandi or Kreuzer + Tippett or Macintosh + Ottens or any other ruck combo $857,600 or less.

Thanks in advance

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

There's a fair bit of talk on Zieball here, but I'm going with Mark Robinson's suggestion and leaving him out. I'm taking Dangerfield instead.

My question:
Adam Schneider or Shaun Higgins?

I've already got Baz Hall and Riewoldt in there too from those teams. Leaning towards Schneider on his NAB form (SCA 101) vs Higgins (SCA 67) but Higgins didn't seem to play a full match last weekend.

Higgins. Will play midfield and rack up the points. Schneider will go missing.

Has to be higgins by an absolute mile!!!

Tippet (ruck) and Medhurst

vs

Naitanui and Tippet (forward)

Tippet as a fwd gives you the luxury of having some back ups in teh notoriously unreliable reuck division. However, I'm not convinced that NicNat will score that well when Cox is playing.

 

[peteshep]

R.Griffin v B.Vince...

both potential breakouts this year. thinking the Montagna of this year. but which one?!? What's everyone think?

Also, one I posted before but would love some more suggestions:
J.Brown and Ziebell
vs
C.Sylvia and B.Hall

Or even Buddy.. but he is very up and down which frustrates me