Player X v Y v Z

[Judd_Magic]

I've started with JOM....is it a waste of a trade to go to Cogs?

Hell no brutha.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Bonner v Fisher

Fisher.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Dusty v Oliver

Reckon they will both average 120-125 but Dusty for me, he doesn't need as many touches as Piggy to score heavily.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

One trade for the week. Dahlhaus can GTFO so

Heeney v McLean

Heeney .....did you see his contested possessions last week .....

 

[Dundalis]

Go Cogs and save cash.

Similar output anyways.....

The cash difference does need to be considered, but I think Oliver will legit be a 120+ scorer, maybe only behind Martin, TMitch and Danger in PPG output this year. I'm gunning to get him in my side maybe more than Danger. I'd be surprised if Cogs is within 10ppg of the pig at years end, especially with the competition for points at GWS.

 

[shizzam]

Taranto vs Fisher

 

[Axly]

Fisher.

Thanks
What are your reasons sir?

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Venables, Waterman, English, Gowers.

Bit of a chook raffle to be honest though and Waterman could get dropped when Kennedy comes back.

I'll go with Venables then Gowers. I like this Gowers kid... just needs to kick straight

 

[Judd_Magic]

Thanks
What are your reasons sir?

Just think he has more of a chance of being a keeper than Bonner.

Fisher is a super skilled little player too.

Plus the coach loves him so he will play every game.

We don't have tons of players to steal points off each other either compared to Port.

 

[Dundalis]

Taranto vs Fisher

Think this is Taranto easily, even though Taranto is probably at the club with the highest competition for points in the league. Almost 30 touches and 6 tackles a game, is output you can't easily ignore. I'm surprised more people aren't talking about him at his price.

 

[Red Syrah]

Lever > finlayson via dpp from mids

Bringing in:
fogarty for cash gen (have all the others)
Taranto - into fwds and only 1 rookie on field

 

[Old Stuckup]

Coniglio and Gray vs Taranto and Oliver?

 

[toxic]

Coniglio and Gray vs Taranto and Oliver?

oliver and taranto

 

[Imoster]

Shaw Vs Luke Ryan Vs Charlie Curnow Vs Taranto

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Oliver vs Cripps + 80K bank.

Reasons for Oliver:
- Season averages of 70, 111 and 135 in 2 games - going up every year.
- Gawn back and Melbourne should improve
- Slight increase in TOG due to fitness? Had over 80% TOG 9/22 games last year. 2/2 so far this year.

Reasons for Cripps:
- Basement price - Priced to average just 98 after injuries last year, Ave 108 the year before and 123 so far.
- Carlton should improve (though looked bad on the weekend but Cripps still got 115).
- No bank otherwise and 80K will assist to upgrade elsewhere sooner.
- Better bye round than Oliver.

Final thought: Bringing one in will leave me with 6 mid premiums but no Danger, Dusty or Crouch (who will all be top 5-6 scorers). As such, some merit in just going the higher averaging player regardless of cost.

Thoughts? (I know I mentioned this in the trades thread but thought full explanation may be helpful to others and more opinions are good, especially as I got one vote for each.)

 

[toxic]

Oliver vs Cripps + 80K bank.

Reasons for Oliver:
- Season averages of 70, 111 and 135 in 2 games - going up every year.
- Gawn back and Melbourne should improve
- Slight increase in TOG due to fitness? Had over 80% TOG 9/22 games last year. 2/2 so far this year.

Reasons for Cripps:
- Basement price - Priced to average just 98 after injuries last year, Ave 108 the year before and 123 so far.
- Carlton should improve (though looked bad on the weekend but Cripps still got 115).
- No bank otherwise and 80K will assist to upgrade elsewhere sooner.
- Better bye round than Oliver.

Final thought: Bringing one in will leave me with 6 mid premiums but no Danger, Dusty or Crouch (who will all be top 5-6 scorers). As such, some merit in just going the higher averaging player regardless of cost.

Thoughts? (I know I mentioned this in the trades thread but thought full explanation may be helpful to others and more opinions are good, especially as I got one vote for each.)

Cripps, oliver becomes mrs jacobs this week

 

[pulpdriver]

Fisher vs Bundy

 

[Mitchell54]

Coniglio and Gray vs Taranto and Oliver?

Cogs & Gray

Shaw Vs Luke Ryan Vs Charlie Curnow Vs Taranto

CC & Tarantula

Oliver vs Cripps + 80K bank.

Reasons for Oliver:
- Season averages of 70, 111 and 135 in 2 games - going up every year.
- Gawn back and Melbourne should improve
- Slight increase in TOG due to fitness? Had over 80% TOG 9/22 games last year. 2/2 so far this year.

Reasons for Cripps:
- Basement price - Priced to average just 98 after injuries last year, Ave 108 the year before and 123 so far.
- Carlton should improve (though looked bad on the weekend but Cripps still got 115).
- No bank otherwise and 80K will assist to upgrade elsewhere sooner.
- Better bye round than Oliver.

Final thought: Bringing one in will leave me with 6 mid premiums but no Danger, Dusty or Crouch (who will all be top 5-6 scorers). As such, some merit in just going the higher averaging player regardless of cost.

Thoughts? (I know I mentioned this in the trades thread but thought full explanation may be helpful to others and more opinions are good, especially as I got one vote for each.)

Cripps & 80K

Fisher vs Bundy

I’d go with the Fisher. Not sure what a Bundy is but I like fish’n chips so the Fisher gets the nod from me

 

[pulpdriver]

I’d go with the Fisher. Not sure what a Bundy is but I like fish’n chips so the Fisher gets the nod from me

Bundy is Allen Christensen.

 

[Mitchell54]

Bundy is Allen Christensen.

I like fish’n chips even more now. Bundy is disgusting

 

[pulpdriver]

I like fish’n chips even more now. Bundy is disgusting

 

[sceptic tank]

Want to get Bonner in so trading Byrne to get him.. I need some cash from somewhere else to make it happen so have decided to trade Lambert out.

Narrowed it down to 4, who do I pick?

Acres, Taranto, Smith, Petracca

 

[Judd_Magic]

Want to get Bonner in so trading Byrne to get him.. I need some cash from somewhere else to make it happen so have decided to trade Lambert out.

Narrowed it down to 4, who do I pick?

Acres, Taranto, Smith, Petracca

Smith.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Cripps, oliver becomes mrs jacobs this week

Thanks mate - though I'm picking them as keepers for the season so opponent this week doesn't mean much.

 

[Axly]

Barry v Garlett v LDU

For SP , JS ?!