Player X vs Y

[SureBuddy]

Beams, Daisy and Goldstein
OR
Rockliff, Daisy and Luey
OR
Cotchin, ROOKIE and Goldstein + 100k elsewhere?

Well Beams is a must. So factor that in to your decision.

 

[Hagpower FC]

Beams, Daisy and Goldstein
OR
Rockliff, Daisy and Luey
OR
Cotchin, ROOKIE and Goldstein + 100k elsewhere?

Number 1 Option for me! All 3 are in my team!

Whats everyones thoughts on -

R.Shaw & Suckling
vs
Hurn & Laidler

 

[toxic]

Caddy & Higgins V Hawkins & Lamb > ?

Hawkins and BKennedy

the lamb has been turned into cutlets and higgins is at the comedy festival in kings cross all winter

 

[toxic]

Beams, Daisy and Goldstein
OR
Rockliff, Daisy and Luey
OR
Cotchin, ROOKIE and Goldstein + 100k elsewhere?

Beams, Rookie, Luey & cash left over for a party

 

[Clutch]

Daisy and defender 2 defender rookies starting (McDonald and someone under 130) v Suckling and 4 mid rookies starting.

 

[Two Planks]

Shiels or Thomas or Savage ???

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Libba vs Cotchin vs Jack vs Fyfe?

 

[Test Tickle]

Libba vs Cotchin vs Jack vs Fyfe?

Libba

 

[toxic]

Libba vs Cotchin vs Jack vs Fyfe?

All of them

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Shiels or Thomas or Savage ???

Shiels I think. Will get more midfield time as he won't tag, killed it in NAB and Thomas is injury prone while savage in a shit house team.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

All of them

only can have 1 ... so which one

 

[karaoke]

Libba vs Cotchin vs Jack vs Fyfe?

IMHO

Cotchin>Libba>Fyfe>Jack

I have Cotchin at 115 this year, others at ~110, FWIW

 

[toxic]

only can have 1 ... so which one

base it on which one suits your byes better

Jack massive POD
Fyfe - a solid POD
Cotchin - getting more popular by the day
Libba - pretty popular already

 

[Two Planks]

Libba vs Cotchin vs Jack vs Fyfe?

Cotchin for me

 

[Judd_Magic]

If your going for 5 mid premos then I reckon Ablett, Rocky, Cotchin, Libba and Beams looks pretty sexy.

Its the mid structure I'm thinking of going into round 1 with at the moment.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

IMHO

Cotchin>Libba>Fyfe>Jack

I have Cotchin at 115 this year, others at ~110, FWIW

I'm just worried in case he stinks it up like last year (for his standards)
Im stuck between him and Libba. Libba won't get tagged but Cotchin might, and not sure how well he can break one.

 

[karaoke]

I'm just worried in case he stinks it up like last year (for his standards)
Im stuck between him and Libba. Libba won't get tagged but Cotchin might, and not sure how well he can break one.

Go with your gut,

 

[timtamWB]

If your going for 5 mid premos then I reckon Ablett, Rocky, Cotchin, Libba and Beams looks pretty sexy.

Its the mid structure I'm thinking of going into round 1 with at the moment.

Shut up you, stop telling people my team!

This is what I'm going. Did have Watson in place of Cotchin, but downgrading Watson allowed me to make my backs/forwards look a bit better.

 

[domskiezzzzzz]

Watson & K.Simpson

vs

Pendlebury & Grimes

 

[Judd_Magic]

Shut up you, stop telling people my team!

This is what I'm going. Did have Watson in place of Cotchin, but downgrading Watson allowed me to make my backs/forwards look a bit better.

Hah!

I did the same thing in downgrading Watson to Cotchin too but mainly because of the ASADA crap.

Forward line is very strong with B.Kennedy at F6.

Backline is probably the weakest area in my team though as I'm not going with Mitchell (too expensive for me) but instead undepriced defenders in Hurn, Grimes, Swallow.

Hoping it all pays off.

 

[longytap]

Watson & K.Simpson

vs

Pendlebury & Grimes

Watson & K.Simpson

 

[Burzum]

Enright vs Simpson vs Hanley

 

[stevebbb]

Enright vs Simpson vs Hanley

Hanley!

 

[kangaroos3]

Watson & K.Simpson

vs

Pendlebury & Grimes

Watson and K. Simpson for me

 

[kangaroos3]

I'm tossing up between Pyke, Ryder and Lobbe.

Was set on Ryder but now Lobbe is looking better and better each day. Threw Pyke in because he is around the same price and could be a good pick.

Thoughts?