Player X vs Y

[Feerits Elf]

If I get Libba, there is a small chance I may be able to get JPK in for Swan as a luxury trade, assuming Swan goes huge in the next few weeks.

There's also the small consideration that Libba averages 164 against the Demons.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Brodie Smith v. Lynden Dunn??

 

[Goats]

Do you need the 70k for anything? If not then McVeigh easily

The 70k allows me to get any mid for my last mid upgrade next week, if I get McVeigh then it's any mid $620k or >.

Almost certainly going with McVeigh because it's a shitty POD not having him.

 

[Feerits Elf]

The 70k allows me to get any mid for my last mid upgrade next week, if I get McVeigh then it's any mid $620k or >.

Which is who? Ablett, Pendlebury, Liberatore and JPK?

How many of those four do you have?

 

[SnappyHappy]

The 70k allows me to get any mid for my last mid upgrade next week, if I get McVeigh then it's any mid $620k or >.

Almost certainly going with McVeigh because it's a shitty POD not having him.

$620k is plenty, get McVeigh

 

[Jiska]

Gray + ~30K vs Boomer

Get both

 

[Goats]

Which is who? Ablett, Pendlebury, Liberatore and JPK?

How many of those four do you have?

I have Pendles and GAJ, not keen on JPK at that price, I don't think he'll keep his current average for the rest of the season. I'm also conscious of saving some coin for my last forward upgrade which I'm hoping will be Gray or Harvey.

McVeigh it will be, appreciate everyone's input.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Get both

Not enough trades or cash on bench to get both

 

[Hoges64]

Last minute doubts: Hurn or Burgoyne?

Hurn: capable of busting out the big numbers. More injury prone. Averages 104 over his 7 full games, but 157 last week skews that a bit. Average of 91.9 for $484k

Burgoyne: played 12 games. Super reliable. 4 scores in 70's, otherwise 90+ with 5 in the ton and above. DPP can be handy but I think I have enough of those with Hanley, Langdon and McVeigh. Average 97.6 at $454k.

Considering i'll only have three trades left after this for injuries / upgrades every dollar counts but I'd hate for Hurn to rampage and score 15 a week more than Burgoyne who has done a load of work so far this year with so many guys missing around him. Burgoynes numbers were better with Mitchell, Gibson etc around him though.

HELP!!!!!!

Or I could go really left field and just go Grimes at average of 75 (not bad with a 23 in there) for $331k.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Last minute doubts: Hurn or Burgoyne?

Hurn: capable of busting out the big numbers. More injury prone. Averages 104 over his 7 full games, but 157 last week skews that a bit. Average of 91.9 for $484k

Burgoyne: played 12 games. Super reliable. 4 scores in 70's, otherwise 90+ with 5 in the ton and above. DPP can be handy but I think I have enough of those with Hanley, Langdon and McVeigh. Average 97.6 at $454k.

Considering i'll only have three trades left after this for injuries / upgrades every dollar counts but I'd hate for Hurn to rampage and score 15 a week more than Burgoyne who has done a load of work so far this year with so many guys missing around him. Burgoynes numbers were better with Mitchell, Gibson etc around him though.

HELP!!!!!!

How much cash do you have to spend? I don't like either, but if I had to chose Id probably go Burgoyne

 

[Hoges64]

How much cash do you have to spend? I don't like either, but if I had to chose Id probably go Burgoyne

Getting Hurn leaves me with $90k, so Burgoyne would leave $120k. So that's what, about $570ish to start.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Getting Hurn leaves me with $90k, so Burgoyne would leave $120k. So that's what, about $570ish to start.

What's the rest of your backline? And are you keeping cash in the bank for any particular reason? There are better options than Burgoyne and Hurn IMO.

 

[gh172]

S martin or McGovern, cant decide! Help please !!

 

[Hoges64]

What's the rest of your backline? And are you keeping cash in the bank for any particular reason? There are better options than Burgoyne and Hurn IMO.

Back line is McVeigh, Hanley, R. Murphy, Langdon, Jaensch, Talia (who is the trade out at $317k), with Langford and Cutler on bench.

Main reason I'm keeping cash is to either K. Mitchell or J. Lloyd > S. Mitchell to finish midfield, plus have McGovern, Shenton and Ambrose at F5, F6 & F7 and 2 of those will need an upgrade at SC finals time.

Only 3 trades left so all will need to be upgrades or sideways at worst.

FYI, unfortunately all my MIDs are not DPP, so can't even swing any if them back and search for a value MID.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Hodge vs hanley
Thoughs please d6/d7

 

[keithrichards]

Hey guys

Going to get rid of Higgins, and wondering who best to get out of Harvey vs Gray vs other....

I have Watson in my side still, so the $20k difference in price will help next week, as I'll want to get Watson out, hopefully for JPK.

Will boomer come back down in a few weeks (2-3) or is it worth getting on him now before he continues to rise?

 

[TassieSaint]

Zorko vs Pav vs Dahlhaus???

 

[keithrichards]

Hey guys

Going to get rid of Higgins, and wondering who best to get out of Harvey vs Gray vs Buddy

I have Watson in my side still, so the $20k difference in price will help next week, as I'll want to get Watson out, hopefully for JPK.

Will boomer come back down in a few weeks (2-3) or is it worth getting on him now before he continues to rise?

Note Fwds are - Dangerfield, d Martin, zorko, pav, Higgins, Ambrose,(McGovern, Cameron)

 

[SnappyHappy]

Is Buddy a safe from here on in? What does everyone think he will average?

 

[GOAUS!]

Hey guys

Going to get rid of Higgins, and wondering who best to get out of Harvey vs Gray vs other....

I have Watson in my side still, so the $20k difference in price will help next week, as I'll want to get Watson out, hopefully for JPK.

Will boomer come back down in a few weeks (2-3) or is it worth getting on him now before he continues to rise?

Robbie Gray.

 

[DMerrett_3Votes]

JPK or Liberatore?

 

[GOAUS!]

JPK or Liberatore?

JPK, he's been so consistent this year. Libba is in very good form at the moment though.

 

[GOAUS!]

Is Buddy a safe from here on in? What does everyone think he will average?

Should average 95+ you would think/hope.

 

[keithrichards]

Robbie Gray.

Ahead of a cheaper buddy or wingard?

I'll have 1 final upgrade down the track which will end up being Boomer I think

 

[GOAUS!]

Ahead of a cheaper buddy or wingard?

I'll have 1 final upgrade down the track which will end up being Boomer I think

Yep, Gray should go 100+ from here I reckon. Wingard not spending enough time in the middle.