Player X vs Y

[Stickers32]

For those in the know...

Libba or Shuey trying to get both in as they will avg 110+ by years end but only have room for one

 

[Amazing Bombers]

For those in the know...

Libba or Shuey trying to get both in as they will avg 110+ by years end but only have room for one

I reckon Libba is more likely.

 

[timtamWB]

Laidler and D Martin + 47k or Suckling + Gunston.

I'd personally go Suckling and Gunston, because I think Gunston will become a premo, as in 540K+ premo.

 

[domskiezzzzzz]

Libba vs Watson?

Will all this ASADA stuff affect Watson's output?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

For those in the know...

Libba or Shuey trying to get both in as they will avg 110+ by years end but only have room for one

Definitely Libba for me.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Libba vs Watson?

Will all this ASADA stuff affect Watson's output?

Nobody knows if he will be banned and if not, how he will be mentally affected.
If really concerned, go Libba/Rocky.
Better still, go Cotchin if your bye structure allows.

 

[Stickers32]

Libba vs Watson?

Will all this ASADA stuff affect Watson's output?

Lol no chance! Watson is a star... If it was going to affect him it would of been last year!

 

[domskiezzzzzz]

Lol no chance! Watson is a star... If it was going to affect him it would of been last year!

He did average 10 points less than the year before

 

[Mattrox]

Pick one out of mummy,Lobbe and Jacobs?

I'm going Jacobs. Biased, but he is fit. Will improve over las year.

Sent from my GT-I9295 using Tapatalk

 

[Stickers32]

He did average 10 points less than the year before

Yeah so he can't get any worse

 

[hoddo]

Yeah so he can't get any worse

He'd want to get a whole lot better. He only averaged 100.1 after round 9 last season. That could have been for any number of reasons, but building pressure from the drug scandal hanging over his head seems a likely one. I can't see it getting any easier this year .. unless ASADA get their arses into gear and make an early decision.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Cotchin and Swallow
or
Murphy and Enright

 

[kananooks]

Cotchin and Swallow
or
Murphy and Enright

cotch and swallow

cant see enright improving.. although the oldies have proven that they can still perform .. boomer .. he seems the type of player to bottom out in price after a couple of bad games. maybe an upgrade target.

imo swallow will avg close enough to enright in order to make the price difference worthwhile

Murphy is a tough one. I personally believe he will average close to cotchin (not enright swallow close but enough to make you consider having both in your team)

*waits to be taken down by someone for comparing murphy and cotchin in the same pedigree*

 

[cdcanman]

Lol no chance! Watson is a star... If it was going to affect him it would of been last year!

If he gets banned I'm tipping he'll be rather heavily affected!

 

[karaoke]

Laidler and D Martin + 47k or Suckling + Gunston.

 

[karaoke]

Cotchin and Swallow
or
Murphy and Enright

Cotchin (115) & Swallow (85)

vs.

Murphy (105) & Enright (90)

Just!

 

[SureBuddy]

Cotchin (115) & Swallow (85)

vs.

Murphy (105) & Enright (90)

Just!

Cotchin (118) & Swallow (85)

vs

Murphy (95) & Enright (95)

Think that is a little more accurate.

 

[Jiska]

Laidler and D Martin + 47k or Suckling + Gunston.

Shaw/Sutcliffe, Gunston and 50k to spare

He'd want to get a whole lot better. He only averaged 100.1 after round 9 last season. That could have been for any number of reasons, but building pressure from the drug scandal hanging over his head seems a likely one. I can't see it getting any easier this year .. unless ASADA get their arses into gear and make an early decision.

Hahahahahahahahahah that's funny..

 

[Stickers32]

If he gets banned I'm tipping he'll be rather heavily affected!

No player will get banned I bet my Supercoach team on it

 

[karaoke]

Cotchin (118) & Swallow (85)

vs

Murphy (95) & Enright (95)

Think that is a little more accurate.

Based on what? Opinion?

 

[SureBuddy]

Based on what? Opinion?

On the previous years form where Murphy got destroyed almost every week by a tag. So not really opinion based at all. I would say your 105 is far more opinion based.

 

[karaoke]

On the previous years form where Murphy got destroyed almost every week by a tag. So not really opinion based at all. I would say your 105 is far more opinion based.

I didn't use word 'accurate' though,

plus what did Cotch ave last year? So is 118 ave opinion or accurate?

 

[Jiska]

On the previous years form where Murphy got destroyed almost every week by a tag. So not really opinion based at all. I would say your 105 is far more opinion based.

^^ this

 

[SureBuddy]

I didn't use word 'accurate' though,

plus what did Cotch ave last year? So is 118 ave opinion or accurate?

I don't think you can compare Cotch and Murph. One is pushing a top 5 mid in the competition. The other is barely making journos top 50 players in the comp atm. Yes my 118 is opinion based, but the chances of that occurring is far higher than Murph reaching 105.

 

[karaoke]

I don't think you can compare Cotch and Murph. One is pushing a top 5 mid in the competition. The other is barely making journos top 50 players in the comp atm. Yes my 118 is opinion based, but the chances of that occurring is far higher than Murph reaching 105.

Cotchin - 0 years of 118+ SC ave
Murphy - 4 years of 105+ SC ave

Not trying to compare them individually, I believe both can increase their SC ave by 10 pts this year on last year,

Again with my original post - IMO