Player X vs Player Y (Part II)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fyfe in the mid, Franklin in the fwd.

Both carrying injuries

I have mzungu to cover one of these too.

The question is, who needs the cover more? Who is less likely to play?
Hmm it's hard to tell who is going to play, they just name them on the field to play mind games I think.

Not sure the extent of Fyfe's shoulder injuries, but you can always tape a shoulder and get out there. Whereas a calf injury is quite difficult to get up for, considering it's a big game for the Hawks, they need him to play.

Really got NFI myself..:eek:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

thanks mate!!

thats what i thought, then i wrote it down on paper it sounded so much better.

spewing, i wanted to get okeefe this week but ahh well. will be better for my bench long term if i wait on him and get griff before he goes up.
 
Tough one, I'd personally go Vardy but don't take my word for it :)

Should i get Priddis now, Swan after Round 13 or another midfielder? Already have Judd, Selwood, Mundy, Pendlebury and Ablett.

vardy will do ok. are u talking about trading in? i'd pay the extra for j griffen if you have it.
i would get priddis now i hate to say. the few extra weeks will help. have u got many trades? could u get priddis now then do a sideways premo upgrade to swan for the last 6 rounds if he comes good?

should i play J griffen against bombers or z smith against north?
 
vardy will do ok. are u talking about trading in? i'd pay the extra for j griffen if you have it.
i would get priddis now i hate to say. the few extra weeks will help. have u got many trades? could u get priddis now then do a sideways premo upgrade to swan for the last 6 rounds if he comes good?

should i play J griffen against bombers or z smith against north?
Id go with Smith. Griffin has played one game (albeit a good one), whereas Smith has done well for a while.

On Griffin, I can't afford him but I am looking for a good back-up ruckman to trade in. Prefer games played than scoring ability. Not sure Griffin will keep his spot with Sandi to come back....
 
Really need help here.........i have a couple of starting player dilemmas, advice is required!!

Heppell vs Puopolo vs Otten vs Lower down back (have room for 1)

Mzunga vs Knights vs Tom Lynch vs Sam Iles (have room for 1)



At the moment i've got Heppel with Puopolo as emergency

Mzunga in mid with Iles as emergency

Much appreciated.....
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Thanks for that, was leaning that way.

I was intending either Poppy or Bach to Strauss but Smith out has f****d that up.

Looks like Bailey will be joining. Not too opposed as I would never have freed up Smiths $ and I can keep solid benches in my backs.
 
There's one spot left in my midfield. I've got:

Pendlebury, GAJ, Judd, Priddis and Bartel.

The final upgrade spot was being held open for Swan upon his return, but then there's Matthew Boyd who just keep smashing out huge scores. He's priced nicely, and I can get him this week to finish the midfield.

Do I get Boyd and do without Swan, or do I have to wait for Swan? Can I win finals without him?
 
There's one spot left in my midfield. I've got:

Pendlebury, GAJ, Judd, Priddis and Bartel.

The final upgrade spot was being held open for Swan upon his return, but then there's Matthew Boyd who just keep smashing out huge scores. He's priced nicely, and I can get him this week to finish the midfield.

Do I get Boyd and do without Swan, or do I have to wait for Swan? Can I win finals without him?
If you don't have a donut this week or you're playing for league then I'd wait a week and get Swan
 
Please only post a given post in one thread. It means you get better quality responses because they can build off each other rather than rehash what someone else has already replied to you in another thread.
 
I.Smith can play midfield and forward so take him.

My midfield at the moment is Pendelbury, Ablett, Selwood, Judd, Watson & Boak
I'm getting rid of Selwood and I am deciding between
Boyd or Pavlich
 
I.Smith can play midfield and forward so take him.

My midfield at the moment is Pendelbury, Ablett, Selwood, Judd, Watson & Boak
I'm getting rid of Selwood and I am deciding between
Boyd or Pavlich

Boyd. No question.

Last forward upgrade - Sylvia, Fyfe or Rioli?
 
Boyd. No question.

Last forward upgrade - Sylvia, Fyfe or Rioli?
tuff call - all 3 injury prone to an extent - I'd choose Fyfe if he stays fit (shoulder), Rioli does not have MPP which is his only downside
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top