Player X v Y v Z

[Hai_Newman]

+1. Let him be our little secret

Yeo v Hurley
Dahlhaus v Parish
McGrath v Maynard
Ah Chee v Bennell

Hurley, think Elliot will slide due to a role change and recently signed a 5 year deal.
Dahl burnt me hard last year, not touching him...not convinced on Parish...yet
Someone convince me/need more research vast thoughts?
McGrath v Maynard, JLT watch, DeGoey in this bracket also.
Bennell, but only when training reports start coming in, AhChee will get plenty of 2018 minutes and is fit, from all reports training well and impressing senior players.

 

[vast]

Hurley, think Elliot will slide due to a role change and recently signed a 5 year deal.
Dahl burnt me hard last year, not touching him...not convinced on Parish...yet
Someone convince me/need more research vast thoughts?
McGrath v Maynard, JLT watch, DeGoey in this bracket also.
Bennell, but only when training reports start coming in, AhChee will get plenty of 2018 minutes and is fit, from all reports training well and impressing senior players.

Ill come back to u next year

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Yeah. **** you Here2tellyouwhy

Oliver>Cuz

haha umm no.

Oliver would sneeze all over the coke mid line

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Has some more strings to the bow yet to be fully shown. Have a look at his final u18 year highlights. Has a bit of run and carry and ability to mark up forward and kick a goal. He’ll get there.

Wait and see I guess. Don't see it just yet though and not expecting much improvement this year. A 111 average is still pretty good.

 

[markm106]

Wait and see I guess. Don't see it just yet though and not expecting much improvement this year. A 111 average is still pretty good.

Yeah if he keeps up 111 that’s pretty good. But I doubt he’s peaked in year 2. He’ll go up another level I think. Even if not next season.

 

[Hawkboy62]

Petracca vs DeGoey vs Lobb?

 

[King_Steele]

Petracca vs DeGoey vs Lobb?

Lobb.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Petracca vs DeGoey vs Lobb?

I have Lobb penciled in at F4 ...due to being #1 ruck this year

De Goey is also penciled in conditionally a) DPP b) plays more midfield c) 4th year & needs to realise his talent .......but Charlie Curnow is a watch in case

 

[King_Steele]

I have Lobb penciled in at F4 ...due to being #1 ruck this year

De Goey is also penciled in conditionally a) DPP b) plays more midfield c) 4th year & needs to realise his talent .......but Charlie Curnow is a watch in case

Parish also needs to be considered in that price range.

 

[markm106]

Petracca vs DeGoey vs Lobb?

I’d go Lobb at this stage. More of a sure thing as a number one ruck.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Parish also needs to be considered in that price range.

Gee, has he shown enough yet, to be considered? ......no tons in 2017, and averaging 75 points .....even a 20 point jump in a season (unusual) would only have him as a 95 point player ......$419K ? maybe safer options

 

[King_Steele]

haha umm no.

Oliver would sneeze all over the coke mid line

Ummmm. You get out.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Ummmm. You get out.

View attachment 448408

Your doing it wrong!!!

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Gee, has he shown enough yet, to be considered? ......no tons in 2017, and averaging 75 points .....even a 20 point jump in a season (unusual) would only have him as a 95 point player ......$419K ? maybe safer options

Then add in Devon, Stringer & Saad to the side.

No for me at this stage.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Then add in Devon, Stringer & Saad to the side.

No for me at this stage.

Your thoughts on DeGoey?

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Your thoughts on DeGoey?

Word is he's still got to increase his tank & two way running before increasing mid mins.

 

[King_Steele]

Word is he's still got to increase his tank & two way running before increasing mid mins.

Shhhh. Let the plebs pick him.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Shhhh. Let the plebs pick him.

He's in my team ATM.

More a wait & see placeholder though.

My teams all over the shop right now though. Has Pruess in it & $550k in le pussah.

It's more who I like plus players that should be on a watchlist.

 

[toxic]

Gee, has he shown enough yet, to be considered? ......no tons in 2017, and averaging 75 points .....even a 20 point jump in a season (unusual) would only have him as a 95 point player ......$419K ? maybe safer options

Parish is average.
No signs of being SC relevant

 

[King_Steele]

Yeo v Witherden +80k

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yeo v Witherden +80k

Post JLT series call on that one?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Yeo v Witherden +80k

Witherden at this stage IMO

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Yeo v Witherden +80k

I can't believe how many people are willing to fork out 480k for a 9 gamer.

To be fair they were 9 pretty good games, but still a big NO for me.

 

[stevebbb]

I can't believe how many people are willing to fork out 480k for a 9 gamer.

To be fair they were 9 pretty good games, but still a big NO for me.

+1
100% this

 

[Leica Tsunami]

Parish is average.
No signs of being SC relevant

Agree.

Parish gets talked about in fantasy way more than he should. Doesn’t look relevant at any stage.