Player X vs Player Y (Part II)

[V_23]

Boyd vs Ablett

Boyd is more consistent, Ablett more explosive. Personally, I'm going Boyd unless things change dramatically by the time Boyd drops in price a bit.

 

[Hodge1]

Can't pick from Roughead or Sylvia.

The big Rough has been elite but can he keep it up?

 

[thebizz3]

I think its time for another premium player in my forward line but who do I choose?? I already have Goodes, Franklin, Pavlich, Riewoldt.
Chapman vs S Johnson vs Sylvia.
What about Fyfe? Can he keep it up for the rest of the year?
Thanks guys

 

[dread and might]

current mids are Judd, bartel, Swan, Pendlebury, kennedy, Libba, (harris, ISmith, Hibberd) (I also have Pav, Goodes deledio, gibbs, Heppel as MPP). I have 333K in bank, so

Boyd, vs Hodge, vs Mundy, vs Selwood, vs Thompson, vs Ablett.??

Don't really want murphy as too many blues for finals. Mundy is part of a multi-bye and Selwood might make too many cats come finals.

Aarghh!

 

[Dizzy Stuff]

Thoughts on who to keep as M7 out of Liberatore and Harris? Have 5 GC players (although only Ablett is in my best 22) as opposed to Libba being my only bulldog, but then Harris is the more experienced player and may be more reliable towards the end of the year.

 

[Jirahax]

Scott Thompson or Mundy.
Heath Shaw or Sam Fisher.

 

[joxstrap]

Someone convince me to get Dal Santo over Boyd.

I really can't decide between them. Then there is Montagna, Ablett, Watson or Mundy.

I like Dal Santo because he's almost always averaged over 110 for the last 5 years. Downside is that he's my third Saint, and they aren't travelling well, so he might get rested at the death.

Boyd similar problems, but he's going better this year than Dal Santo, and I don't have any Dogs.

Ablett will get rested if he has even the slightest niggle.

Mundy will suffer without Sandy and is par of one of the epic byes.

Montagna, see Dal Santo, but doing it for less time, and is prone to turn it over occasionally.

Watson, coming back from injury is a worry.

Scott Thompson might be a nice unique.

Current mids:

Swan, Pendlebury, Selwood, Judd, Priddis, X (Iles, Mzungu, Atley)

 

[JasRulz63]

Mundy actually didn't go too badly on the weekend without Sandi I thought. He wasn't as influential as usual (then again the whole Freo team didn't), but the fact that he still works to get his own ball, means he didn't suffer heaps without Sandi. Though I guess one game isn't much to judge on (though it's one game less until Sandi gets back).

 

[bestin]

Priddis VS Ablett VS Murphy

 

[Main Man]

Priddis VS Ablett VS Murphy

Murphy, but they are all good options.

Chapman vs Sylvia?

 

[Bomber4ever]

Murphy, but they are all good options.

Chapman vs Sylvia?

Sylvia. Averaging 107 with a lowest score of 82.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Ablett vs S Thompson with league only in mind

 

[SoupAStars]

It's handy that Ablett has already had 2 byes, is quite affordable considering his average and GCS is improving all the time.
But, Thompson really is tearing it up. Personally, I'd go with Ablett (and that's what I'm planning to do myself).

 

[CaTTer4Eva]

Ablett vs S Thompson with league only in mind

Personally, I'd go Ablett out of those two.

I just cant seem to make a decision regarding Ablett vs Hodge. Both have tremendous scoring potential when on song. Ablett is 50k more than the other without the byes, however Hodge is 50k less (obviously) but plays in a better side where he is more likely to score consistently.

Current midfield is: Pendles, Judd, Selwood, Boak, Libba, Swallow, Harris.
Harris > Mzungu
Libba > Hodge or Ablett????

Help!

 

[Zim^zuM]

Personally, I'd go Ablett out of those two.

I just cant seem to make a decision regarding Ablett vs Hodge. Both have tremendous scoring potential when on song. Ablett is 50k more than the other without the byes, however Hodge is 50k less (obviously) but plays in a better side where he is more likely to score consistently.

Current midfield is: Pendles, Judd, Selwood, Boak, Libba, Swallow, Harris.
Harris > Mzungu
Libba > Hodge or Ablett????

Help!

Well Thompson is a better scorer than Hodge, And you think Ablett is better than Thompson. So Ablett is your man lol

 

[CaTTer4Eva]

Well Thompson is a better scorer than Hodge, And you think Ablett is better than Thompson. So Ablett is your man lol

Fair call! haha

 

[BomberJacqui]

Priddis ? Thompson? or Boyd?

providing i have Ablett,Penders,Judd,Mundy & Selwood

Too hard to decide lol

I was thinking priddis as he might score better against better opponents and not alot of people own him?

Or Wait a few weeks and get swan?

I am just worried Harris will start dropping money now

 

[shurg123]

Enright vs Rawlings?

 

[dlanod]

Enright vs Rawlings?

I'd still take Enright with his record over the last few years.

Vardy v Bailey for a ruck downgrade?

 

[The Swert]

I'd still take Enright with his record over the last few years.

Vardy v Bailey for a ruck downgrade?

Bailey seems to kept out both Renouf and Hale this week proving his security. Everyone knows he's talented so he'll probably get an extended run now unless he gets injured or spuds up.

 

[bestin]

I'd still take Enright with his record over the last few years.

Vardy v Bailey for a ruck downgrade?

I would take Vardy, both Hale and Renouf are coming back in a week or 2 for hawks and Roughead is doing well as a ruckman, so theres only room for one of the trio in the team. Vardy is in some decent form, Scott has been giving youngsters a fair run as well

 

[J Squad]

Who do I keep for another week;

Yarran or Knights?

Knights seems to be getting alot of junk time points lately. Yarran is very capable of a 90-100 point game against Port. I get an extra 30k from downgrading Yarran, so leaning towards him.

Thoughts?

 

[Glenno23]

Who do I keep for another week;

Yarran or Knights?

Knights seems to be getting alot of junk time points lately. Yarran is very capable of a 90-100 point game against Port. I get an extra 30k from downgrading Yarran, so leaning towards him.

Thoughts?

Similar problem to me. But mine is Knights or Darling > Mzungu.

Knights kicking seems off this year, and he is having a poor DT> SC ratio for it

Both SHOULD score alright this week. Go yarran for the extra 30K. Both of your players BE is around 72ish, so knights can still make that and get you a little more moola, but in Yarran you have that cash now

I'm thinking Darling for me. BE of 97 and has made me 223K

 

[Pigdog]

Robert Murphy v Corey Enright v Bryce Gibbs?

 

[wixy1982]

Which GC player should I choose to keep in my team, Daniel Harris or David Swallow?