Player X vs Y

[GOAUS!]

Duffield

JM won't be pleased.

 

[toxic]

JM won't be pleased.

I got all sweaty typing it.
Doesnt seem right.
No idea what he is worth tbh

 

[GOAUS!]

I got all sweaty typing it.
Doesnt seem right.
No idea what he is worth tbh

He's doing well in my draft side. Wouldn't want him in my "real" team.

 

[toxic]

He's doing well in my draft side. Wouldn't want him in my "real" team.

Why?

Hes in form in a top 4 side currently playing a very sc friendly style

 

[GOAUS!]

Why?

Hes in form in a top 4 side currently playing a very sc friendly style

Reckon the MJ injury may have freed him up, once he gets back he may revert back to the Duffman of old.

 

[toxic]

Reckon the MJ injury may have freed him up, once he gets back he may revert back to the Duffman of old.

I think he was freed up when ibbo returned

 

[SnappyHappy]

Duffield

No way will I be getting Duffield. When MJ returns he'll start spudding it again, can't be trusted.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Which is the best upgrade??

Breust (92.7) > Rockliff (123.3)

Minson (96.3) > Mumford (124.5)

Fairly close on current averages but removing Mummy's score of 40 (his first game back from injury) his average jumps to 136. For the remainder of the season which trade would be better?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Which is the best upgrade??

Breust (92.7) > Rockliff (123.3)

Minson (96.3) > Mumford (124.5)

Fairly close on current averages but removing Mummy's score of 40 (his first game back from injury) his average jumps to 136. For the remainder of the season which trade would be better?

Breust to Rocky would be my pick of the lot...

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Bartel vs the bearded Malco?

 

[Crafted]

Bartel vs the bearded Malco?

Bartel will average more but we all know that he hasn't has his annual rest yet.

Unless you have good bench cover, I'd go with Malceski. He's also a POD too so that helps.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Duffield

I don't understand this guy a few years back he was looking a gun in and under hard type player. But last year or two he's very up and down. A source (my mate - ex eagles coaching staff lol) told me he's known as being a bit lazy.

 

[SC fish]

Have 8 trades left. Need to complete my mids. Would you:

A) Burn 2 trades to get one of Fyfe/JPK
B) Use 1 trade only to get one of K Jack/Goddard.

Leaning towards B.

Option B - Goddard for mine

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Had Duffield last year and it was a pain to field him at D6 every single week, a little bit like Enright this season.
Will be staying away no matter how good his recent form has been.

 

[Goats]

For last spots in my mid and forward line.

Rocky & Wingard

Vs.

Sloane & Gray

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

For last spots in my mid and forward line.

Rocky & Wingard

Vs.

Sloane & Gray

If you don't have Fyfe, get Fyfe and Gray. Otherwise Sloane and Gray- Wingard too erratic

 

[Poetic Justice]

Downgrading Ambrose:

Kersten or BenBrown? The former seems to offer more JS but the latter allows me to swap with Thurlow for ruck cover when needed.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Ben Brown has less JS than Kersten

Ben Brown gives me ruck cover when needed

wat

 

[Poetic Justice]

wat

Good point, but I guess if someone was to tell me that Ben Brown might have better JS than I know (which is zero cause I don't follow North at all) then I would swing that way. Can anyone give me that assurance??

 

[Feerits Elf]

I think Stefan Martin's the boat you were meant to be on, but it's left the harbour.

 

[Poetic Justice]

I'm on the S. Martin train he is currently my F6 (Amrbose @ F7) - what I was hoping to do was have some sort of bench cover on every line which at the moment means only my ruck has no cover.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm on the S. Martin train he is currently my F6 (Amrbose @ F7) - what I was hoping to do was have some sort of bench cover on every line which at the moment means only my ruck has no cover.

Maybe get both side show Brown and Kersten.

 

[Poetic Justice]

Hmm might do that, running low on trades. Might see if Brown gets named this week and make a hard decision and bring Kersten in the week after

 

[Feerits Elf]

?

I don't follow.

If you have Thurlow and Martin already, you have bench cover for the ruck.

If you need bench cover for the forwards, you bring in Kersten.

Why do you need Brown?

 

[Lums23]

Good point, but I guess if someone was to tell me that Ben Brown might have better JS than I know (which is zero cause I don't follow North at all) then I would swing that way. Can anyone give me that assurance??

He has very little JS. Scott loves Tarrant so once he is fit he will be back. Also competing with Majak and Mason Wood. Unless he has a big game in the next two weeks he will probably get dropped