Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[Faz 2000]

Wow, it's exploding knees all-round!

Depends a bit on who your other ruck is... but Sandilands is a point-scoring staple in my Supercoach squad.

Are there alternative players who still have their own knee tendons?

 

[dees 4 life]

Drummond, Natanui, Hall

v

Malceski, Sandilands, Waite

all opinions welcomed!

Tough.

Top 1 for me.

 

[Bomber4ever]

Gumbleton wil play all 22 unless injured. So i'd take him

Not sure about this, is Silvangni promoted? Maybe Lisle from the Hawks if he'll get some games?

Gram and Houli + approx 50k v H.Shaw (or any other premium back except Hurn and Hodge under 510k) and Hunt

 

[Sunday Red]

Gumbleton wil play all 22 unless injured. So i'd take him

Lol... and therein lies your problem!

 

[Hodge2NormSmith]

Shaw and Hunt, depending on where else you can use $50K...

Bartel / Nason

or J.Selwood / A.Silvagni

 

[fr_303]

Last choice I have to make

Robert Murphy $353,800
Partick Dangerfield $332,700
Jack Ziebell $320, 800

I can fit 2 players in one has too go

I'm leaning to leaving Jack out what do you guys think?

 

[Faz 2000]

Last choice I have to make

Robert Murphy $353,800
Partick Dangerfield $332,700
Jack Ziebell $320, 800

I can fit 2 players in one has too go

I'm leaning to leaving Jack out what do you guys think?

I've got 'em all, so we're pretty much on the same page. Danger has been the one I've yanked in and out of my team 100 times. He'll be good, but will he really pile up the points this year?

MPP of Danger and Jay-Z is handy.

Murph and Danger play in better teams, you'd think.

But Jay-Z is the cheapest.

There... a case made for each of them.

 

[thomas_m18]

Ugh. Last minute selections.

Kennelly, Tippett and Ziebell or Macdonald, Sandilands and Rockliff?


Having first combo allows me not to have a rookie at F7.

Cheers guys, good luck.

 

[traaxx]

Last choice I have to make

Robert Murphy $353,800
Partick Dangerfield $332,700
Jack Ziebell $320, 800

I can fit 2 players in one has too go

I'm leaning to leaving Jack out what do you guys think?

If it was me i'd leave Murphy out, the aim is to get as many durable players in your team as possible and unless he's finally having a good run and your confident he wont get injured this year then leave him in but it's enough for me that i dont have him in my team!

 

[alternatevista]

Ziebell is already one of the better players at North and should get plenty of time in the midfield and thus provide a fairly consistent output. Murphy will no doubt miss some games through injury and Dangerfield is promising but competing against better players for a spot and gametime. If you have stacked your team with injury returning players already then leave out Murphy, otherwise Dangerzone.

I'm looking to upgrade one of my forward rookies (Gumby, Rockliff, Rohan) and can either do Rohan->RoK or one of the others to a forward<550k (Brown or Harvey). I like RoK for his consistency but would Rohan be likely to make me any more money than the other 2?

 

[StGradey]

Gilbee and Malceski or Gram and Kennelly?

 

[thomas_m18]

Gilbee and Malceski or Gram and Kennelly?

Both awesome options. Second one looks more settled, but first one arguably has more upside.

I'd go first, by a tiny bit, but both are absolutely fine.


My Question:

Sandilands and Dangerfield or Robbie Gray and Tippett in the ruck?


Take into account that the first option would give me 4 mid price forwards (Hall, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Medhurst)

 

[Wise Guy Sam]

Gilbee and Malceski or Gram and Kennelly?

Word on the street is Gilbee is changing his role in the backline, i'd steer clear. Malceski however shold be on the up this year.

Gram(or Macdonald) and Kennelly will get the job done.

Goodwin and Bellantyne
OR
Kennelly tippett (fwd) and a fair bit of $$$

 

[bloods01]

Sandilands, Banner and Mayne or

Kreuzer, Trengove and Dangerfield???

Any thoughts?

 

[thomas_m18]

Word on the street is Gilbee is changing his role in the backline, i'd steer clear. Malceski however shold be on the up this year.

Gram(or Macdonald) and Kennelly will get the job done.

Goodwin and Bellantyne
OR
Kennelly tippett (fwd) and a fair bit of $$$

Why not Kennelly and Gray/Buddy/Gia/Higgins/Harvey?

Both awesome options. Second one looks more settled, but first one arguably has more upside.

I'd go first, by a tiny bit, but both are absolutely fine.


My Question:

Sandilands and Dangerfield or Robbie Gray and Tippett in the ruck?


Take into account that the first option would give me 4 mid price forwards (Hall, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Medhurst)

That one, and this one too.

Luke ball vs Travis Boak?

 

[BlueVeins]

Gray's just had a question over his hammy - afl.com.au

Also, don't know if this was obvious, but in order to take care of the C/VC loophole, don't select a captain until tomorrow. That way you don't need a 0 on your bench for it to come on as has previously been suggested.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Swan or Dal Santo + 45k?

Although i'm fairly settled and dont need to spend the 45k elsewhere

 

[AD03]

Pendlebury and Cooney

OR

Gibbs and Vince

??????

Cheers guys

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Cooney and Gibbs for mine. Both will have a big year imo.

Scully or Dangerfield? (Starting, not reserve)

Also

Brennan, Sylvia, S. Johnson, Higgins. Which one?

 

[Ed_Gein]

Cooney and Gibbs for mine. Both will have a big year imo.

Scully or Dangerfield? (Starting, not reserve)

Danger + Higgins imo

Ballantyne or Mayne?

 

[Speck]

ROK or Mitchell?

 

[_Hammer_]

Danger.

Ballantyne or Mayne?

Ballntyne... wanna put him in my side... but dangerous.

M. Murphy --or-- Stanton

 

[Spudregus_87]

Cooney and Gibbs for mine. Both will have a big year imo.

Scully or Dangerfield? (Starting, not reserve)

Also

Brennan, Sylvia, S. Johnson, Higgins. Which one?

Higgins

Danger + Higgins imo

Ballantyne or Mayne?

Mayne

ROK or Mitchell?

ROK!!!



Okay......

Ablett, Selwood, Ladson & Ziebell
vs
Goddard, Vince, Malceski & Didak

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Ablett, Selwood, Ladson & Ziebell
vs
Goddard, Vince, Malceski & Didak

First option by the length of the Flemington.

Westhoff (PA) or Rockliff?

 

[Outside 50]

One last decision to make

Stanton $507 (Huge NAB Challenge scores including a 195)

or

Watson $540 (consistant scores of 100)