Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[jinny1]

Ziebell or Medhurst?

 

[wheels4]

2 people in a row not answering a question before asking one, pathetic.

 

[jinny1]

2 people in a row not answering a question before asking one, pathetic.

typical grumpy saints supporter... i didnt answer becuz i didnt know for certain but i did answer on other questions

heres your answer GTFO!!

 

[Hot Tiges]

JKT or Howlett or Bastinac i reckon, i went with Bastinac but others might think different.
4th forward,
B.Harvey vs Higgins vs Gia vs Gray

Harvey getting on a bit, youngsters playing through the middle more, Higgins can get little niggles, Gia is more for DT so I'll stick for Gray

my last issues

O'Brien & Kennelly vs Gram & Malceski

 

[jinny1]

Harvey getting on a bit, youngsters playing through the middle more, Higgins can get little niggles, Gia is more for DT so I'll stick for Gray

my last issues

O'Brien & Kennelly vs Gram & Malceski

Obrien and malceski for best value and you can upgrade to a premium

 

[wheels4]

typical grumpy saints supporter... i didnt answer becuz i didnt know for certain but i did answer on other questions

heres your answer GTFO!!

Well atleast say that, dont just go asking a question, its why alot of these threads get ruined.

 

[jinny1]

Well atleast say that, dont just go asking a question, its why alot of these threads get ruined.

yep no worries mate..i was just mucking around u b4.. got a saints supporter friend u see...

 

[wheels4]

yep no worries mate..i was just mucking around u b4.. got a saints supporter friend u see...

hhaa all good

 

[Hot Tiges]

I'm used to grumpiness lol

just fiddling around with 4th midfield..

got around 485 to spend, I can get Cooney, but have $700 left!

Been looking for a unique pick, someone like a Mackay, Welsh, even Armitage! But I don't think I'd go for Masten or McVeigh..

Any other potential options??

 

[jinny1]

If you have 485k left you can get Ball,Gilbee or even Gram....

Heres mine : Rick Ladson Or Mitch Robinson?

 

[sens]

Jetta (starting), Medhurst (F7), Waters (D7)

vs

Trengove (starting), Rockliff (F7), Greenwood (D7)

 

[Clunk]

Jetta (starting), Medhurst (F7), Waters (D7)

vs

Trengove (starting), Rockliff (F7), Greenwood (D7)

Comfortably.

 

[Tonche]

2 people in a row not answering a question before asking one, pathetic.

Haha, harsh. Clearly I missed that rule.

You should be thanking me for my lovely piece of analysis though.

 

[Zeno The Great]

If you have 485k left you can get Ball,Gilbee or even Gram....

Heres mine : Rick Ladson Or Mitch Robinson?

I would go Robinson, Ladson looks very average over the summer.

Mine is Tippett or Buddy - really cannot split them

 

[eugene_tomas]

tippet.. i hate buddy hes overated. tip due to explode

connors or trengrove?

 

[GotTheGoodes]

I would go Robinson, Ladson looks very average over the summer.

Mine is Tippett or Buddy - really cannot split them

Hey mate,

I'd go Tippett for the fact he has the FWD/RUCK option. Plus Buddy is out early and has had a slight foot niggle early this season which he may be getting over (and may be slightly less ready for season proper). Finally, Buddy may not get too much supply what with half the side gone through injury!!! But later on in the year I'd expect to see Buddy start to pick up & really finish strong. But early on my option would be big Tippett.

Cheers & Good luck!

 

[eugene_tomas]

trengrove or connors?

 

[marshie_blues]

trengrove or connors?

i think id go trengove

mine is medhurst or zeibell?

 

[eugene_tomas]

medhurst mate.. pies look the goods.. medhurst looks the goods to

 

[marshie_blues]

medhurst mate.. pies look the goods.. medhurst looks the goods to

yeh he is in atm think he will stay.
my other one is

Higgins and Waite vs Buddy and Gram?
im finding this one tough, i like higgins over buddy and am worried about Waite's knee but i cant afford higgins and gram

other option would be to downgrade vince to stanton then i could take higgins and gram

 

[Cool Cat]

hmm, perhaps buddy and gram - although i agree with everything you said above. can't go for the stanton solution though, i wouldn't want him as one of my premiums.

my one is for the underpriced premium mid position in my team. the 2 options are luke ball vs adam cooney. both are underpriced and have their pros: ball had a great preseason, has something to prove and averaged 116 a few years back while cooney averaged 106 in 2008. What do you guys think?

 

[Zeno The Great]

my one is for the underpriced premium mid position in my team. the 2 options are luke ball vs adam cooney. both are underpriced and have their pros: ball had a great preseason, has something to prove and averaged 116 a few years back while cooney averaged 106 in 2008. What do you guys think?[/QUOTE]

Hey coolcat, i am a doggies supporter, and Cooney is firing in the pre-season. I have watched every game, and he has been playing very well, but he has still be scoring badly - i don't know why. I had him in my team, but have taken him out now, i think the dogs have too many even players who will all score around 80-90 mark which will mean not too many will score really highly. As much as it kills me to say it, i would go Ball. Higgins is the one that seems to score better, in some of the pre-season games so far he played little more than a half and has scored well.

Tossing up between Clark and Sandi for the R1 position. Thoughts?

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Clark for me i like a ruckman that can tackle the way he does
Eddie Betts yep nope?

 

[HELLA BONG RIPS]

brown or pavlich?

 

[tubes82]

Pavlich for me just. Brown is now sharing the goals with Fev which will lower his score. He will push further up the ground and maybe get more posessions and marks but it's a risk. Could be an upgrade target later on.

Franklin or Tippet in the forward line?

Also Sandi and Kreuzer or Sandi and Nic Nat
Bit of a prize dif there. Do you reckon its worth it? Kreuzer's pretty reliable and will go up a little bit this year and Nat is a risk but could pay off huge.