Player X vs Player Y (Part II)

[Chrizzt]

Harris seems to be struggling under an injury atm, and its hard to see them dropping swallow.

Have Pendles, Boyd, Priddis and Boak, want to upgrade Cotchin and Libba this week and my options are:

Murphy and Hodge
Thompson and Hodge
Selwood and Mitchell

Not completely sold on Mitchell, but not sure if Hodgey will be struggling under an injury for the rest of the year...

 

[toxic]

Which GC player should I choose to keep in my team, Daniel Harris or David Swallow?

neither....

 

[J Squad]

Which GC player should I choose to keep in my team, Daniel Harris or David Swallow?

Both should be upgraded in the next 1-2 weeks, too expensive to keep as bench and can easily be turned into premiums. Get rid of Harris first though, not 100% at the moment.

 

[footyfan08]

who to play on the ground this week out of:
T.Lynch (GCS) vs Darling
D. Harris vs Mzungu
M.Hibbered vs B.Jacobs

thoughts?

 

[Pedsy]

Who has better job security?
Vardy v Bailey v Gawn

 

[Daniels]

Who has better job security?
Vardy v Bailey v Gawn

Bailey IMO

 

[joxstrap]

who to play on the ground this week out of:
T.Lynch (GCS) vs Darling
D. Harris vs Mzungu
M.Hibbered vs B.Jacobs

thoughts?

Darling v GCS, easily.
Mzungu
Last one is tough - Jacobs gets lots of the ball but isn't using it as well as he could, and you have to factor in the LOLPORTLOL factor. Hibbard might be the sub, and won't probably get much of it given the Bombers will be sweetly caressing the bruise-avoiding Dees.

 

[Headless]

Thompson vs. Ablett is killing me.

I've had Thompson locked in all week, but this is GAJ we're talking about.

 

[bystanding backman]

Thompson vs. Ablett is killing me.

I've had Thompson locked in all week, but this is GAJ we're talking about.

Thompson for no other reason than i like that fact not as many people have him in their teams.

Mine is A Krakouer or Didak

 

[RWnBluey]

Thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis... Arrrrrrggggghhh!!!!....

Some help please!... Going for overall, Final mid upgrade

 

[Daniels]

Thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis, thompson, priddis... Arrrrrrggggghhh!!!!....

Some help please!... Going for overall, Final mid upgrade

Same decision for me also.

Took Priddis in end. As said in another thread in last 2 seasons Priddis had 100+ in 20 from last 28 games, that's enough for me...

Thompson not as good in same duration, but saying that has looked extremely solid at same time this season.

 

[Propagandhi]

Who to play on the field..? Too many choices this week! >.<

Backs: 1 of Duigan, Pupolo, Jacobs, Hibberd
Mids: 1 of Krakouer, Mzungu, Hibberd, Jacobs, Prestia
Fwds: 1 of Darling, Krakouer, Mzungu, Prestia

Leaning towards Duigan, Mzungu & Darling...

 

[RWnBluey]

Same decision for me also.

Took Priddis in end. As said in another thread in last 2 seasons Priddis had 100+ in 20 from last 28 games, that's enough for me...

Thompson not as good in same duration, but saying that has looked extremely solid at same time this season.

Also went prddis!

 

[Burzum]

Upgrading Duigan but can't decide between Scotland or Fisher. Leaning towards Scotland because he can play mid.

 

[tubes82]

Harris seems to be struggling under an injury atm, and its hard to see them dropping swallow.

Have Pendles, Boyd, Priddis and Boak, want to upgrade Cotchin and Libba this week and my options are:

Murphy and Hodge
Thompson and Hodge
Selwood and Mitchell

Not completely sold on Mitchell, but not sure if Hodgey will be struggling under an injury for the rest of the year...

Selwoods the best player out of all of them but if you cant get Selwood and hodge/murphy i would go Murphy and Hodge. Thompson is killing it but Adelaide are crap atm so i'm just not that keen.

 

[Kopout]

Which one of these guys should NOT start on my field?

- Krakoeur (vs St Kilda @ MCG)
- Mzungu (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- Lower (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- L Thompson (vs North Melbourne @ Etihad)

 

[Moogs]

I'm planning my trades for the next few weeks.... My options are either to trade Stanley or Lower in the backs to either of Enright or Shaw..
This will effect my final trade next week... Which should be Darling -> Franklin or Brennan

So the question is..

Enright/Franklin/Stanley (D8)
vs
Shaw/Brennan/Lower (D8)
vs
Enright/Roughead/Lower (D8)

note: I also have Poupolo, Jacobs, Hibberd in my backline if that makes any difference...

 

[Daniels]

I'm planning my trades for the next few weeks.... My options are either to trade Stanley or Lower in the backs to either of Enright or Shaw..
This will effect my final trade next week... Which should be Darling -> Franklin or Brennan

So the question is..

Enright/Franklin/Stanley (D8)
vs
Shaw/Brennan/Lower (D8)
vs
Enright/Roughead/Lower (D8)

note: I also have Poupolo, Jacobs, Hibberd in my backline if that makes any difference...

Option 1

Can see that combo (Enright/Franklin) getting you 200+ each week. Stanley will do as cover

 

[toxic]

I'm planning my trades for the next few weeks.... My options are either to trade Stanley or Lower in the backs to either of Enright or Shaw..
This will effect my final trade next week... Which should be Darling -> Franklin or Brennan

So the question is..

Enright/Franklin/Stanley (D8)
vs
Shaw/Brennan/Lower (D8)
vs
Enright/Roughead/Lower (D8)

note: I also have Poupolo, Jacobs, Hibberd in my backline if that makes any difference...

can you do shaw, franklin, lower?

 

[shaun1800]

Which one of these guys should NOT start on my field?

- Krakoeur (vs St Kilda @ MCG)
- Mzungu (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- Lower (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- L Thompson (vs North Melbourne @ Etihad)

Thompson for sure, ever since his big score in his third game he's been spudding.

 

[Hurdley]

Which one of these guys should NOT start on my field?

- Krakoeur (vs St Kilda @ MCG)
- Mzungu (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- Lower (vs Hawthorn @ MCG)
- L Thompson (vs North Melbourne @ Etihad)

Thompson.

Newman v Broughton? As a tradein option for this week.

 

[joxstrap]

Which defender for under 408k?

I have my eye on Broughton because he doesn't need much of the ball to score well.

I already have:

Deledio, Newman, Shaw, Goddard, Gibbs, Enright, Heppell, Lower

 

[dlanod]

Yep, I'd limit it to Broughton, Suckling or Hurn, and Broughton's looked the best out of them so far. Hurn could be good if you want a potential bargain though.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Is that your last upgrade?

If not I'd keep playing Heppell and make the other upgrades first.

 

[joxstrap]

Is that your last upgrade?

If not I'd keep playing Heppell and make the other upgrades first.

Yeah it's effectively the last upgrade.

Heppell will be on the pitch because I'd had to put Deledio in the middle while Swan is out. I will also most likely bring in Chapman for Darling. Just because I like posting my team, this will be it this week with Swan on the bench:

Newman, Goddard, Enright, Gibbs, Broughton, H Shaw, Heppell (Hibbard, Puopolo, Toy)
Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Priddis, Deledio, Judd, Selwood (Swan, Iles, Smith)
Cox, Smith (Bailey, J Tippet)
Franklin, Pavlich, Harvey, O'Keefe, Petrie, N Riewoldt, Chapman (Mzungu, Matera, Richardson)

Then Didak for Matera next week, and Sandilands back in after the bye.