Player X vs Player Y Thread

[SHAKESPEARE]

Cross and Petrie

vs

Ward and Cox

Cross and Petrie. Should average around 190+ imo.

I've got Sandi, Cox (J Tippett, Z Smith). When the stars have a bye, Petrie comes in and performs. He is a lock in my forward line also when he returns from suspension.

I

 

[pies21]

corey v foley+63k

and

rioli v franklin

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

none and franklin

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

cotchin & $95,300 left

or

Boak & $8,100 left

 

[dima_1771]

Judd v Hodge v Montagna

Judd leaves me in trouble down the track in finals
Hodge is underdone
Montagna, not as good as previous two
Any others?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

cotchin & $95,300 left

or

Boak & $8,100 left

Cotchin. Easy done

 

[ozzyoslo]

If you're going to pick, montagna, that means you've got Goddard(lock), reiwoldt?? And montagna.... Too many premiums for my liking.

New rule for 2011 , NO MORE THAN 2 PREMIUMS FROM THE ONE SIDE TIL AFTER THEIR LAST BYE. VERY SIMPLE.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

You tell them....

 

[dima_1771]

well do you go down further and bank on someone like cross boyd or watson, or deal with judd and trade or risk hodge and carry him thru first few weeks

 

[ThePezDispenser]

well do you go down further and bank on someone like cross boyd or watson, or deal with judd and trade or risk hodge and carry him thru first few weeks

Not sure what you're saying. Out of those I would go Judd easily in front followed by the bulldogs boys then Watson and the under prepared Hodge at the bottom.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

yup. Hodge is a definite mid/late year upgrade.

Judd, for now, is safe as houses

 

[Antimatter]

OK here's my conundrums...

Cross vs Boyd

Sylvia vs Higgins

Delidio vs Burgoyne vs Cotchin (one of these three)

 

[ThePezDispenser]

OK here's my conundrums...

Cross vs Boyd

Sylvia vs Higgins

Delidio vs Burgoyne vs Cotchin (one of these three)

I like the upsode Boyd offers= compared to Cross

Higgins

And Lids, but preferably in your backs.

 

[Antimatter]

I like the upsode Boyd offers= compared to Cross

Higgins

And Lids, but preferably in your backs.

Cheers...got Gibbs & Goddard as MPP backs so was shying away from having all 3 down back....currently have Burger in there but tempted by Cotchins potential upside & Lid's MPP flexibility.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I like the upsode Boyd offers= compared to Cross

Higgins

And Lids, but preferably in your backs.

this

 

[Studbuddy]

Gaff vs Conca vs Polec.

Which of these youngsters should I slot into my midfield? Cheers.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

None tbh

 

[Vapor]

Goodes or Harvey as a MPP?

 

[dlanod]

Gaff vs Conca vs Polec.

Which of these youngsters should I slot into my midfield? Cheers.

Out of that lot, Conca looks the most secure in his place in the team but that's not saying a lot.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Goodes or Harvey as a MPP?

Harvey is a consistent gun, but getting on and should share more points with better, fitter young mids.

Goodes goes up and down, but has that 150+ capability. Looks a treat.

I would flip a coin. hahah i've got goodes but had harvey 3 times already this year

 

[StGradey]

Murphy, Hayes and Franklin (10k left) Vs Judd, Dalsanto and Rioli ($200 left) Vs Murphy, Dalsanto, Rioli (32k left)?

 

[Shakermaker94]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Murphy, Hayes and Franklin



my one is wallis or libba?

 

[BomberARMY]

Libba.. from all reports

 

[Gee Dub]

Hale v Stanley + 49000 as a Fwd/Ruck to swap with Petrie? Or save my money and spend the extra 100k (plus the spare 100 I currently have) on upgrading my reasonably weak forward line (Yarran is currently F4)?

Also Watson, Swallow, Boyd or Boak? (Will most likely upgrade this player to Ablett)

And finally Gray, Yarran, Higgins or Knights?

 

[UpTheGuts]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Murphy, Hayes and Franklin



my one is wallis or libba?

Doubt either is a walk up start - better at that price

Gamble or Otten?