Player X vs Y

[timtamWB]

Libba v Macrae + 235k ?

Libba. I love Macrae, but once Griffen comes back into the team his numbers and scoring will dry up a bit. Libba has shown that he can do it with Griff in the team.

 

[kananooks]

Which two would you pick as the MID Bench: Michie, C.Beams, Dunstan or M.Crouch

for the bench?? dunstan and crouch

 

[kananooks]

dwallow v grimes

 

[Judd_Magic]

dwallow v grimes

Tough to split as I have had both in my team alot.

Maybe Swallow just purely on the promise that he will be playing as a pure mid this year.

 

[kananooks]

k.jack v cotchin?

 

[Judd_Magic]

k.jack v cotchin?

Cotchin easily.

 

[kananooks]

Cotchin easily.

is it really that clear cut?

 

[jjsmitty8]

is it really that clear cut?

I don't think it is. Keiran Jack will be a huge POD, but all Cotchin needs to do to reach that next level is get back to kicking goals. He didn't do that so well in 2013 (I would know, I had to put up with him sharing the ball around all year), but if he can improve that side of his game again, it will be as clear as day to select.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Scotty Thompson (D4) and Kennedy-Harris (F6)

Or

Grimes (D4) and B.Kennedy (F6)

 

[Judd_Magic]

is it really that clear cut?

I reckon it is.

Cotchin has more upside than Jack IMO plus Champion Data love him.

 

[kananooks]

I reckon it is.

Cotchin has more upside than Jack IMO plus Champion Data love him.

do any of libba/JPK/sloane/fyfe have a chance against cotchin

 

[kananooks]

heres a decent one..

rockliff vs cotchin

mwahaha

 

[kananooks]

Scotty Thompson (D4) and Kennedy-Harris (F6)

Or

Grimes (D4) and B.Kennedy (F6)

scotty and jkh .. but not by much

I don't rate b . Kennedy that high .. a colliwobble supporter might have better insight into that

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Hodge v Hurn v Swallow v Grimes v Watts

2 from Pendles v Libba v Cotchin v Rocky v Murphy

Hale v Dixon

Taking into account price also..

 

[toxic]

Hodge v Hurn v Swallow v Grimes v Watts

2 from Pendles v Libba v Cotchin v Rocky v Murphy

Hale v Dixon

Taking into account price also..

Hodge by so so far its scary

Pendles & Rocky (assumes a midfield role)

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Hodge by so so far its scary

Pendles & Rocky (assumes a midfield role)

The exactly what I didn't want to hear, only cos I can't afford them all

 

[toxic]

The exactly what I didn't want to hear, only cos I can't afford them all

Same here, in fact struggling to afford two of them let alone all 3

 

[Test Tickle]

Hodge v Hurn v Swallow v Grimes v Watts

2 from Pendles v Libba v Cotchin v Rocky v Murphy

Hale v Dixon

Taking into account price also..

I'd go Hale, he probably wont score as high as Dixon at times but i think he is a good option to keep as a DPP in the Fwd line.
Especially if you have two risky ruckmen.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

I'd go Hale, he probably wont score as high as Dixon at times but i think he is a good option to keep as a DPP in the Fwd line.
Especially if you have two risky ruckmen.

Or 4

 

[Turly]

Enright + Lloyd (f8) OR Gunston/Pav + Laidler

 

[Stickers32]

Pav laidler

 

[Turly]

Pav laidler

I'm leaning towards option 2. Gunston is really tempting though. Feel that he could explode this year.

Pav seems more of a risk

 

[KardiniaPark]

heres a decent one..

rockliff vs cotchin

mwahaha

Both.

 

[Nick Freeman]

Libba vs Cotchin?
Cotchin could get back to his best but burnt me last year, and Libba could improve on last year, but don't know what to expect as he could be tagged. Both potential guns.

 

[stevebbb]

which of the 102,400 rucks will most likely never play this year?
J Holmes, M King, P Mitchell and A Smith

also

Pendles + Hickey
or
Liberatore + Lobbe/Jacobs